- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose BeTAR, a degradationaware agentic framework that integrates structured degradation perception with belief-guided restoration planning for multi-degradation surgical image restoration. An VLM is first used to determine the degradation types and severity, and different restoration tools are used for the final recovery. BeTAR achieved SOTA performance on self-constructed datasets.
Critical strengths
- Agentic recovery for surgical image restoration in mininally invasive surgery is both meaningful and interesting.
- The performance improvement seems to be significant.
Critical weaknesses
-
Figures 1, 2, and 3 require substantial improvements. Figure 1 is overly schematic and lacks specific quantitative values, clearly defined metrics, and sufficient experimental details to support its conclusions. Figures 2 and 3 also suffer from small text, unclear graphical elements, and poor visual organization, making the proposed framework difficult to understand. The authors should redesign these figures to improve both readability and technical clarity.
-
Figures 2 and 3 lack sufficient technical details to support reproducibility. Figure 2 repeatedly uses generic <think> placeholders without clearly illustrating the five-stage reasoning process or the corresponding reward design. Figure 3 mainly presents a generic perception–planning–execution pipeline without adequately highlighting the technical innovations of Agentic-RL. The authors should clarify how the belief state is incorporated into the policy, how restoration trajectories are generated, and how trajectory-level rewards are used for optimization.
-
The experimental evaluation is insufficient to demonstrate generalizability. Although the paper discusses public datasets and benchmarks such as DeSmoke-LAP and SurgClean, the experiments are primarily conducted on the authors' own data. While an independent test set is included, its characteristics and relationship to the training data are not sufficiently described. Evaluations on multiple established public benchmarks would provide stronger evidence of generalizability across different surgical scenarios and degradation types.
-
Comparisons with existing agentic restoration methods are missing. The paper discusses RestoreAgent, AgenticIR, JarvisIR, and Q-Agent, but Table 1 mainly compares BeTAR against conventional restoration networks. Since the primary contribution lies in agentic tool scheduling rather than restoration backbone design, direct comparisons with representative agentic restoration methods are essential. Ideally, these methods should be evaluated using the same restoration tool library to ensure fairness.
-
The manuscript requires further language polishing. The Introduction, Method Overview, and Conclusion repeatedly use phrases such as "tool selection, execution order, and termination" and "structured belief state." Similar conceptual descriptions appear throughout the paper without adding substantial technical information. The authors should reduce repetition, improve the overall conciseness, and devote more attention to explaining the methodological contributions.
-
The necessity of the POMDP formulation is insufficiently justified. The framework generates complete restoration trajectories in an open-loop manner, without updating its belief state based on intermediate restoration results. This raises questions about how the proposed formulation differs from conventional belief-conditioned sequence generation. The authors should clarify the practical advantages of introducing a POMDP and provide more targeted comparisons to demonstrate its necessity.
Questions for authors
The current presentation gives the impression of an insufficiently polished submission. Several figures are overly generic and schematic, with limited technical information beyond what is already stated in the text. It would be much better if the authors provide more informative figures and improve the overall manuscript presentation and proofreading.