- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
G-WADE edits the weather appearance of urban 3DGS assets using tail-latent conditioning and trajectory-aware anchor reuse. Generated views supervise appearance-only optimization while the original geometry remains fixed.
Critical strengths
Endpoint anchoring addresses appearance inconsistency when revisiting scene regions, while freezing geometric parameters explicitly preserves the original asset geometry. Table 1 reports the best PSNR and SSIM in both scene settings.
Critical weaknesses
(1) The video baselines use non-fine-tuned models, whereas G-WADE receives domain-specific training. A same-data fine-tuned first-frame baseline, together with separate ablations of tail conditioning and trajectory scheduling under identical geometry constraints, is needed to establish the source of improvement. (2) The paper does not specify the numbers of scenes and training clips, the evaluation-set size, or whether fine-tuning and evaluation use disjoint scenes. Consequently, the breadth of evaluation and generalization to unseen scenes cannot be assessed. (3) PSNR and SSIM compare reconstructed views against independently generated stylized images, but it is unclear whether these targets are shared across methods or generated separately by each method. These scores measure agreement with synthetic targets, rather than independently establishing weather realism; the target-generation protocol and complementary realism evaluation should be provided.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weaknesses. Section 5.2 describes the long-range baseline as independently generated clips, whereas Figure 4 states that both methods autoregressively condition on the previous chunk’s last frame. Which protocol was actually used?
Response to Reviewer B4Lt
We thank the reviewer for the careful methodological critique. The points about baseline fairness and the protocol description are well taken and we have addressed them directly. The new experiments and protocols are in the supplementary.
W1: Baseline fairness and component attribution
We agree the previous video baselines used the non-fine-tuned Cosmos model, which confounds fine-tuning gain with FL/trajectory gain. We have added:
This decomposes the improvement into domain fine-tuning (a to b), tail-latent anchoring (b to c), and trajectory-aware scheduling (c to d), directly answering the source of each improvement.
W2: Dataset and evaluation scale
We report the full statistics in Supplementary Section A:
W3: Reference-image protocol and complementary realism evaluation
We clarify the protocol. In Table 1, PSNR/SSIM reference images are each method's own stylized views at held-out viewpoints (intra-method multi-view consistency). To address the "blurry is easier to fit" concern, we add a shared-reference setting (all methods measured against the same fixed base-Cosmos targets, Supplementary Section I), and we provide an independent perceptual user study on unseen scenes (2AFC on realism, consistency, geometry. See Supplementary Section F). The target-generation protocol (base-Cosmos stylized targets, curation criteria) is fully documented in Supplementary Section A.
Q1: The Sec. 5.2 vs. Fig. 4 protocol contradiction
We thank the reviewer for pointing out this inconsistency. We acknowledge that the description in Section 5.2 was an inadvertent writing error. We have corrected the text in the revised manuscript to make it consistent with Fig. 4. Specifically, both the baseline and our method generate the long sequence autoregressively, conditioning each subsequent generation on the last frame of the previous chunk. This autoregressive protocol is used to evaluate the accumulation of errors during long-range inference.
We believe these additions resolve the reviewer's concerns.