- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a reinforcement learning framework for underwater image enhancement. The authors claim that global color recovery and local detail restoration need to be learned at different stages, and that reinforcement learning can achieve this. The framework formulates update scheduling as a Markov decision process and uses a PPO-based controller to select among alternating, joint, and weighted updates according to a frequency-aware training state. The method is validated on four underwater benchmarks, and ablation studies show that the proposed reinforcement learning framework is effective.
Critical strengths
Critical Strengths:
The paper brings reinforcement learning into underwater image enhancement for update scheduling. This is a relatively novel angle, since most existing methods still rely on fixed loss weights or predefined training schedules. Framing the coordination of global color recovery and local detail restoration as a sequential decision problem is consequential because it offers a different way to handle their stage-dependent optimization demands.
The empirical study is broad and includes multiple benchmarks, several comparison dimensions, and ablation studies. Although the core motivation is not fully supported by sufficient evidence, the reported metric improvements and ablations provide reasonable support that the proposed framework is effective. The paper is also generally clear and easy to read, which makes its contributions easier to assess.
Critical weaknesses
Critical Weaknesses:
The core motivation is not sufficiently supported. The paper assumes that global color recovery and local detail restoration need to be learned at different stages, but it does not provide cross-model visualizations or statistics showing that this phenomenon is widespread. Moreover, although the authors claim a learning-to-train framework, all experiments are conducted on a single architecture. This is consequential because the stage-dependent motivation and the claimed generality of the framework remain unproven.
The experimental comparison is outdated and limited. Only one compared method is from 2025, and the second-best method is from 2023. This is consequential because the reported improvements do not establish an advantage over recent state-of-the-art methods, which weakens the empirical case for acceptance.
Questions for authors
The comparison includes only one 2025 method, and the second-best baseline is from 2023. Could you clarify the baseline selection criteria and provide comparisons with more recent 2025–2026 methods where available?
The paper claims a learning-to-train framework, but all experiments are conducted on a single architecture. Could you clarify whether the framework is intended to be architecture-agnostic? If so, can you provide results on additional backbones with redefined action spaces?
The central motivation assumes that color recovery and detail restoration progress asynchronously. Could you provide cross-model visualizations or statistics showing that this phenomenon is widespread rather than specific to your architecture?