- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
RegionAgent uses a VLM to choose where and how to refine a degraded image. The policy is trained first on preferences over individual actions and then on preferences based on final trajectory scores. The authors construct a regional restoration preference dataset and evaluate the method on mixed- and single-degradation benchmarks.
Critical strengths
-
Regional refinement is well motivated, and the PSNR results are strong, particularly on Group C: 20.90 dB versus 19.85 dB for the best reported baseline. The comparison with RAR also shows a trade-off between PSNR and LPIPS.
-
I found the B/C and E/F comparisons in Table 3(a) useful. They keep the preference data and update budget fixed, and both support supervising only the differing component or action. These comparisons give clear evidence for the proposed masking choices.
Critical weaknesses
- I am not yet sure how much the learned region selection adds. The shared restorer is fine-tuned on MiO, but the main tables do not include a Base-only result. A comparison with simple heatmap-based selection, using the same restoration components and refinement budget, would help establish the contribution of the VLM’s region choices.
2 .The trajectory stage improves the reported scores, but the full model also receives more preference data and updates than the step-only model. This makes the gain harder to attribute specifically to trajectory feedback. I would like to understand when this feedback changes the policy’s decisions and how those changes improve the final restoration.
Questions for authors
-
Could you add Base-only results? I would also like to see the full policy compared with always selecting the highest-scoring heatmap window, using the same restoration components and refinement budget.
-
Can you show cases where step-level and trajectory-level feedback favor different actions? Comparing the final results of the step-only and full policies in these cases would help explain what the second stage learns.
-
Appendix D.1 states that baseline results are taken from prior work. Were RegionAgent’s results computed using the same test images, preprocessing and metric settings? Please clarify any differences.