- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes APD-Flow, a reward post-training framework for deterministic flow-matching image restoration. It generates two restorations using antithetic perturbations of the source state, converts their reward-weighted output difference into velocity-field updates through a distance-based proxy objective, and adaptively balances preference and fidelity rewards. Experiments cover four restoration backbones, sampling schedules ranging from one to fifteen steps, and face restoration, super-resolution, and scene-text restoration. The paper reports perceptual and task-specific improvements, supported by component ablations and a human preference study, while preserving the original inference sampler and step count.
Critical strengths
Source-state exploration offers a practical way to optimize deterministic restorers with rewards, including non-differentiable feedback. Its applicability to one-step models is particularly useful, and retaining the original inference sampler makes the resulting improvements attractive for deployment.
The evaluation covers several backbones and restoration tasks, with comparisons to alternative post-training methods and targeted ablations. The 20-participant study provides additional evidence of perceptual benefit: APD-Flow is preferred over PMRF for visual quality in 64.2% of comparisons, versus 25.4% for PMRF (Table 3).
Critical weaknesses
The claim of preserving fidelity needs qualification. On PMRF, LPIPS increases from 0.331 to 0.349 despite improvements in other metrics (Table 5). Appendix C.2 also sets the normalized fidelity threshold to 0.95 for FlowIE-BFR, explicitly allowing some composite-fidelity reduction. The evidence supports a favorable perception–fidelity trade-off, but does not establish preservation of every fidelity measure.
The methodological advance is relatively focused. Section 4.2 explicitly builds on the directions and targets of FDFO and the proxy ratio of FPO. Source-state pairing and adaptive fidelity control are useful additions, but the empirical contribution of the proposed mean-response regularizer is not isolated from the rest of the objective. This leaves part of the claimed optimization contribution insufficiently established.
Questions for authors
1.How should the fidelity-preservation claim be interpreted given the LPIPS increase and the 0.95 threshold for FlowIE-BFR? Please clarify the permitted fidelity loss and whether satisfying the composite constraint can conceal deterioration in individual fidelity components. 2.With source pairs, rollout reuse, rewards, and the fidelity controller fixed, how does the proposed mean-response regularizer compare with a per-branch penalty or no regularization? This would help establish its contribution beyond the inherited proxy objective.
2 comments
Thanks to the authors for addressing my concerns. I think their explanation has, to some extent, resolved the issues I raised earlier.
First, the additional experiments on the mean response regularization provided the experimental evidence I was looking for. Second, they added a relevant explanation regarding the cause of the discrepancy in the LPIPS metric.
Therefore, I've decided to keep my original score.
Response to Reviewer ma9A
Many thanks for the careful reading and the supportive assessment. We appreciate your note that the applicability to one-step models is particularly useful, that keeping the original inference sampler makes the improvements attractive for deployment, and that the human study adds evidence of perceptual benefit. Changes in the revised PDF are highlighted in blue.
W1 / Q1. Interpreting "fidelity preservation". Thank you for raising this. In our paper, fidelity preservation does not mean that every fidelity metric stays the same or improves. It means that the composite fidelity score is kept near the pretrained level, so the perceptual gains come without an overall loss of fidelity. We have revised the abstract, Sec. 1, and Sec. 4.3 to state that the method keeps a composite fidelity score at or above a target set relative to the pretrained restorer. Sec. 5.2 now describes the results as a balance between perception and fidelity.
Q1. Permitted fidelity loss. The threshold τ works as a dial. Setting τ=1 keeps composite fidelity at the pretrained level, as used for PMRF and FlowIE-BSR. This default setting is what our claim of keeping pretrained-level fidelity refers to. A higher τ asks for fidelity above the pretrained level, as used for DiT4SR (τ=1.05). A slightly lower τ trades a little fidelity for better perceptual quality. FlowIE-BFR uses τ=0.95 for this reason, which allows at most a 5% drop in composite fidelity. Even so, its identity distance, landmark distance, CLIP-Sim, and FID all improve over the pretrained model (Table 1).
Q1. Can the composite constraint hide deterioration in individual metrics? In practice, it does not hide any severe loss of fidelity. All fidelity components measure agreement with the GT and are strongly positively correlated, so one component is unlikely to collapse while the others compensate for it. On PMRF, LPIPS rises slightly, while several other fidelity metrics, DISTS, identity distance, landmark distance, and CLIP-Sim, all improve (Tables 1 and 5).
W2 / Q2. Effect of the mean-response regularizer. Following your suggestion, we added a controlled ablation in Appendix F.4. With all other components fixed, we retrained PMRF with each of the three regularizers and evaluated them on a 300-image subset of CelebA-Test. Our common-mode (mean-response) regularizer gives the best perceptual quality and fidelity among the three choices.
Table R1. Regularizer ablation, post-training on PMRF (CelebA-Test, 300 images).
As Eq. (A.12) shows, the per-branch penalty also suppresses the contrast between the two branches, and removing the regularizer leaves their joint drift unconstrained.