- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents an image restoration agent that uses accumulated experience to guide tool selection and degradation-removal order. Its experience pool contains insight-level, coarse-grained, and fine-grained guidance, updated from restoration outcomes, metric-based rankings, and degradation-pattern profiles. Experiments evaluate restoration quality, tool invocation counts, and adaptation to changes in tools, degradations, and data sources.
Critical strengths
- The improvements in PSNR and SSIM under Setting I are substantial, and the real-world evaluation also shows useful gains in quality and invocation count. These results suggest that the experience pool improves actual tool use rather than only the agent’s planning descriptions.
- Appendix C explicitly separates the experience-evolution and evaluation datasets. The paper also provides experiments on experience granularity and evolution frequency, which help explain when the mechanism is useful.
Critical weaknesses
- The efficiency comparison does not account for the cost of acquiring experience. Section 3.4 evaluates all candidate tools or removal orders to construct experience; for multiple degradations, this involves trajectories. The reported 61% reduction follows from the invocation counts in Table 2, from 10.89 to 4.23. However, different tools have different runtimes, and experience construction, retrieval, and MLLM calls introduce additional costs. The partial API accounting in Appendix C does not establish how many requests are needed to recover the initial cost or whether the full system is faster overall.
- The justification for decoupling tool selection and removal order is limited, and the adaptation results are more mixed than the discussion suggests. Appendix A.1 examines three two-degradation settings and reports 80% agreement with the modal order. This also shows that changing tools can change the preferred order, but the quality loss from ignoring this interaction is not measured. In Appendix B.1, Table 4, S4 reaches 18.12 dB compared with 20.66 dB for S5, while perception-mode invocations increase from 3.41 at S3 to 5.42 at S4. These results demonstrate some adaptation, but do not clearly establish that the evolved system approaches the reference configuration in both quality and efficiency.
Questions for authors
- Could you report total runtime or GPU/API cost including experience generation, updates, retrieval, and inference, together with the number of requests needed to amortize experience construction?
- In a small setting where joint search is feasible, how much quality is lost by decoupling tool selection and removal order? Do the order changes observed in Appendix A.1 lead to meaningful restoration differences?
- Do the Fidelity and Perception columns in Table 1 correspond to separate restored outputs? Given the mixed LPIPS and no-reference results in Setting II, which quality–efficiency trade-off should be regarded as the main supported advantage?