- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents a precipitation nowcasting framework based on Quanternion Fourier Neural Operator, to address the challenges in precipitation nowcasting such as: standard spectral representations fail to explicitly disentangle scale and orientation, the mismatch between the pixel-wise optimisation and discrete boundaries problem exist in other precipitation nowcasting models. Experiments on several benchmarks demonstrate superior performance of QFSNet to other baselines.
Critical strengths
- The problem setting is timely. The proposed method seems to have strong performance compare to the baselines and the paper compares against a diverse range of baselines.
- Experiments are extensive, covering several different precipitation benchmarks for evaluation of the proposed framework under different conditions
- The results show promise of the methodology (efficient and strong performance) and is generally aligned with the motivation.
Critical weaknesses
- In previous literature ([1]), a similar differentiable CSI-based loss has previously been proposed for precipitation nowcasting (Ko et al., 2022). There is few difference in the incorporation of false-alarm weighting but the formulation follows a similar objective. With this being said, first the authors should cite relevant literatures in section 4.5. Second, the loss seems to contribute the performance substantially. And the improvements of adding this loss are larger than those observed in the later ablations on proposed architecture. So here my question is: to what extent do the reported improvements come from the proposed framework instead of the choice of using this loss? I would need some clarifications on this. I would suggest the authors adding a new ablation, adding this loss to baselines such as SImVP to see how much it will affect its performance.
- The similar decomposition of large-scale and fine-scale features for precipitation nowcasting model has been explored [2]. WADEPre is a new work but it is very similar to the division between the Large-scale LL and Fine-scale QFT branches in QFSNet. I would encourage the authors to add it as another baseline and depending on the results clarify what additional benefits QFSNet’s decomposition provide over WADEPre.
- Other weaknesses see questions.
[1] Ko, J., Lee, K., Hwang, H., Oh, S.G., Son, S.W. and Shin, K., 2022. Effective training strategies for deep-learning-based precipitation nowcasting and estimation. Computers & Geosciences, 161, p.105072.
[2] Liu, B., Zhang, H., Yuan, H., Wang, D., Li, Y., Chen, F. and Wu, H., 2026. WADEPre: A Wavelet-based Decomposition Model for Extreme Precipitation Nowcasting with Multi-Scale Learning. arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.02096.
Questions for authors
- Since CRPS reduces to MAE (up to normalisation) for deterministic point forecasts, why are we adding CRPS as one of the metrics here? Also why the ranking of CRPS seems to be inconsistent with that of MAE if they are equivalent for deterministic forecast? The author should clarify how CRPS is computed for deterministic and generative baselines.
- Could authors clarify why “w/o LL branch” has such bad result and “Fine only” is much better? Because to me the only difference is the phase branches, does this show some interactions between two branches?
- The "w/o fine spectral branch" variant in table 2 and the "LL only (w/o fine & phase)" variant in table 9, are they equivalent to each other?
- Could authors provide baseline details for all experiments?
5 comments
2. Relationship to WADEPre and additional comparison — W2
We will cite WADEPre [2] and discuss its relationship to QFSNet. Both methods use wavelet decomposition to organize precipitation structure across scales. WADEPre predicts approximation and detail coefficients using separate networks and combines the reconstructed fields through a spatial Refiner. QFSNet’s Fine branch processes the complete wavelet–quaternion field, including LL and the directional detail components, through two-sided QFT and Hamilton operators. Its dedicated LL pathway complements this joint predictor, while local phase transport and global/local PhaseConsistency provide additional transport and fusion operations. The distinction therefore lies in how the decomposed information is jointly predicted and fused.
We additionally trained WADEPre on Shanghai using its official implementation and native training objective. Table R2 reports this reproduction together with the QFSNet results.
Table R2. Additional Shanghai comparison with WADEPre.
| Model | CSI-M ↑ | CSI-35 ↑ | CSI-40 ↑ | POD ↑ | SSIM ↑ | MAE ↓ | Parameters ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| WADEPre | 0.3937 | 0.3541 | 0.2374 | 0.5042 | 0.7238 | 2.0616 | 36,526,226 |
| QFSNet | 0.4252 | 0.3882 | 0.2869 | 0.6020 | 0.8040 | 1.7280 | 185,433 |
In these runs, QFSNet has higher CSI-M by 0.0315 and CSI-40 by 0.0495, with MAE lower by 0.3336. It also uses 185,433 parameters, approximately 0.51% of WADEPre.
