- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes error-conditioned neural solvers, which pair a predictor network that gives an initial PDE solution with a recurrent corrector that refines it. At each step the corrector inputs the current prediction together with its PDE residual field and outputs an update. Both networks are trained jointly with a reconstruction loss on few unrolled iterates without a residual loss. At inference the corrector runs until the residual plateaus. Ablations show that the gain comes from conditioning on the residual rather than from extra iterations, and that conditioning on the residual works better than conditioning on the physics-loss gradient.
Critical strengths
- The idea is very simple yet general, despite being already exploited.
- The evaluation covers a large series of PDE, which is rich and demanding.
- The ablation is informative.
Critical weaknesses
- Prior work and novelty.
- The paper leaves out its closest prior work: Le Boudec et al. (2025). That work already proposes a learned "neural solver" for parametric PDEs. A network takes a physics-error signal (the gradient of the PDE residual loss) together with the PDE parameters and forcing/boundary terms, and outputs an iterative correction. The update is applied with a fixed step size, the iterations are unrolled for a few steps during training, the model is supervised only on reconstruction error against ground-truth solutions, and an FNO is used as the backbone. The work is motivated by the ill-conditioning of the physics loss, and it is evaluated on Helmholtz, Poisson and Darcy, among other problems. ENS follows the same template. The main differences are that it conditions on the residual field rather than , works directly in field space rather than on basis coefficients, and adds a learned predictor for initialization.
- Three claims in the paper therefore need to be revised. The first is that ENS is "the first Neural Solver to receive the residual as a direct input" (Tab. 1). The second is that Neural Solvers are "a new class of methods" (Sec. 4). The third is that existing hybrid methods all use the residual as an optimization target. Le Boudec et al. train on reconstruction loss alone, so the residual-reconstruction gap of Prop. 1 does not explain any weakness in their method, and the taxonomy in Tab. 1 has no category that fits it. The residual-versus-gradient conditioning ablation is in effect a comparison against this prior design. It should be presented as such with credit, rather than as an internal design choice. I ask the authors to cite and discuss this work, to state their contribution relative to it and ideally to include it as a baseline on the shared Helmholtz, Poisson and Darcy settings.
- No comparison to classical solvers or PINNs. ENS is presented as a solver, yet the paper never compares it with classical solvers or PINNs at matched accuracy. Le Boudec et al. (2025) compare their learned solver against SGD, Adam and L-BFGS on the same discretization, and against several physics-informed baselines (PINNs, PPINNs, P2INNs, PI-DeepONet, PINO). ENS has nothing equivalent. Newton's method is shown only diverging from a noisy initialization (Fig. 4), even though the authors use it to generate their nonlinear Helmholtz data. PINNs appear only as a residual curve in Fig. 4. On NS and Kolmogorov flow, the speed-up is measured only against the high-fidelity data solver, with no accuracy-matched classical baseline.
- For each setting, including the shifted ones, the number of steps and the step size are tuned on held-out samples from the target distribution. It is unclear whether the baselines got comparable tuning.
References:
- Le Boudec et al. (2025), Learning a Neural Solver for Parametric PDE to Enhance Physics-Informed Methods, ICLR 2025
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses.