- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents T3HG-Editor, a text-driven 3D human garment editing framework based on SMPL-X priors. It introduces SMPL-X-guided Gaussian initialization, vertex-based cross-view feature consistency, and geometry-aware Gaussian pruning to enable more consistent garment editing in 3D Gaussian representations. The method is evaluated on reconstructed human Gaussian scenes with text-driven garment editing tasks and demonstrates improved editing quality compared with existing approaches, with notable improvements in non-target region preservation and perceptual garment consistency.
Critical strengths
- Leveraging SMPL-X vertex correspondences for cross-view attention is an interesting idea for improving garment consistency.
- The method demonstrates promising editing results, particularly in preserving non-target regions, with supporting component-wise ablations.
Critical weaknesses
Although the paper demonstrates strong preservation of non-target regions, the improvement on the edited garment region itself is relatively limited. The reported metrics show only marginal gains on garment regions, and the current evaluation may not fully demonstrate improved garment fidelity and 3D geometric consistency.
Questions for authors
Could the authors provide more direct evaluations of garment fidelity and 3D consistency, such as garment-specific metrics or cross-view geometric consistency measurements?
3 comments
Geometric consistency evaluation
We thank the reviewer for this valuable suggestion. We agree that more direct evaluations of garment fidelity and cross-view consistency are important. However, in 3DGS editing tasks, ground-truth edited 3D geometry and corresponding depth maps are generally unavailable. Therefore, geometric accuracy metrics that require ground-truth 3D surfaces or depth maps cannot be directly computed. We thus retain PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS, which are also adopted in previous 3DGS editing studies, to ensure a fair comparison with existing methods.
To further address the concern regarding cross-view consistency, we additionally introduce MEt3R [Asim et al., CVPR 2025], a geometry-aware metric for evaluating multi-view consistency. Given a pair of views, MEt3R first employs DUSt3R to estimate dense 3D point maps. These point maps are then used to reproject DINO features, upsampled by FeatUp, into a common view, where bidirectional cosine similarity is computed over the overlapping regions. The final MEt3R score is defined as one minus the average bidirectional feature similarity, with lower scores indicating better cross-view consistency. Importantly, MEt3R does not require ground-truth 3D geometry, depth maps, or known camera poses. This metric has also been adopted to evaluate geometric consistency in 3D Gaussian head avatars in MVCHead [Chharia and De la Torre, CVPR 2026], further supporting its applicability to 3D Gaussian human representations.
We report MEt3R alongside the existing metrics in the target garment region comparison, as shown below.
\hline \text{Method} & \text{PSNR}\uparrow & \text{SSIM}\uparrow & \text{LPIPS}\downarrow & \text{MEt3R}\downarrow \\\\ \hline \text{GaussianEditor} & 19.4225 & 0.5290 & 0.2904 & 0.1264 \\\\ \text{DGE} & \mathbf{22.0834} & 0.5783 & 0.2085 & 0.1280 \\\\ \text{EditSplat} & 20.9711 & 0.5731 & 0.2157 & 0.1238 \\\\ \text{T3HG-Editor (Ours)} & 21.2198 & \mathbf{0.5796} & \mathbf{0.1738} & \mathbf{0.1187} \\\\ \hline \end{array}$$ As shown in the table, T3HG-Editor achieves the lowest MEt3R score of 0.1187, outperforming GaussianEditor (0.1264), DGE (0.1280), and EditSplat (0.1238). This result provides additional quantitative evidence that our method improves cross-view garment consistency, complementing the existing image-based evaluation metrics. References [1] Asim M, Wewer C, Wimmer T, et al. MET3R: Measuring Multi-View Consistency in Generated Images[C]//Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). 2025: 6034–6044. [2] Chharia A, De la Torre F. Multi-view Consistent 3D Gaussian Head Avatars 'without' Multi-view Generation[C]//Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). 2026: 40163–40174.I thank the authors for their response and clarifications. After considering the rebuttal, I will raise my rating to 3.
Introduction of the Editing Success Rate (ESR) metric and clarification of garment editing effectiveness and cross-view consistency
We sincerely thank the reviewer for this valuable comment. We agree that additional evaluation metrics should be introduced, and we would like to clarify why the previously reported metrics may understate our improvement.
Since garment editing should first and foremost be judged by whether the result follows the instruction, we introduce the Editing Success Rate (ESR) in the rebuttal version, which jointly considers instruction compliance, garment structural completeness and geometric plausibility, and visual realism. Our method achieves the highest ESR and outperforms all compared methods in target-region SSIM (0.5796) and LPIPS (0.1738), even after substantially modifying garment textures and geometric structures, providing stronger evidence of improved garment fidelity and cross-view consistency. Further discussion is provided in Section 4.3 (p. 9) and the Appendix (pp. 18–19).
Moreover, PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS cannot faithfully reflect the impact of editing failures. When editing fails, the compared methods tend to retain the original garments' appearance and pixel-level textures. As a result, they can obtain favorable image-based similarity scores although the edited results do not conform to the instructions.