Within QFSNet, Table 9 provides a controlled backbone comparison: replacing the spectral backbone with a wavelet-domain convolutional backbone, while retaining the other modules and training objective, changes CSI-M from 0.4252 to 0.4146 and POD from 0.6020 to 0.5836. This supports the contribution of the spectral backbone beyond wavelet decomposition itself. The comparison evaluates the backbone as a whole; its individual quaternion and Fourier components are not separately isolated by this control.
We have expanded the related-work discussion in Sec. 2.2 to explain the differences from WADEPre, added WADEPre to the baseline list in Sec. 5.1, and extended Table 1 with its Shanghai, Meteo, and CIKM results and parameter count of 36.53M, with unavailable entries marked as “–”. Please refer to the resubmitted manuscript for details.
3. CRPS reporting and its equivalence to MAE — Q1
The inconsistent CRPS values in the original tables were transcription errors. For the point forecasts evaluated here, the correct CRPS values equal normalized MAE and therefore yield the same ranking within each dataset. We agree that reporting CRPS is redundant in this setting and have removed it from the revised manuscript’s result tables and the corresponding metric descriptions and comparisons.
We have revised the original evaluation to retain MAE for absolute reconstruction error and removed the redundant CRPS metric from Sec. 5.1, Appendix D.2, the result tables, and the associated comparisons. Please refer to the resubmitted manuscript for details.
4. Fine-only, Fine + Phase, and the conditional contribution of LL — Q2
The Fine branch processes all wavelet components, including LL, and can therefore learn a complete forecast. Its strong standalone performance does not require a dedicated LL pathway. The difference between Fine-only and Fine + Phase involves their interaction with the shared PhaseConsistency (PC) module, as shown by the additional ablation in Table R3.
Table R3. Branch configurations with and without PhaseConsistency on Shanghai.
| Branch configuration | With PC: CSI-M ↑ | POD ↑ | MAE ↓ | Without PC: CSI-M ↑ | POD ↑ | MAE ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fine only | 0.4178 | 0.5893 | 1.7873 | 0.4099 | 0.5686 | 1.7588 |
| Fine + LL | 0.4173 | 0.5891 | 1.7866 | 0.4101 | 0.5622 | 1.7489 |
| Fine + Phase | 0.2507 | 0.3217 | 2.3355 | 0.4086 | 0.5677 | 1.7664 |
| Fine + LL + Phase | 0.4252 | 0.6020 | 1.7280 | 0.4094 | 0.5627 | 1.7598 |
Without PC, Fine-only and Fine + Phase achieve CSI-M values of 0.4099 and 0.4086, compared with 0.4178 and 0.2507 when PC is retained. The large degradation therefore occurs when Phase and PC are jointly enabled without LL.
Phase contributes signed transport increments relative to the last observation, while PC processes the entire fused prediction using historical information. Its shared consistency correction acts on the combined Fine and transport contributions. The LL pathway supplies separately parameterized coarse-intensity adjustments before this processing.
The results establish a conditional contribution of LL when Phase and PC are jointly enabled. With both present, adding LL raises CSI-M from 0.2507 to 0.4252; without PC, the corresponding change is only from 0.4086 to 0.4094. Likewise, with LL and PC retained, adding Phase improves CSI-M from 0.4173 to 0.4252. These controls support their coordinated use within the complete predictor and clarify why branch contributions depend on the fusion configuration. We will incorporate this analysis into the revised ablation discussion.
We have revised the ablation discussion in Sec. 5.3 from describing the LL branch as “irreplaceable” to explaining its configuration-dependent contribution, and added the with/without-PC branch controls and their analysis in Appendix E.1. The revised analysis identifies the pronounced Fine + Phase degradation as occurring when Phase and PC are jointly enabled without LL. Please refer to the resubmitted manuscript for details.
