acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

SNAP-Diffusion: From Unpaired Snapshots to Anisotropic Diffusion Operators

Abstract

Unpaired population snapshots reveal marginal evolution but do not determine an unrestricted stochastic generator. We introduce SNAP-Diffusion, which recovers a structured anisotropic diffusion field by converting snapshot statistics and occupation quadrature into a finite weak Fokker–Planck system over a uniformly elliptic coefficient class. Restricted coercivity of the weak design yields identifiability within this class and deterministic stability to perturbations in both responses and design. Under fixed Fick drift, coefficient-recovery error further controls held-out density error and associated distributional and observable errors. In controlled two-dimensional transport, SNAP estimates one operator from short-horizon training releases and freezes it for downstream prediction. The recovered anisotropic operator improves prediction from unseen releases, remains accurate beyond the identification horizon, and transfers to first-passage functionals without refitting. A controlled FX experiment applies the same principle to state-dependent local correlation recovered from joint snapshots. On held-out tenors and contracts, SNAP reduces mean pricing error by and percent relative to constant- and time-dependent-correlation models and by percent relative to same-class forward calibration. Together, the results connect weak snapshot identification of structured diffusion fields to reusable operators for downstream prediction.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
Inverse Learning, Anisotropic Diffusion

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_WcaYOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This papers calculate diffusion fields via snapshots. The challenges is that the estimation of diffusion field can be ill-posed (same snapshots may refer to different diffusion fields.) To handle this, the papers restrict diffusion fields to a certain family and estimate the low-dimension parameters. The paper formulate a way to avoid direct estimation of density (or its derivative) and this make calculation tractable and efficient.

Critical strengths

The formulation in weak snapshot system is new to me.

Critical weaknesses

See questions.

Questions for authors

Thanks the authors for their dedicated work. I have some questions and hope author can help understand the paper.

  1. I see that you restrict the diffusion family to serveral base diffusion formulation. How about the coverage of this formulation? Can it handle all diffusion modeling?
  2. How many test functions needed to accurately model the parameters. How to design the test functions? It there a way to set a universal test function for all diffusion settings, or we need to build specifc test functions for one setting.
1 comment

We thank the reviewer for providing some insightful questions.

Response to Q1: Scope and Coverage of the Diffusion Formulation

1. Scope of the formulation. SNAP-Diffusion is formulated for continuous-state Itô SDEs and their associated Fokker–Planck equations in Section 3.1, Eqs. (1)–(3), accommodating anisotropic, spatially varying, and time-dependent diffusion tensors. The recovered operator can also be incorporated into reverse-time SDE and probability-flow ODE formulations in Appendix C.5, Eqs. (47)–(52).

2. Coverage limitations. The general stochastic formulation must be distinguished from the recoverable coefficient class. SNAP represents the unknown diffusion tensor through an affine SPD parameterization in Section 3.1, Eqs. (4)–(5) and Assumption 3.1:

Dθ(x,t)=Dref(x,t)+∑k=1qθkBk(x,t).D_\theta(x,t)=D_{\mathrm{ref}}(x,t)+\sum_{k=1}^{q}\theta_k B_k(x,t).

The framework supports different admissible tensor bases, but exact recovery requires sufficient representation coverage and identifiability. Discrete-state diffusion models and arbitrary coefficient fields outside the prescribed class are not covered by the current recovery guarantees.

These findings align with Proposition 3.2 (non-identifiability), Assumption 3.3 and Theorem 3.4 (restricted coercivity and stability), and Corollary 3.5 (empirical design perturbations).

Conclusion. SNAP provides a general weak-form inverse framework for structured continuous-state diffusion models, not a dataset- or basis-specific method. Its recovery accuracy depends on basis coverage, identifiability, and finite-sample stability, rather than universal expressivity.

Response to Q2: Number, Design, and Universality of Test Functions

1. How many test functions?

No fixed number guarantees accurate recovery. With SS releases, RR observation intervals, LL test functions, and qq unknown parameters, the weak design has at most SRLSRL equations. Hence, SRL≥qSRL\ge q is necessary for full-column-rank identification but insufficient for stable recovery (Proposition 3.2; Appendix B.3).

