- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
NucleCast is a two-stage radar-nowcasting framework combining a frozen deterministic forecaster with a conditional flow-matching refiner. The refiner models pixel-space residuals, uses an anchor-guided compound-Poisson source, and combines ensemble members through a probability-matched mean for deterministic verification. Experiments on SEVIR and ARSO report improvements over the anchor and analyze intense precipitation, precipitation births, numerical integration, and longer-horizon forecasting.
Critical strengths
The complete system offers a practical inference configuration. Reported results show improvements over the anchor at low inference cost, with a smaller model than the compared FlowCast configuration; these deployment results have practical value.
Refinement benefits are supported on two radar datasets. Intense-precipitation forecasts improve, and the birth-recovery analysis measures newly introduced false components, making both benefits and costs visible.
Critical weaknesses
1.The structured source's independent benefit is not established. The source comparison is limited to one example, and its training setup is unclear, so it does not establish a general benefit. Please provide a fair aggregate source comparison or narrow the claim.
2.Probabilistic forecasting needs direct validation. The reported CRPS evaluates a Gaussian fitted to the members, while improvements after aggregation do not establish ensemble calibration. The claimed non-Gaussian or multimodal forecast quality therefore still lacks direct evidence. Please provide direct ensemble diagnostics using existing predictions.
Questions for authors
Q1 : What controlled evidence supports the structured source's independent benefit?
Q2 : What direct ensemble diagnostics support its probabilistic forecast quality?
Q3 : What cost evidence supports the training-cost advantage and residual refinement's efficiency contribution?
Q4 : Does feedback outperform output-only refinement under the same protocol?
We thank the reviewer for the constructive questions. Each one led to a new experiment, and in two cases to a narrower claim: on what the structured source improves (Q1) and on the ensemble (Q2).
Q1. Controlled evidence for the structured source's independent benefit.
We trained an identical twin of the released refiner, also 50 epochs, in which only the source changes to Gaussian noise. We compare the two at matched epochs on SEVIR Cohort B, paired over storm timestamps (Section 4.3.1, Figure 4; exact values in Appendix Table 12).
Following the reviewer's suggestion, we narrowed the claim: the source improves the prediction of extreme cores, not general skill. Figure 4 also shows where general skill comes from: the residual target (+0.0105 CSI-M) and the anchor clip (+0.0044). Appendix A.9 reports the proposal-rate variants.
Q2. Direct ensemble diagnostics.
Section 4.3.2 and Appendix A.10 now report fair ensemble CRPS, rank histograms, spread–skill and reliability/Brier, for NucleCast and for FlowCast's members.
We therefore describe NucleCast's ensemble as a low-cost probabilistic product with dispersion comparable to FlowCast's, not a calibrated one, and we removed the "multimodal" claim. Table 2 now reports the fair ensemble CRPS instead of the Gaussian-fit estimator the reviewer pointed out.
Q3. Cost evidence: training cost and the efficiency contribution of residual refinement.
Appendix A.12 now lists the training cost of every model as run (Table 16) and end-to-end inference latency (Table 17).
Q4. Does feedback outperform output-only refinement under the same protocol?
Yes. Appendix A.8 now reports both NucleCast modes, feedback and output-only refinement, under the same 12→36-lead protocol on the same 96 events, with the released checkpoint and paired tests.
We are grateful for these questions; the paper's claims are now tied to direct evidence.