- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SegDis, a unified framework for salient object detection (SOD) and camouflaged object detection (COD). The method decomposes three-class segmentation into task-agnostic foreground discovery and foreground-conditioned object-type discrimination. It introduces a Progressive Foreground Refinement System (PFRS), relation-conditioned type queries, and an uncertainty-boundary refinement mechanism. Experiments on USC12K demonstrate improvements over USCNet in overall mIoU and foreground mIoU, along with a reduction in saliency-camouflage confusion.
Critical strengths
1.The USC12K results are promising. Compared with USCNet, mIoU improves from 78.03 to 80.25 and CSCS drops from 7.49 to 3.27 (Table 1). The improvement in Scene-C camouflage IoU, from 45.73 to 51.60, is particularly relevant to the problem of detecting both object types in the same image.
2.The separation of foreground segmentation and object-type discrimination provides a reasonable approach to unified SOD and COD, particularly in scenes where both object types coexist.
Critical weaknesses
1.My main concern is how to attribute the largest gain in Table 2. E0 to E1 increases FG-mIoU from 64.874 to 70.867, but changes both the foreground factorization and the query head. Section 4.4 explicitly acknowledges this, so the result supports the combined change. It does not establish how much the factorization itself contributes. E0’s background prediction and losses are also insufficiently specified to assess how comparable the supervision is. A direct three-class head using the same PFRS, comparable head capacity, and matched foreground supervision would help establish the specific benefit of foreground-first prediction. This matters because the factorization is a central contribution of the paper.
2.A smaller concern is the stability of the component gains. Adding relation conditioning in E3 to E5 improves overall FG-mIoU from 71.049 to 71.819 and reduces CSCS from 3.362 to 3.275. Scene-C IoU-S changes from 74.017 to 73.819, and IoU-C from 51.724 to 51.605. These small differences do not establish a benefit or a degradation on Scene-C. The authors disclose that these are single runs and acknowledge the missing seed analysis. The remaining question is whether the aggregate improvement is consistent across runs; the current results provide only limited evidence on this point.
3.The experimental comparison lacks a comparison with some methods from 2025 and 2026, such as SAM2-UNet, VSCodeV2, CamoDiffusion, Samba, which limits the persuasiveness of the assessment.
Questions for authors
1.How are E0’s background prediction and training losses defined, and exactly how do they differ from E1? Is a direct three-class baseline with comparable head capacity and foreground supervision available?
2.Additional experimental evidence: Do you have repeated-run results for E3 and E5? These would help assess whether the gain from relation conditioning is reliable, both overall and on Scene-C.
3.Dividing first and then classifying is an intuitive approach. The technical contributions and innovations shoud be further hightlighed.
4.There is no explanation or discussion of the training strategy, whether it is end-to-end or two-stage training.