- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
S$^3$Therm predicts 3D steady temperature fields for changing volumetric heat sources under fixed geometry, conductivity, and Robin cooling. The source is reduced to finite-thickness sheets, each with a unit-peak footprint, a centroid height, and an amplitude. A shared height-conditioned branch–trunk operator, trained only from PDE and Robin residuals on individual synthetic sheets, predicts each sheet's response; amplitude-weighted responses are summed, rescaled for global energy balance, and symmetry-averaged. On held-out layouts scored at COMSOL plane samples, it outperforms supervised LANO and FactFormer on every layout; ablations examine the corrections and collapsing source heights into a single sheet.
Critical strengths
-
Single-sheet physics-informed training generalizes to multi-height layouts. With cross-interval addition and positive homogeneity in amplitude explicit before correction (Eqs. (2), (5)), the operator is trained on individual synthetic sheets (Sec. 4.3), yet the complete predictor has the lowest error on every held-out layout (Table 1). This is consequential because a model trained without paired temperature fields outperforms the evaluated supervised baselines in this fixed-physics setting.
-
Physically motivated inference-time corrections with modest latency overhead. Rescaling enforces discrete integral balance and averaging enforces in-plane equivariance (Eqs. (7)–(8)); together they give the lowest mean and worst-layout RMSE (Table 2), whereas applying both to LANO does not improve its accuracy (Sec. 5.3). This is consequential because the rescaling addresses a global source–boundary mismatch that local residual training can leave (Sec. 4.5).
Critical weaknesses
-
The benefit of the sheet decomposition over complete-source inputs is not isolated. The representation control supports resolving source heights over a single collapsed sheet (Sec. 5.3). However, no physics-informed operator using the complete-source input contrasted in Sec. 1 is compared, although DeepOHeat is named as particularly relevant (Sec. 2); this gap is distinct from the per-stage error separation acknowledged in Sec. 4.5. Moreover, without rescaling, the composed predictor is on average worse than both baselines (Tables 1–2). This is consequential because the conclusion presents the decomposition as a useful inductive bias (Sec. 6), yet its independent contribution to the advantage over supervised baselines, beyond the rescaling gain credited above, remains unclear.
-
The practical cost benefit is not established, and the representation-control protocol is unclear. Setting aside the acknowledged budgeted, native-resolution protocol (Sec. 5.1), repeated-solve cost motivates the work (Sec. 1), yet S$^3$Therm's training time is unreported and its inference time is compared with neither COMSOL nor the baselines (Table 2). The control's multi-sheet reference (Sec. 5.3) also falls below the Table 1 mean over the same layouts, with its checkpoints and settings unstated. This is consequential because these omissions limit assessment of the practical speedup and of how the control's effect relates to the main benchmark.
Questions for authors
- (Related to W1; suggested experiment.) On the existing held-out layouts, how does a physics-informed operator using complete-source input (e.g., the composite-volume branch input in Sec. 4.2) compare at comparable capacity, budget, and corrections?
- (Related to W2; clarification.) What is S$^3$Therm's training time relative to the baselines' budget (Sec. 5.1), and how do all methods' end-to-end inference times compare with COMSOL solve times on these layouts? Which checkpoints and corrections produce the Sec. 5.3 reference, and why does it differ from Table 1?
- (Related to S2; clarification.) How thick are components relative to (Eq. (4)), and does the lifted source, whose budget Eq. (7) closes, carry the COMSOL source's integrated power?
- (Related to S1; clarification.) How do the held-out stress layouts (Sec. 5.1), once reduced to sheets, compare with the synthetic training sheets in footprint shape and height, and which generator settings produce the latter (Sec. 4.3)?
- (Related to S1; suggested experiment.) Both baselines are attention-based; how does a standard convolution-based surrogate (e.g., a U-Net, or the FNO cited in Sec. 2), trained on the same paired layouts and budget, perform on the held-out layouts?
If any part of this review reflects a misunderstanding of the paper, I would appreciate the authors pointing it out, and I am happy to revise my assessment accordingly.
3 comments
Response to Reviewer 5ZSm (W1 and Question 4): Training-Source and Evaluation-Layout Distributions
Thank you for asking about the relationship between the evaluation layouts and the training source sheets. Because data acquisition remains difficult, the current data are still generated in COMSOL. For the 1 mm computational domain, the in-plane size of the rectangular training generator is 0.10 × 0.05 mm, while the evaluation rectangles have - and -direction sizes of 0.04--0.26 mm and 0.035--0.12 mm, respectively. Training also includes smooth random-field sources. Training source heights are sampled continuously in the normalized interval [0,1], and evaluation component centers lie in 0.18--0.82 mm.
Each evaluation source map is normalized before entering the operator, and its amplitude is applied to the predicted response. The normalized source-map distribution and source-amplitude range are therefore reported separately. The ten layouts contain 1--36 components at one or three heights, with the same in-plane pattern repeated at each occupied height. The experiment evaluates the shared operator on new spatial arrangements and cross-height compositions; the generator settings and evaluation ranges will be presented in the same table.