The governing condition is restricted coercivity (Assumption 3.3):

$

∥Ah∥W≥κ∥h∥G,∥θ^−θ⋆∥G≤2∥η∥Wκ,\|Ah\|_W\ge\kappa\|h\|_G, \qquad \|\widehat\theta-\theta^\star\|_G \le\frac{2\|\eta\|_W}{\kappa},

$

where the second inequality follows from Theorem 3.4 under its stated assumptions. Thus, accuracy depends on both the information captured by the test functions and finite-sample observation noise.

2. How should test functions be designed?

The weak design in Section 3.2, Eqs. (7), (10) determines which tensor directions are observable. For the fixed-Fick-drift formulation in Eq.10,

$\int_{I_r} \mathbb{E}{p_t^{(s)}}\left[ \nabla\cdot\left(B_k\nabla\phi\ell\right) \right]dt ]$

Here, s,ℓ,rs, \ell, r, and kk index the release, test function, observation interval, and tensor basis, respectively. For fixed Itô drift, Eq. (7) instead uses (Bk:∇2ϕℓB_k:\nabla^2\phi_\ell). We follow four principles:

  • Boundary compatibility: satisfy weak-form regularity and boundary conditions (Assumption 3.1; Appendix B.1).
  • Directional coverage: choose frequencies, directions, centers, and scales that distinguish candidate tensor responses (Eqs. (7), (10)).
  • Identifiability: inspect rank⁡(A)\operatorname{rank}(A) and its kernel; augment informative tests or releases when necessary (Proposition 3.2; Appendix B.3–B.4).
  • Finite-sample stability: evaluate restricted coercivity, singular values, and empirical moment noise (Theorem 3.4; Corollary 3.5).

Naive test Func takes the first (L) functions from a fixed Fourier candidate library. For L=8L=8, the selected based on the requirements are cos⁡(2π(xi−xi+1))\cos(2\pi(x_i-x_{i+1})) for i∈2,7,12,15,19i\in{2,7,12,15,19} with sin⁡(2πxj)\sin(2\pi x_j) for j∈5,10,17j\in{5,10,17} .

Experimental validation. We consider a 20-dimensional diffusion process(d=20) and unknown diffusion coefficient dimensions (q=20) , with amount (L=16) of test functions, the weak system contains (16*L) equations and 4 initial releases and 4 observation intervals to conduct 50 recoveries.

Test designLLEquationsRank(A)Condition Num(A)Median error
Naive81285/20—Not identify
Naive162569/20—Not identify
Naive64102417/20—Not identify
Selected812820/208.68143.64%
Selected1625620/207.71118.06%
Selected641,02420/202.7670.61%

(1) Test-function design matters more than amounts. All naive tests remain rank-deficient and do not uniquely identify the 20 parameters. But test functions selected by principles maintain full-rank.

(2) More test functions can reduce error but not guarantee error under 10%. L=8/16L=8 /16 selected test functions yield a median error of 143.64%/118.06%. Increasing the selected set to 64 tests reduces the median error to 70.61%, but both configurations can't achieve 50 recoveries within the 10% error threshold.

Reviewer_k6WTOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper tackles the problem of recovering stochastic dynamics from unpaired population snapshots. In this context, there is no single sample that we can track to recover the dynamics, so estimating the parameters is harder. To do so, the paper proposes using the weak fokker planck equation to define a least squares regression problem which when solved can recover an approximation to the stochastic dynamics. Furthermore, the paper provides theoretical guarantees under which the dynamics can be recovered. Experimental evidence supports the advantage of their algorithm when compared to existing approaches.

