- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates supervised low-light image enhancement in the HVI color space, which decouples chromatic HV from intensity I. Addressing how color and intensity branches should coordinate during restoration, the authors propose SPARNet.
Controlled 3-level Haar DWT and Centered Kernel Alignment on 689 LOLv2-Real image pairs reveal that low-frequency HV and I components exhibit growing representation similarity at coarser scales. However, grouped ridge regression yields an out-of-fold , demonstrating that low-frequency color and intensity share common spatial layout yet remain linearly non-substitutable.
A three-level wavelet backbone isolates low frequencies, where a shared–private cross-space low-frequency latent fusion module explicitly partitions features into shared and private subspaces via complementary gating.
The framework enforces three regularizers: shared alignment, intra-branch orthogonality, and private purity to prevent representation collapse and cross-branch leakage. Level-1 directional high-frequency subbands (HL, LH, HH) are selectively updated using fused low-frequency context and branch-specific features to suppress sensor noise while preserving sharp boundaries.
Critical strengths
The paper opens with a carefully controlled empirical study using spatial-shuffling and cross-image null controls alongside grouped cross-validation, establishing a quantitative foundation for the dual-pathway architecture.
The combination of soft complementary gating and three Frobenius-norm regularizers enforces a clean division of roles. Representation analyses using stage-wise CKA matrices verify that the separation margin rises from to .
SPARNet achieves the top score in 8 of 9 metrics across the LOL family (LOLv1, LOLv2-Real, LOLv2-Synthetic), attains the lowest average NIQE (3.53) across five unpaired datasets, and reports evaluations on extreme sensor-noise data (Sony-Total-Dark).
Critical weaknesses
On the primary real-world benchmark LOLv2-Real, although SPARNet leads in PSNR (28.602 dB) and SSIM (0.893), its perceptual score (LPIPS 0.110) lags behind several existing methods, indicating a tendency toward slight over-smoothing.
On the Sony-Total-Dark dataset, SPARNet yields only a minor PSNR improvement of +0.126 dB over CIDNet. In severe low-photon regimes, level-1 high-frequency subbands remain corrupted by heavy signal-dependent noise that low-frequency guidance struggles to filter out.
The motivation rests on the failure of linear ridge regression (). Because color and luminance exhibit inherently non-linear dependencies in complex scenes, evaluating only linear mappings leaves the degree of non-linear predictability unaddressed.
Questions for authors
On the LOLv2-Real benchmark, SPARNet achieves superior PSNR and SSIM, but its perceptual distance metric (LPIPS 0.110) lags behind existing methods such as GSAD (0.096) and Wave-Mamba (0.105). Does the strong low-frequency context guidance in Equation 8 cause slight over-smoothing in fine textures, and can this trade-off be improved by adjusting the perceptual loss weight or relaxing the high-frequency gating?
On the extreme low-light Sony-Total-Dark dataset, the performance gain over CIDNet is relatively modest (+0.126 dB PSNR). In severe photon-starved regimes where level-1 high-frequency subbands are dominated by sensor noise, have the authors explored incorporating explicit wavelet shrinkage or a preliminary noise-filtering prior before gated subband correction?
The motivation analysis relies on linear ridge regression yielding an out-of-fold to claim that HV and I are non-substitutable. Did the authors evaluate non-linear predictability (e.g., using a shallow MLP, Random Forest, or Mutual Information)? Could the low reflect non-linear coupling rather than an intrinsic lack of cross-component predictability?
What are the inference latency, FLOPs, and parameter counts of SPARNet compared to CIDNet and Wave-Mamba on standard input resolutions? Does the three-level CSLF module with bidirectional transformer attention introduce substantial computational latency on edge or mobile devices?
We thank the reviewer for the detailed analysis. We clarify the interpretation of the motivation study, connect the perceptual-quality concern to the existing ablation, and report the scope of available computational measurements.
1. Low-frequency guidance and the PSNR–LPIPS trade-off.
The fixed-architecture ablation in Table 5 shows that shared–private regularization improves LPIPS on LOLv2-Real from 0.1279 to 0.1100, alongside improved PSNR and SSIM. Thus, the constraints are compatible with improved perceptual similarity in the tested setting. The final LPIPS nevertheless remains worse than GSAD’s 0.096 and Wave-Mamba’s 0.105 in Table 1, which we recognize as a remaining limitation.
Eq. (8) retains the input high-frequency subband and adds a learned gated correction. It does not directly replace high-frequency information with the low-frequency context. The reported LPIPS gap alone therefore does not identify low-frequency guidance as its cause, although the learned update and reconstruction objectives may affect texture retention.
Appendix D specifies a perceptual-loss weight of 0.012 for LOLv2-Real. Changing this weight or the gating strength is a reasonable direction to investigate, but no systematic sensitivity study is reported. We will distinguish the observed perceptual gap from the unverified explanation of over-smoothing and avoid claiming that either adjustment has already improved the trade-off.
2. Extreme sensor noise and explicit denoising.
Sony-Total-Dark already tests this boundary: Table 2 reports 23.030 dB PSNR and 0.688 SSIM, corresponding to gains of 0.126 dB and 0.012 over CIDNet. These results show a measured improvement, while the small PSNR margin also exposes the limitation under severe noise.
The current model learns contextual, direction-specific corrections without an explicit wavelet-shrinkage stage or calibrated sensor-noise model. When fine signal is overwhelmed by noise, contextual guidance alone cannot guarantee its recovery. Shrinkage or a preliminary denoising prior is a relevant extension, but neither is evaluated in the submission. We will make this boundary explicit without presenting an untested extension as an established solution.
3. Nonlinear predictability and the scope of the motivation.
Our intended conclusion is limited linear substitutability under the tested fixed cross-image mappings. The controlled study provides two observations: paired CKA increases from 0.1550 at LL1 to 0.2633 at LL3 and exceeds the null controls, while image-grouped five-fold ridge regression yields out-of-fold R² no greater than 0.0598. Together, these observations motivate modeling shared structure alongside complementary representations.
We agree that low linear R² can coexist with nonlinear coupling. The main text and Appendix F.3 already specify the linear scope; the study does not evaluate MLP, Random Forest, or mutual-information alternatives. We will consistently qualify the “not substitutable” wording to avoid implying information-theoretic non-substitutability or a result about arbitrary nonlinear predictors. The usefulness of the shared–private modeling choice is additionally supported by the restoration ablation in Table 5.
4. Parameters, computation, latency, and deployment.
An existing profiling record for the three-stage implementation with level-1 subband correction provides the following absolute costs. The input is 400×600, batch size is 1, and execution uses FP32 on an NVIDIA RTX 4090, including DA-CLIP:
The computation figure uses 1 MAC = 2 FLOPs for counted convolution, linear, and attention matrix-product operations; it is not a complete count of every operator. Timing averages 300 forwards and includes the prior encoder, while excluding disk I/O, host-to-device transfer, and external preprocessing. Frozen parameters are included in the loaded-model total.
These measurements provide the cost of the profiled implementation, rather than a standardized speed comparison against CIDNet and Wave-Mamba. Such a comparison requires the same resolution, hardware, precision, and timing boundary. No edge/mobile measurements are available in the submission, so the current evidence does not establish real-time deployment on those devices. We will report the profiling scope explicitly and keep deployment claims within the available evidence.