- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies cross-task EEG transfer when the source and target label spaces do not correspond. The core idea is to transfer hierarchical transition dynamics characterized by microstates and BSDS, rather than features or a classification head. Specifically, source prototypes are used to anchor target microstates; dynamics fingerprints align the slow regimes on both sides; the source transition matrices are then used as Dirichlet priors and updated with target data; finally, a random forest is trained on the target data.
Critical strengths
What should be transferred when the label spaces do not correspond is an interesting question in itself; treating transition dynamics as the object of transfer is also a fairly novel idea. However, the current experiments do not yet provide enough evidence to support it.
Critical weaknesses
- I cannot understand Table 3. According to Eq. (2) and Eq. (9), λμ and τ affect only the target side. The source prototypes, BSDS, and transition matrices are all estimated separately from source data, so removing the prototype anchor or operator prior should not change the source diagnostic. Yet these are precisely the two ablations that cause the largest drops in source Macro-F1 (26.30 and 14.86 points, respectively). Moreover, the four source classes are themselves created using rules based on the alpha/theta ratio, spectral entropy, and similar measures, while the classifier uses overlapping features. This source metric therefore tells us very little.
- I do not think the experiments demonstrate that “dynamics can transfer across tasks.” The differences between target-only and the full model are just 3.36 points on SEED-IV and 0.04 AUROC on I-CARE, with neither variance estimates nor significance tests. A key control is also missing: replacing the prior, at the same τ, with a shuffled prior or one from an unrelated dataset would show whether the benefit comes from the source itself or simply from an additional layer of shrinkage. In addition, CBraMod is compared only with a scratch version; the most direct transfer baseline, fine-tuning a pretrained model, is absent.
Questions for authors
- How exactly are the two source columns in Table 3 calculated? How do λμ and τ affect the source diagnostic? Which model produces the source numbers in the target-only row?
- Could you add controls using a shuffled prior, a uniform prior, and a prior from another dataset, as well as sensitivity analyses for τA, τT, and λμ? At present, these values are simply specified.
- The variances of several baselines in Table 1 are unusual (SVM-DE ±20.05, BiHDM ±14.09), and the SVM-DE result of 56.61% is also considerably lower than figures commonly reported in the literature. How were these baselines tuned?
- φ concatenates traditional features such as h_base, but there is no ablation. What are the results using only h_base and only the dynamics features?
- What is the justification for using microstate transition structure from healthy people at rest as a prior for the EEG of comatose patients after cardiac arrest? How well do the microstates fit I-CARE data with burst suppression (for example, in terms of GEV)?