- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies negative transfer in cross-city spatio-temporal forecasting and asks what information should actually be transferred when source and target cities differ substantially. It proposes CauCrossNet, which decomposes representations into a relatively stable branch and an environment-specific branch . CauKD learns the transferable representation through consistency regularization and MMD-based alignment, CauCL performs invariant-conditioned target augmentation and curriculum learning, and RAFusion controls source contribution according to representation mismatch and predictive uncertainty. The evaluation covers multiple transfer directions, few-shot adaptation, temporal shifts, cross-region OOD transfer, and longer forecasting horizons. The paper explicitly frames its contribution as predictive invariant transfer rather than causal identification.
Critical strengths
The paper correctly points out that reducing source-target discrepancy does not necessarily imply that the aligned information is transferable, since source-specific correlations may still induce negative transfer. The method performs well not only under standard transfer, but also under few-shot, cross-region OOD, temporal-shift, and long-horizon settings. For example, on PeMS03→PeMS08, the average MAE decreases from 17.55 for the strongest baseline D2MHyper to 14.64 for CauCrossNet. This makes the empirical result more convincing than a gain limited to a single benchmark setting.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The experiments mainly compare against earlier cross-city transfer methods such as DASTNet, DAGN, CCL, D2MHyper, MTPB, and ST-GFSL, while recent models such as OpenCity, UrbanDiT, UniFlow, UrbanFM, and FactoST-v2 are not systematically discussed or evaluated. The paper currently discusses PLM-CUP as a recent complementary method, but the broader positioning against recent spatio-temporal foundation or generalization models remains limited. Although some of these methods may use different data formats or adaptation protocols and therefore may not admit a direct numerical comparison, the paper should clearly explain these incompatibilities and evaluate those that can be adapted to the graph-based sensor setting. Without this, it is difficult to assess the current empirical competitiveness and novelty of CauCrossNet relative to recent cross-city spatio-temporal modeling.
W2. The roles of and are induced by the training objectives, but the paper does not directly quantify whether is indeed more stable across environments than , nor whether RAFusion weights systematically track actual source usefulness or negative-transfer risk. The authors themselves acknowledge that there is no direct quantitative vs role-identification test and that RAFusion is not independently evaluated as a calibrated uncertainty mechanism. Thus, the evidence is stronger for “the full pipeline works” than for the proposed mechanistic interpretation of why it works.
[1] Li et al., Open Spatio-Temporal Foundation Models for Traffic Prediction, ACM TIST, 2025.
[2] Yuan et al., UrbanDiT: A Foundation Model for Open-World Urban Spatio-Temporal Learning, ICLR, 2025.
[3] Yuan et al., UniFlow: A Foundation Model for Unified Urban Spatio-Temporal Flow Prediction, IEEE TMC, 2026.
[4] Chen et al., UrbanFM: Scaling Urban Spatio-Temporal Foundation Models, KDD, 2026.
[5] Zhong et al., Learning to Factorize and Adapt: A Versatile Approach Toward Universal Spatio-Temporal Foundation Models, 2026.
Questions for authors
Q1. Could the authors provide a more systematic comparison or positioning against recent methods such as OpenCity, UrbanDiT, UniFlow, UrbanFM, and FactoST-v2? For methods that cannot be directly compared, please clarify whether the incompatibility comes from the data representation, forecasting protocol, or adaptation setting.
Q2. Could the authors provide more direct diagnostics of the roles of and , and of the behavior of the RAFusion gate? For example, comparing the two branches in terms of cross-city or workday/non-workday discrepancy, their standalone predictive utility, or showing how source weights change with increasing mismatch would help establish that the proposed mechanism behaves as intended.
Request for Review Leadership Attention to the Completed Experimental Responses Before the Discussion Deadline
Dear Program Chairs and Area Chairs,
We sincerely appreciate your efforts in coordinating a rigorous and constructive review process for our submission, What Transfers Across Cities? Invariant Representation Learning for Robust Spatio-Temporal Forecasting (Paper 16000).
As the discussion deadline approaches, we respectfully request your attention to the substantial additional experiments and technical responses submitted during the rebuttal period, particularly those addressing the remaining concerns of Reviewers ujnG and fZJV.
First, we substantially expanded the forecasting evaluation. We evaluated five contemporary methods across four cross-city transfer directions, covering 48 forecasting comparisons. CauCrossNet achieves 36 strictly best results and one jointly best result, including leading results across all 24 comparisons in the two traffic-flow transfer directions.
Second, we directly addressed Reviewer ujnG's concerns about large-scale forecasting and baseline reliability. Our additional experiments include real-world LargeST forecasting in both GBA→SD and SD→GBA directions, as well as three-seed evaluation on the 2,409-sensor Orange County network in TraffiDent. Furthermore, we traced the duplicated VAR/GBRT values to Table 3 of a published Knowledge-Based Systems paper and provided independent rerun results for the affected configurations. The complete numerical results and experimental explanations have been presented in our latest responses.
Third, we provided two dedicated technical replies to Reviewer fZJV's follow-up questions. These responses include three-seed stable/specific representation diagnostics, equal-capacity predictive probes, a mathematical explanation of the near-zero routing weights, and controlled comparisons between learned and fixed source-admission coefficients. We explicitly explain the fixed-0.5 result and distinguish source-benefit ordering from fusion-weight calibration.
Additionally, nine matched alignment experiments directly compare stable-only alignment, full-representation alignment, and the no-MMD configuration using the same backbone.
We are grateful that Reviewer Lcf6 explicitly acknowledged that the additional experiments improved their overall assessment and indicated an increase in rating.
Meanwhile, the other two reviewers' current ratings remain at 2. Since their latest questions have motivated further substantial experimental work and detailed responses, we respectfully request that the review leadership consider these new materials and encourage a final technical reassessment of the outstanding concerns before the discussion closes.
We would particularly appreciate your guidance on whether any specific scientific questions still require clarification. We remain fully available to respond promptly and provide precise explanations.
Our aim is to ensure that the final assessment reflects the complete scientific record, including the original submission, the expanded experimental evaluation, and the detailed exchanges during rebuttal.
Thank you again for your time, careful consideration, and commitment to a comprehensive evaluation of our work.
Best regards,
The Authors