- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes DOME, a Distortion-Driven Domain Mixture-of-Experts framework for robust LiDAR–4D Radar 3D object detection under adverse weather. Rather than relying on predefined weather categories or image-based weather recognition, DOME learns latent, distortion-aware routing cues directly from multimodal features. Its Physical Distortion-guided Router (PDR) combines global multimodal context with local LiDAR–Radar discrepancies to build a distortion fingerprint, which it then uses to activate Distortion-Specialized Experts through Top-K routing. The paper also introduces DOME-L, a parameter-efficient variant that replaces full experts with LoRA-based distortion experts. Experiments on K-Radar and OmniHD-Scenes show improved all-weather detection performance, with additional analyses on generic-MoE baselines, weather-based routing, continuous and held-out degradation conditions, expert routing behavior, and cross-backbone transfer.
Critical strengths
The main strengths of the paper are that (i) it identifies a meaningful limitation of existing weather-aware adaptation and proposes a practically relevant, camera-free alternative, and (ii) the design of the proposed router is well motivated and examined through targeted analyses beyond aggregate accuracy.
First, the paper addresses a real gap in weather-aware multimodal 3D detection. Discrete weather categories give only a coarse description of environmental conditions and need not match the type, severity, or spatial pattern of the actual sensor degradation. Existing approaches also depend on camera-based weather recognition, which can itself become unreliable in adverse visual conditions. Deriving routing cues directly from LiDAR and 4D Radar observations is therefore a reasonable and practically relevant direction. It also allows DOME to perform comparably to camera-assisted methods without the camera modality.
Second, the PDR design is well motivated, and the paper examines it with analyses that go beyond overall detection accuracy. The global branch captures scene-level multimodal context, while the local branch models LiDAR–Radar disagreement, reflecting degradation that affects one modality more than the other. The component ablation supports this complementarity: global-only and local-only variants reach 59.7 and 58.8 AP3D, compared with 61.6 for the full PDR. In addition:
Sample-adaptive routing outperforms both weather-fixed routing (60.2) and image-based weather routing (59.4). In the controlled fog experiment, scene content and Radar observations are held fixed, and routing divergence increases with fog severity. In the held-out snow experiment, performance drops by only 2.6 and 2.5 points, compared with 15.8 and 14.9 for L4DR.
The lightweight DOME-L variant (about 78M parameters) and the InterFusion experiments further suggest that the approach is practical and not tied to a single backbone.
Critical weaknesses
My main concerns are that (i) the source of the improvement is unclear, and the contribution attributed to the proposed distortion-aware routing is small and confounded with MoE capacity and training strategy, and (ii) DOME does not outperform existing weather-aware methods on the main benchmark. Together, these issues lead to my current rating.
First, it is unclear what drives DOME's improvement. Most of the 8.1-point AP3D gain over L4DR comes from expanding to a generic MoE with about five times more parameters (53.5 → 59.7). However, the paper includes neither a parameter-matched dense L4DR nor a single conditional model that uses the same PDR fingerprint without multiple experts. As a result, it remains unclear whether the MoE formulation itself is necessary. The remaining 1.9-point gain attributed to distortion-aware routing is also difficult to interpret. Generic-MoE (Table 3) and Global-only PDR (Table 8) both reach exactly 59.7, which suggests that this gain largely corresponds to adding the local LiDAR–Radar discrepancy branch. It is also not stated whether Generic-MoE was trained with the same Progressive Expert Maturation strategy. Without it, PDR+DSE reaches only 58.3, below Generic-MoE. Finally, this comparison is reported from a single run. This is consequential because the paper's central claim, that distortion-aware routing drives robustness, is not cleanly supported by the current evidence.
Second, the comparison with prior weather-aware methods is less favorable than the text suggests. In Table 1, L4DR-DA3D achieves a higher overall AP3D than DOME (61.9 vs. 61.6), and AW-MoE achieves a higher overall APBEV (84.2 vs. 83.2). Under Rain, DOME is notably weaker (58.2 vs. 63.0 and 63.5). The augmentation-matched comparison in Appendix B.6 uses a non-standard protocol: it fine-tunes the detector with precomputed, fixed routing scores, so the 62.7 vs. 61.5 comparison is not fully matched. On OmniHD-Scenes, the improvements over L4DR are around 1 AP, and AW-MoE is not included. This is consequential because the practical value of DOME then rests mainly on achieving comparable performance without the camera modality, which is a weaker claim than the state-of-the-art performance the paper suggests.
Questions for authors
- Why is a Mixture-of-Experts formulation necessary for this problem?
