- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies the problem of learning stochastic dynamics from noisy position-only trajectories, where velocities are unobserved. The authors argue that conventional two-stage approaches, which first reconstruct latent velocities and then estimate drift and diffusion, systematically underestimate diffusion because posterior-mean reconstruction discards uncertainty.
To address this issue, they propose Observation-Marginalized Weak Generator with endpoint correction (OMWG-C), which incorporates posterior velocity-increment variance obtained from a Gaussian smoother into weak-moment diffusion estimation. The method is evaluated on synthetic stochastic systems, where it improves diffusion recovery relative to a posterior-mean baseline, although an established Stochastic Force Inference (SFI) method generally achieves better joint parameter recovery. The authors also introduce a cross-sampling-rate audit to evaluate the stability of estimated diffusion coefficients when ground truth is unavailable. Experiments on cell-migration and ocean-drifter trajectories demonstrate that predictive performance and sampling-rate stability can differ substantially.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
1. Insufficient scientific clarity and motivation. The manuscript is difficult to follow, particularly in the first three sections. The introduction lacks sufficient context and references to relevant literature, introduces mathematical quantities without adequate explanation, and reports numerical results without clearly explaining their significance. The theoretical development in Section 3 also lacks sufficient motivation, making it difficult to understand why the proposed equations are necessary and what they contribute. These issues substantially undermine the accessibility and scientific clarity of the paper.
2. Limited methodological novelty and insufficient evidence of advantages over established methods. The central theoretical contribution relies largely on standard conditional variance identities, and the paper does not sufficiently explain how the proposed correction advances existing approaches to stochastic system identification. Although OMWG-C improves upon several baselines, the established SFI parametric method achieves lower joint recovery error in 51 out of 72 matched synthetic experiments. Furthermore, the ablation study shows that a simpler single-lag correction already accounts for much of the improvement achieved by the full method. These results raise concerns about whether the additional methodological complexity is justified and whether the paper offers a sufficiently substantial contribution for ICLR.
Overall assessment. In my view, the manuscript requires major revision, particularly in its scientific presentation, motivation, and positioning relative to existing methods. The current version does not communicate a sufficiently clear and compelling methodological contribution, while the experimental evidence does not convincingly establish its advantages over strong existing approaches. Given these substantial concerns, I recommend rejection in its current form.
Questions for authors
See critical weaknesses.