- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This papers calculate diffusion fields via snapshots. The challenges is that the estimation of diffusion field can be ill-posed (same snapshots may refer to different diffusion fields.) To handle this, the papers restrict diffusion fields to a certain family and estimate the low-dimension parameters. The paper formulate a way to avoid direct estimation of density (or its derivative) and this make calculation tractable and efficient.
Critical strengths
The formulation in weak snapshot system is new to me.
Critical weaknesses
See questions.
Questions for authors
Thanks the authors for their dedicated work. I have some questions and hope author can help understand the paper.
- I see that you restrict the diffusion family to serveral base diffusion formulation. How about the coverage of this formulation? Can it handle all diffusion modeling?
- How many test functions needed to accurately model the parameters. How to design the test functions? It there a way to set a universal test function for all diffusion settings, or we need to build specifc test functions for one setting.
We thank the reviewer for providing some insightful questions.
Response to Q1: Scope and Coverage of the Diffusion Formulation
1. Scope of the formulation. SNAP-Diffusion is formulated for continuous-state Itô SDEs and their associated Fokker–Planck equations in Section 3.1, Eqs. (1)–(3), accommodating anisotropic, spatially varying, and time-dependent diffusion tensors. The recovered operator can also be incorporated into reverse-time SDE and probability-flow ODE formulations in Appendix C.5, Eqs. (47)–(52).
2. Coverage limitations. The general stochastic formulation must be distinguished from the recoverable coefficient class. SNAP represents the unknown diffusion tensor through an affine SPD parameterization in Section 3.1, Eqs. (4)–(5) and Assumption 3.1:
Dθ(x,t)=Dref(x,t)+∑k=1qθkBk(x,t).
The framework supports different admissible tensor bases, but exact recovery requires sufficient representation coverage and identifiability. Discrete-state diffusion models and arbitrary coefficient fields outside the prescribed class are not covered by the current recovery guarantees.
These findings align with Proposition 3.2 (non-identifiability), Assumption 3.3 and Theorem 3.4 (restricted coercivity and stability), and Corollary 3.5 (empirical design perturbations).
Conclusion. SNAP provides a general weak-form inverse framework for structured continuous-state diffusion models, not a dataset- or basis-specific method. Its recovery accuracy depends on basis coverage, identifiability, and finite-sample stability, rather than universal expressivity.
Response to Q2: Number, Design, and Universality of Test Functions
1. How many test functions?
No fixed number guarantees accurate recovery. With S releases, R observation intervals, L test functions, and q unknown parameters, the weak design has at most SRL equations. Hence, SRL≥q is necessary for full-column-rank identification but insufficient for stable recovery (Proposition 3.2; Appendix B.3).
The governing condition is restricted coercivity (Assumption 3.3):
$
∥Ah∥W≥κ∥h∥G,∥θ−θ⋆∥G≤κ2∥η∥W,$
where the second inequality follows from Theorem 3.4 under its stated assumptions. Thus, accuracy depends on both the information captured by the test functions and finite-sample observation noise.
2. How should test functions be designed?
The weak design in Section 3.2, Eqs. (7), (10) determines which tensor directions are observable. For the fixed-Fick-drift formulation in Eq.10,
$\int_{I_r} \mathbb{E}{p_t^{(s)}}\left[ \nabla\cdot\left(B_k\nabla\phi\ell\right) \right]dt ]$
Here, s,ℓ,r, and k index the release, test function, observation interval, and tensor basis, respectively. For fixed Itô drift, Eq. (7) instead uses (Bk:∇2ϕℓ). We follow four principles:
Naive test Func takes the first (L) functions from a fixed Fourier candidate library. For L=8, the selected based on the requirements are cos(2π(xi−xi+1)) for i∈2,7,12,15,19 with sin(2πxj) for j∈5,10,17 .
Experimental validation. We consider a 20-dimensional diffusion process(d=20) and unknown diffusion coefficient dimensions (q=20) , with amount (L=16) of test functions, the weak system contains (16*L) equations and 4 initial releases and 4 observation intervals to conduct 50 recoveries.
(1) Test-function design matters more than amounts. All naive tests remain rank-deficient and do not uniquely identify the 20 parameters. But test functions selected by principles maintain full-rank.
(2) More test functions can reduce error but not guarantee error under 10%. L=8/16 selected test functions yield a median error of 143.64%/118.06%. Increasing the selected set to 64 tests reduces the median error to 70.61%, but both configurations can't achieve 50 recoveries within the 10% error threshold.