- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3(+1)
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the challenge of transferring spatial–spectral relations across datasets for EEG emotion recognition and proposes TRACE, which aims to learn how to adaptively adjust relation weights according to the characteristics of different target domains. The method learns a relation adaptation rule from labeled source domains, infers target-specific adjustment coefficients from unlabeled target-domain data, and incorporates the resulting relational changes into EEG representations for emotion classification. TRACE achieves improved performance across 8 transfer directions involving 4 EEG emotion datasets.
Critical strengths
- Novel perspective on relation adaptation. Rather than transferring a fixed spatial–spectral structure across datasets, TRACE learns a transferable rule for adjusting relation weights according to target-domain context, offering a clear perspective on cross-dataset EEG emotion recognition.
- Target-specific adaptation. TRACE infers target-specific relation adjustment coefficients from unlabeled target-domain context and constrains them to a source-supported region, limiting unconstrained extrapolation during adaptation.
- Consistent empirical performance across evaluated transfer directions. Experiments across four public EEG emotion datasets and eight transfer directions show that TRACE achieves the highest reported accuracy and Macro-F1 among the compared methods in the evaluated settings. Ablation, target-substitution, and input-perturbation experiments provide additional evidence supporting the proposed design.
Critical weaknesses
- Dependence on the availability of unlabeled target-domain data. TRACE operates in a transductive setting and uses all available unlabeled windows from the target domain for adaptation. This assumption may limit its applicability in scenarios where only a small amount of target data is available or data arrive sequentially. The robustness of the method under limited target-data availability has not been sufficiently investigated.
- Concerns about statistical reliability. Although TRACE achieved performance improvements in different migration directions, the standard deviation of performance is particularly large in many settings. Meanwhile, the results are conducted under three random seeds, which may not be sufficient to prove the stability and significance of the model.
- The motivation shown in Figure 1 is difficult to understand. Figure 1 contains several key diagnostic experiments, but it is not easy to understand them clearly. It would be better if the description could be improved.
Questions for authors
- Adaptation with limited target data: How does TRACE perform when only a fraction of the unlabeled target-domain data is available? It would be better to report results under different target-data budgets, and discuss the feasibility of adapting to streaming target data.
- Statistical reliability: Could you provide results across additional random seeds, report variability across runs separately from variation across target recordings, and conduct paired statistical significance tests against the strongest baselines?
- Contribution of relationship modeling: To what extent does graph based relationship modeling itself bring benefits compared to target condition relationship adjustment?
6 comments
## Response to Reviewer uESJ — Part 2/3
W2 and Q2. Statistical reliability and variability across target recordings and random seeds.
The accuracy SD reported in Table 1 describes variation across target recordings. Specifically, for each of the original three seeds, we compute the population SD of recording-level accuracy and then average these SDs across seeds (Section 4.1; Appendix D.1). It therefore captures the heterogeneity of target recordings.
To examine the latter, we conducted a supplementary five-seed evaluation across all eight transfer directions, using five seeds (seeds 20261110–20261114). Within each direction, the target-recording evaluation set is held fixed across seeds. Each seed independently performs source-side learning and target adaptation, using the same per-recording metric definitions and equal-weight recording aggregation as the main evaluation.
For a given seed, we first average each metric across the evaluated target recordings. We then calculate the mean and sample SD of the five seed-wise averages.
| Transfer direction | Accuracy (%) | Macro-F1 (%) | BAcc (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| SEED → SEED-IV | 54.25 | 51.73 | 55.59 |
| SEED-IV → SEED | 60.36 | 60.50 | 60.33 |
| SEED → SEED-V | 60.13 | 62.39 | 60.58 |
| SEED-V → SEED | 60.21 | 59.68 | 56.78 |
| SEED-IV → SEED-V | 64.49 | 59.46 | 64.61 |
| SEED-V → SEED-IV | 64.00 | 57.46 | 56.47 |
| SEED³ → MPED³ | 44.35 | 43.61 | 43.56 |
| MPED³ → SEED³ | 52.67 | 49.41 | 50.57 |
Across the eight directions, these observations support the consistency of TRACE's results across independently seeded runs on the evaluated target sets. They also clarify why the larger recording-level SDs in Table 1 should not be interpreted as equivalent to run-to-run training instability. Recording heterogeneity and random-seed variability are distinct properties, and the two analyses report them separately.
