acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

TWINWORLD: Contrast-Consistent Causal Response-Surface Learning for Reality–Belief Counterfactuals

Abstract

Reliable counterfactual modeling requires distinguishing changes in the physical world from changes in an agent's belief about that world. Under partial observability, the same behavioral response can arise from different underlying causes, making conventional intervention-based evaluation insufficient to identify whether behavior changes are driven by physical conditions, beliefs, or their interaction. We formulate this challenge as a causal response-surface learning problem and introduce a paired factorial intervention framework that independently manipulates physical state and initial belief across four counterfactual worlds, . This design identifies three interpretable causal contrasts: the physical main effect, the belief main effect, and their interaction.Building on this formulation, we develop TWINWORLD, a contrast-consistent response-surface estimator that jointly recovers physical openness, belief openness, and target relevance, and reconstructs the four potential-response cells through a shared structured decoder with a bounded residual. The resulting factorization couples latent-state prediction with intervention algebra, providing an explicit inductive bias for counterfactual consistency rather than treating intervention conditions as unrelated outcomes. We further characterize the identifiability of belief from behavioral evidence, showing that belief-independent actions provide no information about the hidden belief state, whereas repeated observations can improve recoverability under persistent beliefs and conditional independence.We evaluate the framework using controlled interventions and semi-synthetic traffic environments with map and motion-history evidence. The experiments examine route-response estimation, latent-state recovery, intervention contrasts, and negative controls, demonstrating that temporal evidence supports hidden-state recovery and that contrast-consistent structure improves counterfactual response estimation. Overall, TWINWORLD provides an operational causal framework for separating reality from belief and for learning structured counterfactual response surfaces when latent beliefs mediate observed behavior.

Primary area:
causal reasoning
Keywords:
Causal Inference, Counterfactual Learning, Causal Representation Learning, Treatment Effect Estimation, Response Surface Learning, Latent Belief

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.25 over 4 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_ti6ZOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes TWINWORLD, a causal response-surface learning framework that aims to distinguish the effects of physical conditions and agents' beliefs on route-selection behavior under partial observability.

Critical strengths

NA

Critical weaknesses

Please see the section below for specific questions and concerns.

Questions for authors

page 10

The empirical evidence probes this structure at multiple levels. TWINWORLD reaches route ... ... 7 CONCLUSION

The manuscript appears to exceed the initial submission page limit. According to the official Author Guidelines, the main text must not exceed nine pages at the time of submission, and submissions exceeding this limit are subject to desk rejection. However, in the submitted PDF, Section 6 (Discussion) and Section 7 (Conclusion) extend onto page 10, before the reproducibility statement and references. I recommend that the Area Chair verify this apparent formatting violation and determine whether the manuscript is eligible for desk rejection under the conference guidelines.

Beyond this issue, the manuscript falls short of the quality and rigor expected of a competitive ICLR submission. The methodological novelty is insufficiently established, and the empirical evaluation relies heavily on simplified synthetic settings, raising concerns about the generalizability and significance of the findings. Overall, the work resembles a preliminary technical or project report rather than a mature research contribution suitable for a top-tier machine learning conference.

My specific concerns are detailed below:

  1. The proposed causal response surface appears to be largely predetermined by the benchmark's Boolean intervention rule. Could the authors clarify what fundamentally new causal inference problem TWINWORLD solves? How does the proposed method compare with a simpler relevance-prediction baseline using the same known intervention logic?

The base response is a soft-OR factorization.

  1. The proposed decoder appears to encode the assumed data-generation mechanism directly, rather than discovering a general causal relationship from observations. Could the authors explain why the soft-OR factorization is necessary and under what assumptions it remains valid?

Proposition 1 (response-surface error bound).

  1. Could the authors clarify which theoretical results are genuinely novel? More importantly, what conditions guarantee the identifiability of latent beliefs when belief states are not programmatically assigned or directly supervised, as would be the case in real-world applications?

We generate connected weighted (3×33 \times 3) lattices with 12 undirected edge slots.

  1. The experimental validation relies predominantly on highly simplified synthetic road networks with deterministic shortest-path behavior. Could the authors provide more realistic evaluations using larger road networks, heterogeneous driver policies, dynamically evolving beliefs, or closed-loop traffic simulation?

4.1 Additionally, could they clearly distinguish the newly executed controlled experiments from the archived map-grounded and sequence results, which were not independently rerun for this study?

TWINWORLD obtains ... , while direct-struct obtains ...

  1. Could the authors explain why the proposed factorization should be preferred when simpler alternatives achieve better performance on the primary causal contrast metric?
Reviewer_px2LOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes TWINWORLD to predict counterfactual responses under interventions on physical and belief states. The model jointly estimates physical openness, belief openness, and target relevance, then feeds these estimates into a factorized decoder to predict responses under four intervention combinations. The authors claim that this approach explicitly characterizes the main and interaction effects of the interventions while improving counterfactual response estimation.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper's writing is disorganized and difficult to follow. For example, the introduction contains no citations and does not discuss relevant prior research or its limitations, leaving the research gap and the novelty of the proposed approach unclear. Likewise, the paper does not clearly describe model variants such as Hard-gate and AND-gate in Table 1, making the corresponding results and conclusions difficult to interpret. Similar problems with writing and exposition recur elsewhere in the manuscript; the examples above are not exhaustive. In my assessment, the paper does not meet the basic standard of writing required for acceptance at ICLR.