Critical strengths
  • The paper tackles a well defined mathematical problem, that is likely to occur in many scientific fields
  • The empirical evidence suggests that the method is very competitive and outperforms existing methods by wide margins
  • The rigour is high, and although sometimes hard to read, the paper properly introduces all its components
Critical weaknesses

The main issue with this paper is presentation:

  • Although I am not an expert in this particular problem, I can't help but believe that the paper must be missing many important previous works as it only references 15 works.
  • The paper doesn't do a great job at motivating the problem, for instance by stating some scientific problems where it appears
  • The introduction to the paper is a bit messy, skipping over how things were motivated, although after some thinking it is easy to understand, it could benefit from better writing. Although the page limit could be a problem.
Questions for authors
  • How does the method scale with dimension? It seems like most examples are performed in 2D, so a natural question is how could the model be applied in higher dimensions
  • In the case where rank(A)≤LR<qrank(A) \leq LR < q we have non-identifiability, but using other test functions could help address this. How should the test functions be chosen to alleviate this issue?
2 comments

Response Q1: Scalability Beyond Two Dimensions

SNAP-Diffusion is not intrinsically restricted to 2D. Its weak formulation (Section 3.2, Eqs. (6)–(11)) estimates expectations directly from particles, avoiding exponential-size density grids. We both conduct experiments on the dimensions of state-space dimension (d)(d) and unknown diffusion coefficients (q)(q).

Experimental setup. We consider high-dimensional diffusion model with state-space dimensions (d)(d) and unknown diffusion coefficient dimensions (q)(q) , fix the amount (L=16L=16) of test functions, the weak system contains (16∗L)(16*L) equations and 4 initial releases and 4 observation intervals, and use �0��0� particles to conduct 50 recovery instances per model.

Table 1. Scaling with state dimension and parameter complexity

ModeddqqRank(A)Median error≤10% Pass
Fixed (q=3)333/32.51%50/50
Fixed (q=3)533/32.89%50/50
Fixed (q=3)1033/32.61%50/50
Fixed (q=3)2033/32.44%50/50
Increasing (q=d)333/32.51%50/50
Increasing (q=d)555/516.07%5/50
Increasing (q=d)101010/1041.48%0/50
Increasing (q=d)202020/20118.06%0/50
Fixed (d=20) Increasing (q)20320/206.43%45/50
Fixed (d=20) Increasing (q)20520/2015.84%10/50
Fixed (d=20) Increasing (q)201020/2043.39%0/50
Fixed (d=20) Increasing (q)202020/20118.06%0/50

Median error is the relative error in the unknown diffusion perturbation. The recovery pass threshold is ≤10%. Rank(A)Rank(A) denotes the nominal weak-design rank.

Fixed �3��3�: With 3 unknown coefficients, constant diffusion models maintain median errors ≤ 3% as �4��4� increases from 3 to 20, with 50/50 recoveries at each dimension.

Increasing �5��5�: In the spatially varying ring family, increasing �6��6� from 3 to 20 raises median error from 9.67% to 118.06%, despite full-column-rank designs. This indicates that recovery error increases substantially with parameter complexity �7��7�.

Fixed (d)(d) Increasing (q)(q) With the high dimensions of diffusion model fixed at �8��8�, increasing coefficients �9��9� from 3 to 20 raises median error from 6.43% to 118.06%, but the mean error with varying �10��10� .

Conclusion: The results suggest that, within the evaluated settings, high-dimensional scalability is to extend the diffusion process (d=3,5,10,20)(d=3,5,10,20) while keeping the parameter dimension (q)(q) fixed.

Response Q2: Non-identifiability and test-function selection

Non-identifiability. Proposition 3.2 establishes that (rank⁡(A)<q\operatorname{rank}(A)<q) implies non-identifiability for interior feasible parameters: distinct diffusion coefficients can produce identical weak observations.

Test-function selection. Naive uses the first (LL) functions from a fixed Fourier library, while Selected applies deterministic greedy selection based on rank and singular values. For (L=8L=8), the selected functions are \begin{aligned} &\cos(2\pi(x_i-x_{i+1})), &&i\in{2,7,12,15,19},
&\sin(2\pi x_j), &&j\in{5,10,17}. \end{aligned}

Here, LL denotes the number of scalar test functions; each cosine or sine function counts separately. With 4 training releases and 4 time intervals per release, the total number of weak equations is 16L16L.

Why test-function selection helps?.

