- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a precipitation nowcasting framework combining multi-scale truncated residual diffusion with horizon-targeted reforecasting. A deterministic backbone first produces coarse forecasts, which are refined through fragment-wise residual diffusion guided by optical-flow information and multi-scale spatiotemporal features extracted using a Mamba encoder. A separate latent diffusion model with a Cuboid Transformer then regenerates the final five forecast frames to improve late-horizon predictions. The authors also introduce the Southern Anhui Mountain Radar Dataset and evaluate the framework on this dataset alongside SEVIR and CIKM. The reported results outperform the compared baselines across the evaluated metrics, with particularly notable improvements at high-intensity thresholds.
Critical strengths
- Targeted refinement of late-horizon forecasts. The proposed reforecasting module explicitly focuses on terminal frames, providing an intuitive approach to improving predictions at longer lead times.
- Evaluation across multiple datasets and baselines. Experiments cover SEVIR, CIKM, and the newly constructed dataset, with comparisons against deterministic, probabilistic, and hybrid methods. The reported improvements are particularly noticeable at high-intensity thresholds.
- Additional data for mountainous precipitation scenarios. The Southern Anhui Mountain Radar Dataset extends the evaluation to a practically relevant setting. Component ablations and supplementary analyses also provide empirical evidence for the benefits of motion cues, contextual guidance, and terminal-frame refinement.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficiently articulated challenges and motivation in the abstract. The abstract lists precipitation evolution, performance degradation with increasing lead time, and complex mountainous terrain as key challenges, but does not clearly explain the specific limitations of existing methods or how the proposed components address them. In particular, the connection between the proposed architecture and terrain-related forecasting difficulties remains unclear. Constructing and evaluating a mountainous-region dataset alone does not establish terrain-specific adaptation.
-
Insufficient justification for the combination of modules. The framework combines a deterministic backbone, multi-scale spatiotemporal guidance, truncated residual diffusion, and horizon-targeted reforecasting. Although component ablations are provided, they do not fully establish why this particular combination is necessary or how the modules complement one another. Comparisons with simpler alternatives and configurations under comparable computational budgets would help distinguish architectural benefits from gains attributable to additional capacity or refinement steps.
-
Incomplete disclosure of computational complexity. The parameter counts and FLOPs in Appendix B require more detailed accounting. The authors should specify the profiling tool, input resolution, sequence lengths, sampling schedules, and whether FLOPs represent a single denoising step or the complete forecasting pipeline. A component-wise breakdown should include the backbone, context encoder, residual diffusion, latent reforecasting, and VAE computation. Both total and trainable parameter counts should be reported, together with inference latency under consistent hardware and evaluation settings.
-
Insufficient guidance for interpreting Figure 2. The intended takeaway from Figure 2 is difficult to identify from the current presentation. The caption and accompanying discussion should explain which visual differences readers should examine and how these observations support the claimed improvements. Clearer references to forecast lead times, annotations of relevant regions, and enlarged views where appropriate would make the comparison more informative.
-
Unclear provenance and comparability of baseline results. All 130 baseline entries on SEVIR and CIKM in Table 1 exactly match those reported in Table 2 of DuoCast. The manuscript should explicitly distinguish results taken from prior publications from independently reproduced results. For reused results, the authors should establish that data splits, preprocessing, forecasting horizons, and metric implementations are consistent with their own evaluation. Backbone variants and inference settings should also be specified, particularly for DiffCast and CasCast. Reusing published results is acceptable, but their provenance and comparability must be transparent.
Questions for authors
-
Provenance and comparability of baseline results. All 130 baseline entries on SEVIR and CIKM in Table 1 exactly match those reported in Table 2 of DuoCast. Were these results taken from that publication or independently reproduced? If reused, can the authors confirm that their own evaluation follows identical data splits, preprocessing, forecasting horizons, and metric implementations? Please also specify the backbone variants used for DiffCast and CasCast.
-
Accounting for computational complexity. Does the reported 0.32 TFLOPs cover the complete forecasting pipeline, including all temporal fragments, repeated residual denoising, 50-step latent reforecasting, and VAE encoding and decoding? What input dimensions, batch size, and profiling tool were used? Can the authors provide a component-wise breakdown of FLOPs and parameters, reporting frozen VAE parameters separately from the stated 94.40M trainable parameters?
-
Necessity of the combined architecture and terminal reforecasting. What evidence establishes that multi-scale guidance, truncated residual diffusion, and terminal reforecasting provide complementary benefits beyond increased model capacity or additional refinement? In particular, what supports refining exactly the final five frames, and do the available comparisons distinguish the benefit of targeting late horizons from that of simply allocating additional computation?
-
Dataset construction and evidence for mountainous-terrain performance. How is the 8:1:1 split of the Southern Anhui dataset constructed—by individual sequence, precipitation event, or chronological period? Can overlapping sequences or observations from the same event occur across partitions? Additionally, what evidence links the reported improvements specifically to terrain-related forecasting difficulties, rather than demonstrating stronger overall performance on another regional dataset?