- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper uses a conditional generative model with data and physics corrections to reconstruct high-resolution states from coarse observations and combines these states with numerical integration to recover phase-field dynamics.
Critical strengths
-
The framework separates learned reconstruction from numerical propagation. This makes the role of each part clear and helps explain how reconstruction errors affect the predicted trajectory.
-
The paper evaluates both field accuracy and energy behavior. It also reports mixed results from the component comparisons and discusses the limitations.
Critical weaknesses
-
My main concern is about how the learned correction is trained and applied. During training, it receives the reference state and a residual calculated from the coarse input. During sampling, it receives the predicted state and a residual calculated from that prediction. The training objective learns the correction through the perturbed input. It does not directly check whether the correction improves a generated state. The paper acknowledges these different inputs but does not clearly show why the correction should remain helpful when the prediction contains errors.
-
My other concern is about the experimental support for the full design. Some simpler configurations give comparable or better field accuracy. The existing comparisons are useful but do not directly show whether the learned correction improves the same predicted states before and after the update. This makes it difficult to separate the effect of the correction itself from differences caused by training.
Questions for authors
-
Why are different state inputs used to train and apply the correction? Please explain how the training objective prepares it to handle imperfect predictions during sampling. Could the authors test a version that uses more consistent inputs during training and sampling?
-
Could the authors apply the correction to the same predicted states and compare reconstruction error and physical consistency before and after the update? Please also separate the effect of the raw residual update from the learned correction. This would help explain when each component is useful and why the full design should be preferred.
If the authors answer these questions well and provide convincing evidence that the correction improves the actual sampling process, I am willing to change my recommendation to acceptance.
5 comments
Response to Reviewer s57q:Regarding whether the correction improves the same predicted states
2. Regarding whether the correction improves the same predicted states
Following your suggestion, we tested no correction, raw residual only, learned M2NO correction only, and both corrections. For the local diagnostic, all four branches act on exactly the same pre-correction prediction from the FULL reference sampling chain. We also evaluated complete sampling chains starting from common noise, distinguishing local update effects from accumulated trajectory effects.
The same-state results reveal complementary but stage-dependent behavior:
- The raw residual update reduces mean coarse-data inconsistency at all 15 sampling steps. It increases mean HR error at the first three steps but decreases it thereafter.
- Adding M2NO improves local energy error during the later sampling steps, orders 6–14. It does not improve mean HR error, coarse-data inconsistency, or vector-field inconsistency relative to raw-only. Complete-chain results using a single fixed checkpoint | Correction branch | Anchor RMSE ↓ | Rollout RMSE ↓ | Mean energy error ↓ | |---|---:|---:|---:| | None | 0.065819701 | 0.062595221 | 0.001400185 | | Raw only | 0.065815809 | 0.062590373 | 0.001398266 | | Learned only | 0.065837212 | 0.062608999 | 0.001397717 | | Full | 0.065833173 | 0.062603994 | 0.001395805 |
The complete-chain evaluation is consistent with this distinction. Raw-only achieves the lowest rollout RMSE, approximately 0.0077% lower than without correction; 17/20 trajectories improve. FULL achieves the lowest mean energy error among the four branches, approximately 0.176% lower than raw-only; adding M2NO improves energy error on 17/20 trajectories. Its rollout RMSE is slightly higher, by approximately 0.0218% relative to raw-only.
An additional three-training-seed evaluation supports the same interpretation: adding M2NO reduces mean energy error by 2.35%, with a 0.186% increase in rollout RMSE. The energy benefit has the same direction across all three seeds.
Three-training-seed aggregate results
| Configuration | Rollout RMSE ↓ | Mean energy error ↓ |
|---|---|---|
| Raw only | 0.06294519 | 0.00144299 |
| Full | 0.06306249 | 0.00140905 |
The same-state diagnostics and complete-chain intervention are reported in Appendix I.3 and Table 20. The three-training-seed aggregate and per-seed correction effects appear in Tables 12 and 13, respectively.
For the remaining questions, please refer to the other responses. Thank you very much.
Response to Reviewer s57q :Regarding when the full configuration should be preferred
The requested experiments clarify the components’ roles: the raw residual provides a small field-accuracy benefit, while M2NO provides an energy-matching refinement. Thus, FULL is useful when reference-energy agreement is an important objective; raw-only is preferable when field RMSE alone determines the choice. Energy agreement here does not imply monotone energy dissipation.
We consider M2NO when agreement with the reference energy is an important objective alongside field accuracy. In our three-seed evaluation, adding M2NO reduces mean energy error by 2.35% with a 0.186% increase in rollout RMSE. Therefore, M2NO is a useful refinement.
The resulting energy–accuracy tradeoff is discussed in Section 4.4 and Appendix H.3, with the corresponding aggregate results in Table 12.
Thank you for prompting these targeted tests. They provide direct evidence about actual correction behavior and a concrete improvement through prediction-input training. We hope this evidence supports a more favorable assessment.
Response to Reviewer s57q :Regarding whether consistent training and sampling inputs improve the correction
Dear Reviewer s57q,
Thank you for your constructive suggestions. We conducted both requested tests: a same-state, four-branch correction experiment and a controlled comparison using more consistent training and sampling inputs. These experiments identify the distinct contributions of the raw and learned corrections and provide evidence that input alignment improves their deployment behavior.
1. Regarding whether consistent training and sampling inputs improve the correction
The difference originates from the inherited training construction: the correction receives the reference HR state and a residual computed from the interpolated coarse input during training, but the predicted clean state and its corresponding residual during sampling.
Although the reconstruction objective uses perturbed inputs, this does not directly train the correction on deployment-time prediction errors. We agree that these two forms of robustness should be distinguished.
To test your suggestion, we fine-tuned the same checkpoint under two conditions with matched optimizer settings, training-sample and timestep sequences, and a budget of 1,000 updates. The original-input condition retains the original construction. The prediction-input condition uses frozen pilot predictions generated from training-set coarse observations as both the correction’s state input and the state used to compute its residual.
Prediction-input fine-tuning improves both rollout RMSE and energy agreement relative to original-input fine-tuning. RMSE decreases by approximately 0.050%, with a paired difference of −3.15 × 10⁻⁵ and a reported 95% interval of [−5.69 × 10⁻⁵, −7.12 × 10⁻⁶]. Mean energy error decreases by approximately 1.39%. The adverse RMSE increment introduced by M2NO decreases by approximately 57.8%.
The last column reports FULL minus raw-only within each model; positive values indicate increased rollout RMSE. This indicates a practical benefit from input alignment, although the evidence comes from a single training seed, the frozen pilot inputs only approximate deployment inputs, and neither fine-tuned model exceeds the unfine-tuned checkpoint in overall field RMSE.
The training and inference inputs are clarified in Section 2.4 (Eqs. 21–22); the matched-budget fine-tuning protocol and results are reported in Appendix I.3 and Table 21.
For the remaining questions, please refer to the other responses. Thank you very much.