5. “w/o Fine” and “LL only” are distinct ablations — Q3
The “w/o fine spectral branch” variant retains both LL and Phase, whereas “LL only” removes both Fine and Phase. The other shared modules and the training/evaluation settings are retained. Their identical reported values resulted from a transcription error in the “w/o Fine” row of Table 2.
Table R4. Corrected comparison of the two ablations on Shanghai.
| Configuration | CSI-M ↑ | CSI-35 ↑ | CSI-40 ↑ | POD ↑ | SSIM ↑ | CRPS ↓ | MAE ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| w/o Fine: LL + Phase | 0.3827 | 0.3408 | 0.2455 | 0.5461 | 0.7871 | 0.0215 | 1.9357 |
| LL only | 0.3832 | 0.3428 | 0.2478 | 0.5553 | 0.7867 | 0.0218 | 1.9607 |
The corrected results distinguish the two configurations: retaining Phase alongside LL improves MAE and slightly improves SSIM, with slightly lower event-detection scores. We will correct Table 2 and align the associated discussion with these results.
We have corrected the “w/o fine spectral branch” row in Table 2: CSI-M/CSI-35/CSI-40/POD/SSIM/MAE have been changed from 0.3832/0.3428/0.2478/0.5553/0.7867/1.9607 to 0.3827/0.3408/0.2455/0.5461/0.7871/1.9357. We have also added an explicit distinction in Appendix E.1 that this variant retains LL and Phase, whereas LL-only removes both Fine and Phase. Please refer to the resubmitted manuscript for details.
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the practical motivation, empirical coverage, and efficiency of QFSNet. We address the relationship to prior CSI-based training and wavelet decomposition, provide the additional baseline and branch controls, and clarify the metric and implementation details below.
1. Prior CSI-based objectives and attribution to the architecture — W1
We thank the reviewer for highlighting Ko et al. (2022) [1], which we will cite in Sec. 4.5. Their nowcasting objective constructs differentiable hit, miss, and false-alarm counts from predicted class probabilities and optimizes the average soft CSI for Rain (the union of Light and Heavy) and Heavy, with equal coefficients for misses and false alarms.
QFSNet supervises continuous radar-intensity forecasts. Its event term evaluates threshold exceedances across the selected intensity thresholds and forecast lead times, while MAE directly supervises the magnitudes of the same predictions. In Eq. (15), αFA controls the false-alarm contribution relative to misses within the overlap score, whereas λe balances this event term against intensity reconstruction in L=LMAE+λeLevent. These two coefficients separately control the relative weighting of event-detection errors and the balance between event overlap and continuous-intensity accuracy. We will clarify these differences in Sec. 4.5.
To examine the contribution of the event term across predictors, we additionally trained SimVP and AlphaPre with this term on Shanghai. Table R1 includes both their original and event-augmented results.
Table R1. Original and event-augmented training results on Shanghai.
The event term improves SimVP’s CSI-M by 0.0125 and POD by 0.0326. AlphaPre shows a small POD increase of 0.0084 but lower CSI scores. QFSNet gains 0.1122 in CSI-M and 0.2455 in POD. The corresponding MAE increases are 0.2859 for SimVP, 0.4161 for AlphaPre, and 0.0402 for QFSNet. Thus, the event objective makes a substantial contribution to QFSNet, while its benefit varies across predictors. Under the tested settings, QFSNet achieves larger detection gains with a smaller reconstruction penalty.
The architectural contribution is also measurable with the objective fixed. Under MAE-plus-event training, a core predictor retaining the three branches, additive fusion, and spatial readout, but excluding PC and all calibration/Normal–Tangent refinement, achieves CSI-M/POD/MAE of 0.4023/0.5341/1.7724. The complete model achieves 0.4252/0.6020/1.7280 under the same objective. These controls establish additional gains from the consistency and calibration/refinement stages. We will present the results as contributions from both the architecture and its event-aware training.
We have added the comparison with Ko et al. (2022) to Sec. 2.2 and supplemented the original loss-weight analysis with event-loss transfer experiments on SimVP and AlphaPre and clean-core versus complete-model controls under both MAE-only and MAE-plus-event training in Appendix E.3. These additions clarify the contributions of the architecture and the training objective under the evaluated settings. Please refer to the resubmitted manuscript for details.