Paired statistical significance against baselines. This is a separate question from run-to-run variability. A paired comparison requires TRACE and the strongest baseline in each transfer direction to be evaluated on matched target recordings, with the dependence between sessions of the same participant appropriately handled. The supplementary five-seed results address the reproducibility of TRACE's performance estimates.
## Response to Reviewer uESJ — Part 3/3
W3. Motivation and interpretation of Figure 1.
Figure 1 uses controlled diagnostics on SEED → SEED-IV to answer two questions motivating TRACE.
First, which spatial–spectral relations should be attenuated? Figures 1(a–b) compare four strategies within the same eligible regional groups: Target selects relations with beneficial attenuation effects on target discovery trials; Source uses source-domain effects with matched selection counts; Random matches these counts by random selection; and Uniform distributes the same total attenuation across candidate relations. Figure 1(a) uses a source-only predictor, whereas (b) uses a target-aligned predictor. Predictor parameters and selected relations remain fixed throughout the attenuation sweep.
Selected relations and predictor parameters remain fixed across the attenuation sweep; selections are made on discovery trials and evaluated on independent confirmation trials.
In both settings, Target yields larger accuracy improvements than matched Random or Uniform controls. Thus, the result depends on which frequency-specific relations are adjusted, not merely on reducing edge weights or selecting more relations.
Second, do useful relation selections transfer across target recordings? Figure 1(c) compares centered relation-effect profiles from disjoint trials of the same target with those from different targets. Their agreement is higher within the same recording, indicating that relation effects are more repeatable across trials from a given target than transferable across recordings. Figure 1(d) evaluates Current (current-target selections), Other (selections from other targets), Pooled (aggregate effects), and Random on held-out trials. Its metric is NLL reduction relative to the unmodified predictor, so larger positive values indicate greater improvement. Current produces a larger reduction than Other. This provides a prediction-level check of the effect-agreement observation in panel (c): selecting a relation because it helps another recording need not give the same held-out benefit on the current recording.
Together, these findings motivate both relation-specific adjustment and target conditioning. Target labels are used for these diagnostics, whereas TRACE infers coefficients from unlabeled target context using a rule learned on labeled sources. We clarified the Introduction and Figure 1 caption; the full protocol appears in Appendix E.1.
Q3. Contribution of graph-based relation modeling beyond target-conditioned adjustment.
Table 2 original results contains two complementary controls. w/o Graph Relation Adjustment (last row) keeps the inferred target-specific coefficients but injects them directly as a feature residual instead of changing spatial–spectral graph weights. w/o Target Conditioning (second row) preserves graph-based adjustment but replaces target-specific coefficients with one shared source-optimized vector. In the first control, the coefficient vector is still inferred from each target, so the difference is not explained simply by having access to target context. In the second, graph-relation weighting is still active, so its performance gap isolates the benefit of target-dependent selection within the tested adaptation pipeline. Thus, the former tests how coefficients enter the model; the latter tests whether their selection depends on the current recording.
| Transfer direction | Full TRACE | w/o Graph Adjustment | w/o Target Conditioning |
|---|---|---|---|
| SEED → SEED-IV | 54.82 | 50.60 | 50.10 |
| SEED-IV → SEED | 60.89 | 53.27 | 54.59 |
| SEED-IV → SEED-V | 64.26 | 55.06 | 53.67 |
| SEED-V → SEED-IV | 63.32 | 57.92 | 56.27 |
All values are accuracy (%). Full TRACE gains 4.22, 7.62, 9.20, and 5.40 points, respectively, over w/o Graph Relation Adjustment, and 4.72, 6.30, 10.59, and 7.05 points over w/o Target Conditioning. The former comparison supports explicit graph-mediated adjustment rather than direct feature conditioning. The latter supports recording-specific coefficient inference rather than imposing one source-derived adjustment on every target. The gains occur in all four tested directions, not just in one transfer setting.