  2. The main text exceeds the nine-page limit by approximately half a page. I am unsure why this has not triggered desk rejection, but if the policy permits revisions, I recommend that the authors correct it immediately.

Questions for authors

Q1. Could you improve the paper's writing and exposition?

Q2. Could you provide a version that complies with the page limit?

Reviewer_RAseOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the effect of changing the state of an environment and changing the agent's belief about the state of the environment. Importantly, the authors look at these two separately, motivated by the fact that an observed behaviour can have different causes, so only looking at the behaviour and predicting it will not be informative about what change caused the behaviour.

Looking at these two scenarios (changing the state vs. changing the agent's belief about the state) independently gives us four different combinations: changing the reality, changing the belief, changing both, and changing neither. The authors argue that this can give us further insight into the combined effect of these changes compared to when they are changed separately.

Given this, the paper proposes TWINWORLD, whose goal is to predict exactly these four outcomes. The main contribution is to do this in a way that follows a common structure for each condition rather than learning each one separately.

There are experiments on synthetic road networks that test this approach, and the results show improved prediction of route changes, but with some mixed evidence regarding the estimate of intervention effects.

Critical strengths

1- The problem formulation of the paper is quite interesting and well-motivated. Separately changing the state and the agent's belief about the state is a reasonable way of distinguishing between different causes.

2- Proposition 1 in the paper nicely connects the contributions of the actual state, the belief state, and relevance predictions. This is further seen in experiments where it is shown that better outcome predictions do not necessarily translate into better effect estimation, which I think is a useful result.

Critical weaknesses

1- A key weakness of the paper I believe, is in eq. (3), under which every situation follows one of the following patterns: either changing the state alone, belief alone, or both will always change the outcome, or none of it changes the outcome. As a result, the true state and the belief seem to have equal individual effects in this framework. This masks situations in which the true state and the belief have different effects, or if they interact in other ways.

2- It seeme like eqs. (16) and (17) use the model's raw scores before they are converted intro probabilities, but the answers they are compared with are differences in outcome. This I believe might make the training rule discourage the predictions that the model is actually supposed to make. I am not sure if the implementation of the authors actually compares probabilities, in which case this well may be an error in the equations rather than the method itself.

3- Fig. 3 and eq. (24) seem to disagree about which model performs better. In fig. 3, we see a negative difference between TWINWORLD's error minus the direct model's error for the original test conditions, while in eq. (24) the TWINWORLD error is reported to be higher than the direct model's error. The same thing happens again when the road costs change. If these results concern different experiments, the authors need to clarify this.

4- In table 1, it seems like the hard-gate version has almost the same outcome prediction score as TWINWORLD, and a lower error when estimating intervention effects. This makes the advanateg of the method over simpler methods not super clear.

Questions for authors

1- Can you please clarify if (16)-(17) describe teh training rule actually used in the expeirment? (See W2 above)

2- Why are the true effects in (24) not equal? (3) should make the effects of changing the true state and the belief equal in every situation, but we are not seeing that in (24).

3- Why do numerical results and figures disagree? (See W3 above)

Reviewer_X2JLOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This study estimates separately whether a road is actually passable and whether a driver believes it is passable, and predicts whether the driver will change their route. The authors made four conditions by combining these two factors in a synthetic road network and evaluated a model that also considers whether the target road affects the route.

While there has been improvement in predicting route changes, the model sometimes performs worse than comparative methods when estimating the effects of changing conditions. Because their experiments are based on synthetic simulation data, it is unclear whether the model can accurately estimate actual driver perceptions, and the scope of its contribution needs to be clarified.

Critical strengths

The authors artificially generate road closures and driver perceptions separately, using the same road network and the same origin and destination. Because this experimental design provides clear ground truth for each condition, the authors can compare how well each model handles the differences between the two in a controlled environment.

The authors separately estimates of road conditions and driver perceptions, and the effects of changing conditions. This evaluation protocol enables to diversely compare models, rather than judging model performance based on a single metric.

The authors standardized model scale and training conditions for key comparisons and also examined scenarios where certain components were removed.

Critical weaknesses

The authors generate the dataset using artificial rules. Even if the proposed model can estimate recognition under these rules, the authors have not verified its correspondence with actual driver perception, so its effectiveness in real-world scenarios cannot be confirmed.

The authors define that the route changes if there is an actual closure or if the road is recognized as closed. Although the proposed model also uses this rule, the authors have not verified cases where the rule does not hold, and its scope of applicability is unclear.

A previous study [1] explains behavior by distinguishing between reality and the individual’s perception. The authors have not sufficiently clarified the similarities and differences between the design of this study.

[1] Baker, C., Saxe, R., & Tenenbaum, J.(2011)Bayesian Theory of Mind: Modeling Joint Belief-Desire Attribution

Questions for authors

Answer a weakness

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.