- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces Inertial Fragment Matching (IFM), an inference framework that generates molecular fragments conditioned on local principal moments of inertia, then assembles and jointly denoises them to match a reference shape. IFM improves average shape similarity and fixed-fragment integration success.
Critical strengths
The core idea is clean and physically motivated. MOI tensors are additive and can be shifted between reference points with the parallel-axis theorem.
Critical weaknesses
-
The main text is thin and does not provide a self-contained description of the method, leaving essential formulation and implementation details to the appendix. Consequently, the paper reads more like a technical note or workshop submission than a fully developed study.
-
The underlying model and training data are only briefly described, with substantial reliance on prior work. This makes it difficult to assess reproducibility and distinguish the contribution of IFM from that of fragment-level training augmentation.
-
The headline shape-similarity gain comes with a large strain cost, while the benchmarks and baselines cover a narrow evaluation setting. The paper lacks a sufficiently broad, fair comparison with other moment-of-inertia-conditioned generation approaches under matched optimization and computational budgets.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors expand the main text to include the essential method formulation, inference procedure, and implementation choices? What additional evidence would establish IFM as a broadly applicable framework beyond the current proof of concept?
-
Can the authors provide fuller details of the model architecture, training procedure, dataset construction, and fragment augmentation? Can an ablation separate the effects of fragment augmentation from those of IFM inference?
-
How does IFM compare with other moment-of-inertia-conditioned generation approaches under identical geometry optimization and matched computational budgets? Can the evaluation cover more diverse molecular architectures and jointly report chemical validity and inference cost?
2 comments
Thanks for the rebuttal from authors. Although the new clarifications and method introduction are helpful, I think this manuscipt still below the acceptance bar of ICLR. It needs better paper writing with clearer background and related work discussion, more detailed and rigorous introduction of the method, and more comparison with existing baselines. Therefore, I will maintain my score.
1. Method formulation and generality
We agree that the original main text was insufficiently self-contained. We have moved the essential IFM formulation into the revised manuscript, including the distinction between the additive full MOI tensor and the principal-moment conditioning vector, rigid-motion transport, fragment recomposition, and the inference procedure.
The revised description covers reference fragmentation and local descriptor computation, storage of fragment rotations and translations, independent fragment generation, rigid placement in the global frame, and late-stage global-MOI-conditioned denoising in relaxed or clamped mode. We also specify the main implementation settings: 100 denoising steps, with merging during the final 10 steps.
We have clarified that the current implementation requires a decomposable reference geometry or externally supplied fragment descriptors and placements; the global principal-moment vector alone does not determine the fragmentation.
Finally, although Section 2.2 formulates a broader transport-additive principle, our experiments establish feasibility only for MOI-conditioned molecular generation. Demonstrating broader applicability would require validation with other generative backbones, descriptors, or object classes. We have therefore revised the Abstract and Conclusion to present generalization as future work rather than an established empirical result.
2. Architecture, training and augmentation
We have expanded Appendix A.3–A.5 and added a summary of the architecture and training procedure to the main text.
All experiments use MLConformerGenerator, an equivariant diffusion model conditioned on ordered principal moments of inertia, with bond prediction performed by AdjMatSeer. The original checkpoint was trained on ChEMBL-derived conformations containing 15–39 heavy atoms. For IFM, we trained an augmented checkpoint using the same architecture and objective, extending the training data with 6–15-heavy-atom fragments obtained by iteratively breaking non-ring single bonds, canonicalizing by SMILES, and removing duplicates. The resulting checkpoint covers 6–39 heavy atoms.
Importantly, all primary comparisons (conventional generation versus relaxed IFM, and inpainting versus clamped IFM) use the same augmented checkpoint. Thus, the observed differences cannot be attributed to unequal fragment augmentation.
We additionally evaluated the effect of augmentation on conventional whole-molecule generation:
Shape and chemical similarity remain statistically unchanged, with confidence intervals centred near zero. This suggests that fragment augmentation has little to no effect on conventional generation, while the larger improvements arise from combining the augmented checkpoint with IFM inference.
3. Computational efficiency and molecular architectures
We compare IFM with conventional generation and inpainting using the same MOI-conditioned backbone to isolate the effect of the inference procedure.
On an NVIDIA L4 GPU with 4 CPU cores, generating 100 samples per reference across the full dataset, using 100 diffusion steps (including 10 merging steps for IFM), required:
Thus, IFM introduces a 6.1% increase in total generation time, indicating a relatively modest computational overhead.
Regarding molecular architectures, we consider the diversity of the reference dataset sufficient for the present feasibility study. We also argue that chemical-space coverage is difficult to interpret without a specific application or target distribution. We therefore consider application-driven evaluation of generated chemical space a more meaningful direction for future work.