For a constant symmetric diffusion basis (Bk)(B_k), Fourier tests satisfy Bk:∇2ϕv(x)=−(2π)2(v⊤Bkv)ϕv(x).B_k:\nabla^2\phi_v(x)=-(2\pi)^2(v^\top B_kv)\phi_v(x). Thus, different frequency directions probe different diffusion-basis responses. Selecting complementary frequencies can increase rank(A)rank(A), reducing the null-space dimension q−rank(A)q-{rank}(A) responsible for non-identifiability.

Experimental validation. We consider a extremely complex scene: high-dimensional diffusion model with dimensions(d=20) and state-space dimensions (q=20)(q=20) unknown diffusion coefficients, with amount (L=16)(L=16) of test functions, the weak system contains (16∗L)(16*L) equations and 4 initial releases and 4 observation intervals to conduct 50 recoveries.

Test designLLEquationsRank(A)Unidentifiable directionsCondition Num(A)Median error
Naive81285/2015—Not identify
Naive162569/2011—Not identify
Naive64102417/203—Not identify
Selected812820/2008.68143.64%
Selected1625620/2007.71118.06%
Selected641,02420/2002.7670.61%

Conclusion. Naive test functions leave 3–15 parameter directions unidentifiable, even with 1,024 weak equations remain deficient rank 17/20. In contrast, selected tests resolve structural non-identifiability with zero unidentifiable directions and full rank 20/20.

Thanks for answering my questions. I believe this has helped me strengthen my understanding of the methods capabilities. I keep my score towards acceptance!

Reviewer_o39kOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes SNAP-Diffusion, a framework for recovering structured anisotropic diffusion operators from unpaired population snapshots. By introducing a finite-dimensional parameterization of the diffusion tensor and constructing weak Fokker–Planck constraints, the method reduces coefficient estimation to a constrained least-squares problem.

The authors provide theoretical results on identifiability, estimation stability, and downstream prediction error. Experiments evaluate the recovered operators on unseen initial distributions, longer prediction horizons, first-passage functionals, and simulated FX local-correlation estimation.

Critical strengths
  1. A coherent and practically motivated framework.

The paper addresses a meaningful inverse problem and presents a clear methodology for recovering structured diffusion operators without reconstructing individual trajectories or repeatedly simulating candidate dynamics during estimation.

  1. Comprehensive validation and a consistent research narrative.

The theoretical analysis establishes conditions for identifiability and stability, while the experiments evaluate whether the recovered operators generalize to unseen initial conditions and downstream prediction tasks. The inclusion of strong baselines and negative controls further strengthens the empirical evaluation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited generality of the experimental settings.

The main experiments rely on controlled synthetic systems with known drift conventions and predefined low-dimensional coefficient families. Although these settings provide clear validation, the applicability to more complex or unknown diffusion structures remains uncertain. The reported degradation under basis misspecification highlights this limitation.

  1. Unclear methodological novelty relative to existing weak-form estimation approaches.

The central estimator builds on weak Fokker–Planck constraints and finite-dimensional linear parameter estimation. The paper would benefit from a clearer explanation of which methodological components are fundamentally new compared with established weak-form approaches to stochastic system identification.

Questions for authors

Q1. How could the proposed framework be extended to settings where the diffusion coefficient class is not known in advance? Is there a principled strategy for selecting or adapting the basis functions?

Q2. Could the authors further clarify the main methodological advances over previous weak Fokker–Planck estimation approaches, particularly when the unknown coefficients admit a finite-dimensional linear parameterization?

1 comment

We thank the reviewer for these constructive questions.

Response to Q1: Principled Basis Selection for Unknown Diffusion Classes

The affine diffusion representation in Section 3.1, Eqs. (4)–(5), accommodates spatially varying, time-dependent, and off-diagonal tensor bases. Under fixed Fick drift, the weak system in Section 3.2, Eqs. (10)–(12), remains linear in the unknown coefficients, enabling principled dictionary expansion and selection.

