- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents FACt, a feed-forward framework for animatable clothed human reconstruction from sparse-view images. The method combines deformable feature fusion with an extended LBS formulation based on learned cloth joints. The problem is relevant, and the reported quantitative results are promising.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a meaningful and challenging problem. Feed-forward reconstruction of animatable clothed humans from sparse-view images is practically valuable, particularly for loose garments with complex non-rigid deformations.
The proposed framework is well-structured. The combination of deformable feature fusion and cloth-joint-based deformation provides a coherent approach to integrating image information with structured garment motion modeling.
The experimental results are promising. The method achieves competitive quantitative performance on THuman2.1 and 4D-DRESS while using relatively few network parameters and Gaussian primitives. The paper also includes ablation studies and visualizations to analyze its main components.
Critical weaknesses
-
Fairness and completeness of baseline comparisons. Table 1 compares the proposed method using two input views and 50K Gaussians against LHM-MINI using only one view and 20K Gaussians. This makes it difficult to determine whether the improvements arise from the proposed architecture or the additional input information. Moreover, although LHM++ is included in the efficiency comparison in Table A2, its reconstruction quality is not reported. I suggest providing comparisons under matched input conditions where possible and including LHM++ in the reconstruction evaluation.
-
Limited methodological novelty of extended LBS. The proposed cloth-joint-based extended LBS shares substantial similarities with existing approaches such as GART (CVPR 2024) and ToMiE (ICCV 2025), which also extend skeletal representations to model non-rigid clothing deformation. Although the feed-forward formulation is a potentially valuable distinction, the paper does not sufficiently clarify the technical novelty of its cloth-joint learning mechanism relative to these methods.
-
Insufficient isolation of the contributions of extended LBS. In Table 3, the effects of the cloth template and extended LBS are not fully disentangled. Furthermore, the deformation MLP contributes substantial improvements, raising questions about how much of the final performance gain is attributable to the proposed cloth joints. More controlled ablations, particularly under novel-pose animation, would strengthen the claims regarding the effectiveness of extended LBS.
-
Generalization evaluation and dataset splitting. According to Appendix B.3, the 4D-DRESS dataset is split at the pose-sequence level, with identities and outfits shared between training and testing. While this evaluates generalization to unseen motion sequences, it does not establish generalization to unseen identities or clothing. A subject-disjoint evaluation or a clearer discussion of this limitation would be valuable, especially given the claimed generalizability of the framework.
-
Limited evidence for reconstruction fidelity and alignment robustness. Despite using additional input information compared with LHM-MINI, the proposed method does not consistently show visibly superior reconstruction quality in Fig. 4. The third case exhibits artifacts around the neck and hair, while certain regions in 4D-DRESS appear oversmoothed compared with GHG.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses
6 comments
| Method | #Params | #Gaussians | #Views | THuman2.1 PSNR ↑ | THuman2.1 LPIPS ↓ | THuman2.1 SSIM ↑ | 4D-DRESS PSNR ↑ | 4D-DRESS LPIPS ↓ | 4D-DRESS SSIM ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LHM++ | 459M | 160K | 2 | 19.08 | 0.200 | 0.811 | 17.66 | 0.189 | 0.810 |
| LHM++ (Fine-tuned) | 459M | 160K | 2 | 19.93 | 0.176 | 0.817 | 18.10 | 0.178 | 0.812 |
| Ours | 133M | 50K | 2 | 20.53 | 0.198 | 0.802 | 19.95 | 0.170 | 0.817 |
Thank you for your follow-up and for acknowledging that the additional experiments address much of the concern about baseline fairness and generalization.
To address the remaining training-distribution difference, we fine-tuned LHM++ on the same training split used by FACt and evaluated both methods with two input views. Fine-tuning improves LHM++ on both datasets. FACt retains higher PSNR on THuman2.1 (20.53 vs. 19.93). On the identity-disjoint 4D-DRESS test set, FACt performs better on all three metrics. We will update the comparison and its interpretation accordingly.
For the additional Standard LBS versus Extended LBS temporal comparison, the deformation MLP is disabled in both settings. This comparison therefore measures the effect of extended LBS without an MLP contribution. We agree that, on the 4D-DRESS subset for ablation study, extended LBS alone does not seem to improve reconstruction when the MLP is disabled. The temporal comparison uses the full training data and the same clips as our temporal evaluation. The results show the benefits of extended LBS.
We appreciate again your constructive feedback, which has helped us clarify the evaluation and improve our work.
Regarding LHM++, the fine-tuned results make the comparison more informative. However, I would still like to understand the fine-tuning protocol in more detail, especially which parameters are updated, the optimization settings/training budget, and whether the original LHM++ losses are reproduced. Since the comparison is now used to support the effectiveness of FACt under matched training data, these details are important for assessing fairness.
Regarding extended LBS, I appreciate the clarification that the deformation MLP is disabled in both the Standard-LBS and Extended-LBS temporal comparisons. This shows that extended LBS can provide benefits on the full temporal training setting. However, the gain is still relatively modest, and the earlier ablation on the subset shows almost no improvement when extended LBS is introduced without the MLP. More importantly, the authors also acknowledge that extending the skeleton with clothing joints is established prior work. Therefore, I am still somewhat unclear about the main technical novelty here. Is the key contribution the feed-forward prediction of cloth joints and their pose-dependent motions from sparse-view observations? If so, I suggest making this distinction more explicit in the paper.
Thank you for the additional experiments. The new LHM++ comparison and the identity-disjoint 4D-DRESS evaluation substantially address my concerns regarding baseline fairness and generalization.
I have one additional concern regarding the LHM++ comparison. Although both methods now use two input views, FACt is trained directly on THuman2.1/4D-DRESS, whereas LHM++ is evaluated using its pretrained model without training on these target datasets. Therefore, the comparison still mixes architectural differences with an in-domain training advantage. If possible, I think a more informative comparison would be to fine-tune LHM++ on the same training split, or alternatively evaluate FACt in a comparable cross-dataset/zero-shot setting. Otherwise, this limitation should be made explicit when interpreting the comparison.
I also still have one question regarding the independent contribution of extended LBS. In the new ablation, when the deformation MLP is disabled, adding extended LBS does not improve performance (PSNR 20.08 → 20.04, LPIPS 0.201 → 0.209). For the additional Standard LBS vs. Extended LBS temporal comparison, is the deformation MLP enabled in both settings? If so, the results may suggest a complementary effect between extended LBS and the deformation MLP rather than an independent gain from extended LBS itself.