- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes Dual-geometry Carrier Atlas Transport (DCAT), a single-reference framework for efficient and consistent text-driven 3D human garment editing. DCAT combines a garment-adaptive dual-geometry carrier, comprising a silhouette-aligned SMPL-X shell and an independent skirt proxy, with UV Atlas Transport and Side-View Feedback to propagate a single reference edit across views, improving editing efficiency and cross-view consistency while maintaining high visual quality.
Critical strengths
- Important task. Existing 3D human garment editing methods update 3D Gaussians through independent per-view diffusion editing, resulting in high computational costs and cross-view inconsistencies. DCAT propagates edited garment appearance across views using a garment-adaptive carrier and a shared UV atlas with side-view feedback.
Critical weaknesses
- Small evaluation scale. The evaluation covers only two human subjects, providing insufficient evidence of generalization across diverse body shapes, poses, and garment types.
- Limited garment-structure coverage. The skirt-specific proxy addresses one type of structural mismatch, but the applicability of the dual-carrier design to other challenging garments, such as capes, open coats, and layered clothing, remains unclear.
Questions for authors
- Figure labels. Please correct the LM/RM definitions in the lower-left corner of Figure 2.
- Evaluation protocol. What reference images are used for PSNR/SSIM/LPIPS in Table 1? Are test views excluded from atlas construction and side-view completion?
- Evaluation scale. Could the authors evaluate beyond two subjects to demonstrate generalization across body shapes, poses, and garment types?
- Garment-structure coverage. Can DCAT handle capes, open coats, and layered clothing without additional proxies? Please provide examples or clarify its limitations.