Principled selection strategy. We extend the original framework through six steps:

  1. Physical admissibility: Construct an enlarged dictionary of candidate diffusion-tensor bases under the affine representation and SPD constraints in Eqs.(4)–(5).
  2. Identifiability diagnostics: Assess weak-design rank, parameter-direction coverage, and restricted coercivity in Proposition 3.2 and Assumption 3.3.
  3. Cross-validated sparsity: Select the L1 penalty ($\lambda$) through four-fold leave-one-training-release-out cross-validation.
  4. Support identification: Retain candidate directions whose normalized coefficient magnitudes exceed (10−310^{-3}), while preserving the three original bases.
  5. SPD-constrained refitting: Re-estimate the selected coefficients using the original constrained quadratic estimator in Eq. (12).
  6. Independent predictive validation: Evaluate the frozen recovered operator on four genuinely unseen releases, excluded from model selection and fitting.

Experimental validation. To assess these principles empirically, we evaluate a extended version 12-basis dictionary containing the three original bases, one relevant diffusion direction, and eight irrelevant candidate tensor bases serving as distractors. The experiment uses a 2D periodic Fick diffusion system, nonzero misspecification levels ρ∈{0.1,0.2}\rho\in\{0.1,0.2\}, and 50 paired instances per level.

ρ\rhoOriginal 3Full 12Sparse 12Selected refit
0.110.66%12.61%4.71%4.42%
0.220.82%8.79%6.61%6.66%
Mean relative full-tensor error

Compared with the original 3-basis, Cross-validated sparsity (Sparse 12) and SPD-constrained refitting(Selected refit) substantially reduce the mean tensor recovery error under basis misspecification.

This provides a practical extension of SNAP-Diffusion toward partially unknown coefficient structures through candidate-basis expansion and sparse selection. Then SPD-constrained refitting produces the final physically admissible estimation.

Extension beyond selecting dictionaries. weak-form sparse identification methods such as symbolic regression, or learned neural basis functions may offer ways to construct additional candidate directions. However, integrating such approaches would require separate analysis of identifiability, stability, and SPD admissibility, it will be discussed in Appendix.

Response to Q2: Methodological Advances over Previous Weak Fokker–Planck

Our contribution is not weak FP estimation itself, but a structured inverse framework for finite-dimensional linear parameterizations of unknown coefficients:

1. General inverse framework

Existing methods: WSINDy(arXiv:2005.04339), WSINDy-PDE(arXiv:2007.02848), mean-field WSINDy(arXiv:2110.07756), and Self-Test Loss(arXiv:2412.03506) provide regression, sparse identification, and convex operator-learning, but don't specifically propose a general inverse framework.

SNAP-diffusion: advances in establishing a general weak-form inverse framework beyond specific datasets. Its affine parameterization in Eqs. (4)–(5), SPD constraints in Assumption 3.1, and weak-form inversion accommodate different diffusion-tensor bases, state dimensions, and snapshot designs. Theorem 3.4 guarantees unknown coefficient stable under restricted coercivity in Assumption 3.3. And the framework remains amenable to systematic extension and continued methodological refinement.

2. End-to-End Deterministic Error Propagation

Existing methods: Mean-field WSINDy (arxiv:2110.07756) provides convergence analysis for weak-form sparse identification; WSINDy consistency (arxiv:2211.16000) establishes consistency for error convergence.

Ours advances in an explicit stability Error Propagation Chain in Section 3.4:

Snapshot error (A^,y^)→(\hat{A},\hat{y}) \rightarrow Parameter error θ^→\hat{\theta} \rightarrow Diffusion error Dθ^→D_{\hat{\theta}} \rightarrow prediction error p^t→\hat{p}_t \rightarrow downstream.

Corollary 3.5 bounds parameter errors against snapshot noise and quadrature-induced design perturbations via the coercivity margin (κ−ϵA)(\kappa - \epsilon_A). By tracing how inaccuracies in the unknown coefficients θ\theta propagate through the estimated diffusion operator to downstream predictions, we extend the error analysis from coefficient recovery to predictive reliability.

We further clarify these distinctions in Introduction & Related Work.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.