Response to Reviewer 5ZSm (W2, Question 2): Total Cost and Workloads for Response Reuse
Thank you for asking about the cost implications of training without paired labels and the workloads that benefit from response reuse. Omitting paired temperature-field labels reduces total cost. S3Therm takes 3.434 s per layout with an RMSE of 0.297787 K; FactFormer, LANO, and FNO take 2.056 s, 9.619 s, and 1.854 s, with RMSEs of 0.915161 K, 0.778929 K, and 0.831163 K, respectively. CPU finite volume takes 2.266 s with an RMSE of 0.050769 K on the coarser grid and 5.853 s with an RMSE of 0.046687 K on the finer grid. Among the learned models, S3Therm has the lowest measured RMSE.
The suitable workload is high-throughput design exploration: under fixed geometry and boundary conditions, many heat-source footprints, positions, and height combinations are compared while the same trained operator repeatedly reuses source-sheet responses. When paired COMSOL temperature labels are difficult or costly to obtain, the PDE/Robin training objective also removes this label requirement.
Response to Authors
I thank the authors for their careful answers to my questions. The multi-seed results resolve the inconsistency in Sec. 5.3 and confirm the benefit of retaining source heights, and the power trace answers my question on component thickness. However, the added timings show a CPU finite-volume solver to be both faster and more accurate on its coarser grid, and the comparison with a physics-informed operator using complete-source input is not addressed, so the practical benefit and the contribution of the decomposition remain unclear. I maintain my assessment of 2 (weak rejection).
Reviewer 5ZSm
Response to Reviewer 5ZSm (W2, Question 2): Numerical Consistency in Section 5.3
Thank you for identifying this inconsistency. When we expanded the experiments to three random seeds, we updated Tables 1 and 2 but overlooked the single-seed values in the four-layout source-representation paragraph in Sec. 5.3. The reported 0.296 K and 1.020 K are therefore single-seed results. We apologize for this oversight.
We have now evaluated both source representations using the same three trained models as in the main comparison. Within each training run, the model weights are held fixed between the two representations, and both use the same balance correction, symmetry averaging, and COMSOL evaluation coordinates. The control preserves the integrated in-plane footprint and discrete source budget while replacing the three retained heights by one power-weighted centroid. We first average the layout RMSEs over the four layouts for each seed, then compute the mean and sample standard deviation across the three seeds.
The updated mean RMSE is 0.393 ± 0.085 K with the source heights retained and 1.104 ± 0.188 K after centroid collapse. The RMSE increases for every layout under all three random seeds. Thus, the benefit of retaining the vertical source distribution is consistent across the three runs.
We will replace the single-seed values in Sec. 5.3, state the averaging procedure explicitly, and provide the per-seed results in the supplement. Table 2 will also identify the results as averages over three random seeds.
Response to Reviewer 5ZSm (Question 3): Component Thickness and Integrated Source Power
Thank you for requesting clarification of the component thickness and source power. The nominal lifted-sheet thickness matches the physical component thickness in our experiments. Each component is 0.05 mm thick. For the 1 mm domain, W=0.05 therefore corresponds to the same 50 μm thickness. The parameter P controls the maximum height interval used to group source slices, whereas W specifies the finite-thickness source whose response is learned. Their default normalized values coincide, but they enter different steps of the construction.
We traced the power from the specified component geometry through voxel encoding, sheet construction, and finite-thickness lifting. Across all ten layouts, the largest relative difference between the encoded-volume power and the lifted-sheet discrete budget is 4.3×10−8. Thus, sheet construction preserves the encoded source power to numerical precision in these experiments. Equation (7) balances this discrete source budget against the predicted boundary flux.
The distinction from the geometrically specified source power can be quantified. In Dense small blocks, the geometric power is 31.500 mW, voxel encoding gives 32.288913 mW, and the lifted-sheet discrete budget is 32.288914 mW. Integrating the bilinearly interpolated lifted source gives 32.418458 mW, 2.916% above the geometric power. The trace therefore identifies rasterization and integration as the sources of this discrepancy, while the sheet-construction step preserves the encoded budget.
We also evaluated the temperature effect directly on a common 500×500×120 finite-volume grid, solving for the response to the difference between the lifted and original block sources. The RMS temperature difference at the reference plane coordinates averages 0.0596 K over the ten layouts; the largest layout RMS is 0.3499 K for Dense small blocks. We will clarify P and W near Eq. (4), identify the discrete budget in Eq. (7), and add the power trace and temperature comparison to the supplement.
Response to Reviewer 5ZSm (W2, Question 2): Training Budgets under Different Supervision Protocols
Thank you for asking how to compare the budgets of supervised and physics-residual training. Data acquisition is difficult in this field, so the present study uses twelve labeled layouts within the available cost budget. S3Therm runs for 100,000 updates and minimizes the PDE and Robin boundary residuals on synthetic source sheets. Each run instantiates four successive pools of 2,000 sheets, with a simultaneous pool size of 2,000 and continuously sampled source height. The supervised baselines use COMSOL temperature labels from the twelve training layouts, with a nominal training budget of about 10 hours; checkpoints are selected according to the recorded training-loss criterion.
We separate training cost into label generation, data preprocessing, network optimization, and checkpoint selection, and report wall-clock time, GPU count, update count, and sampling scale on the same hardware. This presents label-generation, model-optimization, and model-selection costs separately, allowing the cost structures of supervised and physics-residual training to be compared directly.