- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper is somehow hard to follow. Under my understanding, this paper proposes two new metrics that can investigate the topological response. The two metrics are DMIS and RD based on latent representations.
Critical strengths
- This problem is novel. Except errors, this paper notices the change in topology. This is a new perspective.
- The experiments are comprehensive from multiple perspecgtives.
Critical weaknesses
- This paper exhibits extensive traces of AI related content. Including paper writing and figure generation. The paper is really hard to follow. For example, "which measure representation responsiveness and normalized post-intervention error increase", I cannot understand these sentences without the help of GPT. The figure is generated by AI.
- In my understanding, the coordination in Fig1.c is the main contribution. However, this seems to be an theoretical contribtuion. What're the thresholds of this coordination? Is this thresholds effecient for other tasks?
- The metrics are based on latent representations. How to prove these representations are continous and robust? Will the affect of noise or drift?
- In my opponion, papers in this field is to propose some good metrics to divide different data, just like a regression or PCA. However, the data comes from controlled synthetic dynamics. Authors need to use naturalistic data to validate.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.