- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies precipitation nowcasting from radar sequences. DAWN-Cast decomposes features into wavelet scale families, assigns each family an independent Frequency Adaptive Temporal (FAT) block combining a Gabor mapping and an MLP, and reconstructs forecasts with spectral and local spatial refinement. The authors report competitive results across several datasets and investigate the design through ablations, zero-shot transfer, and adaptation of a small parameter subset.
Critical strengths
Separating scale-dependent temporal evolution from subsequent spatial refinement has a clear task-specific motivation. The scale-persistence analysis includes a pure-advection control and states limitations of fine-scale resolution and lifetime estimation, making the rationale concrete.
SEVIR has an explicit chronological split, and zero-shot transfer using SEVIR-selected models provides useful evidence. The nearly parameter-matched shared-FAT comparison and small-parameter adaptation results are also meaningful, although their interpretation remains limited by the concerns below.
Critical weaknesses
1.Independent temporal operators are not isolated by the ablation. The main ablation changes both operator sharing and wavelet depth, while the existing parameter-matched comparison also leaves depth settings unclear. Please support the benefits of independent operators with a comparison at the same decomposition depth, or narrow the attribution.
2.The physical intensity mapping needs clarification. The paper and code do not clearly reconcile their intensity ranges, leaving high-intensity thresholds and target-domain normalization difficult to verify. The discrepancy alone does not prove an incorrect conversion; please explain the pixel-to-physical-intensity mapping used in the actual experiments and align the descriptions.
Questions for authors
Q1 : What evidence isolates the contribution of independent temporal operators?
Q2 : How were stored pixels mapped to physical intensity in the reported experiments?
Q3 : Do the performance advantages over the main competing methods remain stable across repeated training runs?
3 comments
Response to reviewer 1Psh.
We hope our responses and the revised paper address the reviewer’s concerns. If any point remains unclear, or if further experiments would help, we would be glad to provide them as much as possible. If the reviewer finds the concerns resolved, we would be grateful if they would consider updating their score. Thankyou.
Response to reviewer 1Psh.
As the author–reviewer discussion closes in a few hours, we wanted to check whether our responses address all the reviewer's concerns, in particular the same-depth comparison of shared and separate FAT blocks, the intensity mapping in App. B, and the multi-seed results. If any point remains unclear, we would be glad to clarify it before the deadline. If the reviewer finds the concerns resolved, we would be grateful if they would consider updating their score.
Response to reviewer 1Psh.
W1/Q1. Independent temporal operators...the attribution. / What evidence...temporal operators?
We agree. The Shared FAT of the original Table 2 used J = 1, and the parameter-matched zero-shot variant (59.51M) was the same model, so both mixed depth with sharing. We now share one FAT block (Gabor and MLP weights and λ) across all families at the model's own depth (J = 2), with the same parameter count as ours to two decimals (59.54M SEVIR, 15.32M CIKM).
At equal depth, ours(separate FAT variant) wins over (shared FAT variant) every in-domain metric and, over five CIKM seeds, leads 0.3358 ± 0.0049 vs. 0.3260 ± 0.0120 (2.9%, Table 14) on cikm (refer Table 14 of the paper).
Depth settings
J is selected per dataset (SEVIR 2, MeteoNet 1, Shanghai 3, CIKM 2, App. M). Retraining MeteoNet at other depths changes CSI-M by at most 0.003:
Paper updated: Tables 2, 4 and 14 (J = 2 variant, seeds), App. F (J = 1 variant), App. Q (depth), Secs. 5.1 and 5.3.1.
W2/Q2. The physical intensity...align the descriptions. / How were...reported experiments?
All models use the data loaders and evaluator from the AlphaPre [2] release (DiffCast [3] protocol). App. B of the paper has been updated to provide a clearer explanation of the dataset details. Stored frames are divided by a fixed constant; outputs and ground truth are rescaled before scoring based on the protocol as shown below:
The SEVIR thresholds follow from SEVIR's VIL encoding (Veillette et al., 2020). MeteoNet is stored in dBZ, so its thresholds are physical reflectivity values. Shanghai and CIKM are stored as 8-bit radar echo images (0–255) and are not converted to dBZ: their thresholds apply on the protocol's scale, identically for every model.
Target domains
In zero-shot transfer, each dataset uses its own normalization constant from the table, with no statistics from target data, and is scored on its own scale and thresholds. SEVIR (VIL) and the targets (radar echo) are not physically matched, so Sec. 5.3.1 describes transfer of normalized dynamics, not physical calibration.
Paper updated: App. B states each dataset's stored range, physical units, normalization constant, evaluation scale, and thresholds.
Q3. Do the performance...repeated training runs?
Yes. We repeated DAWN-Cast and the strongest competitor over seeds on two datasets: EarthFormer (FACL) on CIKM and AlphaPre (FACL) on Shanghai.
Refer to Tables 14 and 30 of the paper for the tables below.
Paper updated: App. F and App. O (Tables 14 and 30).
References
[1] Veillette, Mark, Siddharth Samsi, and Chris Mattioli. "Sevir: A storm event imagery dataset for deep learning applications in radar and satellite meteorology." Advances in neural information processing systems 33 (2020): 22009-22019.
[2] AlphaPre (Lin et al., 2025)
[3] DiffCast (Yu et al., 2024)