Table 2 also includes w/o Relation Adaptation, retaining reference relation weights, and w/o Relational Residual, substituting the reference graph representation for the adjusted-minus-reference difference. All variants use the same adaptation procedure and budget but are adapted separately, so results compare complete adaptation pathways rather than frozen-network interventions. Together, they support distinct, complementary benefits from target-specific coefficients and their graph-mediated application. We clarified this interpretation in Section 4.3.
## Response to Reviewer uESJ — Part 1/3
Thank you for the constructive feedback and for recognizing the value of target-specific relation adaptation. We conducted supplementary evaluations of target-data availability and random-seed variability. We also clarified the motivation in Figure 1 and the interpretation of the graph-modeling ablations. Revisions addressing this review are marked in dark green.
W1 and Q1. Adaptation with limited unlabeled target data and streaming targets.
We evaluated TRACE under four target-data budgets on SEED → SEED-IV, using 10 fixed target recordings and three random seeds. Each SEED-IV recording contains 24 complete trials. We constructed nested, label-agnostic subsets containing 6, 12, 18, and 24 trials, corresponding to 25%, 50%, 75%, and 100% of the available trials.
The budget restriction applies to the entire target-side procedure, rather than to context estimation alone. At each budget, target min–max normalization, context construction, relation-coefficient inference, clustering, pseudo-label generation, and downstream adaptation use the selected unlabeled trials. The source-trained model is shared across the four budgets within each seed, and each budget completes the same adaptation procedure. All conditions are evaluated on the same complete target recordings, including the trials previously used for unlabeled adaptation. Target labels are used for evaluation, not adaptation.
Entries report mean ± sample SD across three seed-wise recording averages. With 25% rather than 100% of the trials, accuracy decreases by 1.12 percentage points, macro-F1 by 1.32 points, and BAcc by 2.74 points. BAcc exhibits the largest decrease. These results characterize TRACE's behavior under reduced target-data availability in the evaluated offline transductive setting.
The model design provides several reasons for the observed behavior.
First, TRACE learns the context-to-relation adaptation rule from labeled source domains. Candidate relation adjustments are retained for learning this rule when they reduce classification loss on disjoint source validation trials. Consequently, reducing the number of available target trials does not require learning a new relation basis, graph encoder, or context-to-coefficient mapping. The target data are used to infer how a previously source-trained rule should be applied to the current recording.
Second, target context is constructed by aggregating trial-level graph representations using estimated class probabilities. Rather than independently estimating a large collection of target-specific edge parameters, TRACE predicts an eight-dimensional relation-coefficient vector. The coefficients are further constrained to the convex hull of source-domain predictions and the reference coefficient vector. This restricts extrapolation when target context is estimated from fewer trials.
Third, the source-trained graph encoder and within-relation edge proportions remain fixed. Target coefficients modify the relative total weights of the shared spatial–spectral relation types. TRACE then projects the difference between adjusted and reference graph representations into a residual that complements the base EEG representation. Target adaptation therefore uses a constrained relation-adjustment pathway while retaining the source-trained relational structure and the base feature pathway.
These mechanisms provide a structural explanation consistent with the limited-budget results. The experiment evaluates their combined behavior rather than attributing the measured performance difference to any single component.
We also agree that streaming targets are a valuable direction for further investigation. TRACE's trial-level context aggregation suggests a possible route toward incremental context and prototype estimation, while drift-aware coefficient updates could accommodate changes over time. A streaming evaluation would require chronological adaptation and prediction, ensuring that each newly arriving trial is scored before its information is incorporated into subsequent updates. The present experiment establishes the behavior of offline adaptation with smaller unlabeled target batches; it does not assume such a streaming procedure has already been evaluated.