The paper argues that predefined weather categories are inadequate because physical distortions vary continuously in type and severity. However, why should this continuous variation be represented through a finite set of experts rather than through a single condition-adaptive model?
Could the authors compare DOME with a parameter- and FLOP-matched universal model that receives exactly the same PDR distortion fingerprint but uses it to continuously condition a shared network, for example through feature modulation, dynamic residual adapters, conditional normalization, or another lightweight conditional transformation? Could they also report a dense L4DR scaled to a comparable parameter count? These baselines would separate the contribution of the distortion representation from the architectural benefit of introducing multiple expert branches, as well as from a simple increase in parameter count.
- How should the gain from PDR be interpreted relative to the Generic-MoE and Global-only variants?
The Generic-MoE (Table 3) and Global-only PDR (Table 8) both achieve 59.7 AP3D. Could the authors clarify exactly how the generic router differs from the Global-only PDR variant? If they are nearly equivalent, should the 1.9-point gain be understood primarily as the contribution of the local discrepancy branch?
In addition, was Generic-MoE trained with the same ALE, TAS, and ABS components as DOME? PDR+DSE without PEM reaches only 58.3, which is below Generic-MoE. Could the authors report Generic-MoE with and without PEM, along with mean and standard deviation over multiple seeds for both Generic-MoE and DOME, so that the 1.9-point difference can be assessed against run-to-run variance?
- How should DOME's performance be positioned relative to prior weather-aware methods?
In Table 1, L4DR-DA3D achieves a higher overall AP3D and AW-MoE† a higher overall APBEV than DOME, and DOME is notably weaker under Rain. Could the authors discuss these cases, in particular why DOME underperforms under Rain? Regarding Appendix B.6, could the authors also report an augmentation-matched comparison in which DOME is trained end-to-end with UDMA (with PDR computing routing scores online) rather than fine-tuned with precomputed routing scores?
- Can the authors provide more direct validation that PDR learns physical distortion rather than correlated scene properties?
The current continuous-fog experiment is useful because it holds scene content and Radar observations fixed while changing LiDAR degradation. However, it evaluates only one corruption family at three severity levels.
Could the authors perform controlled same-scene experiments across multiple physically distinct corruption types and severities and test whether the learned fingerprint or routing distribution tracks known degradation variables? For example, reporting how well the fingerprint predicts or correlates with simulated attenuation, point-drop rate, noise magnitude, or another physically defined degradation parameter would provide more direct support for the "physical distortion fingerprint" interpretation. It would also help to report the JSD between routing distributions of different real weather categories as a reference scale for the values in Table 9.
- How well does DOME generalize to genuinely unseen degradation levels or distortion types?
The simulated fog experiments use the same severity values for training augmentation and evaluation, although the scenes themselves are disjoint. Could the authors evaluate interpolation and extrapolation to severity values that are never observed during training?
More importantly, could the authors perform a leave-one-weather-out experiment in which an entire degradation type is excluded from training and evaluated without test-time adaptation? This would provide stronger evidence that DOME discovers reusable latent degradation structure rather than specializing to the set of distortion regimes already observed during training.
- How does PDR respond to non-weather sources of cross-modal disagreement?
The local PDR branch explicitly treats LiDAR–Radar discrepancy as a useful distortion signal, but similar discrepancies may arise from calibration errors, temporal misalignment, object motion, random point dropout, or sensor-specific noise.
Could the authors report routing or fingerprint changes under controlled non-weather perturbations, rather than only downstream detection accuracy? This would clarify whether PDR is specifically sensitive to weather-induced degradation or more generally reacts to arbitrary cross-modal inconsistency.
- Can the authors provide stronger evidence for expert specialization?
The routing distributions show that different weather conditions activate experts differently and that there is no one-to-one mapping between weather categories and individual experts. However, it remains unclear what functional specialization each expert actually learns.
Could the authors perform expert-level interventions, such as disabling, swapping, or forcing individual experts and measuring the resulting degradation across corruption types and severity levels? Such an analysis would provide stronger evidence that the experts correspond to distinct latent degradation functions rather than largely interchangeable high-capacity branches.
- How should the efficiency of DOME-L be interpreted when training cost is included?
DOME-L substantially reduces inference-time parameter count and FLOPs, but it uses a two-stage training procedure: a full first-stage detector training (35 epochs) followed by an additional adaptation stage (15 epochs). Could the authors report total GPU-hours, peak training memory, and active parameters per input for L4DR, DOME, and DOME-L?
This would help distinguish parameter-efficient deployment from overall computational efficiency and make the practical trade-off clearer.