- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GDDNO, a domain-decomposition neural operator for predicting PDE solutions on complex geometries and large meshes. The method partitions the computational domain into overlapping subdomains, employs a shared geometry-aware graph network to capture local interactions, and uses attention over compact subdomain tokens to exchange global information. Local features and global context are combined for field prediction, while overlap averaging and consistency losses coordinate predictions across subdomain boundaries. Experiments on AirfRANS, five RealPDEBench systems, and a three-dimensional reacting-flow dataset demonstrate improvements in prediction accuracy and selected physical quantities over existing neural operator baselines.
Critical strengths
- The integration of geometry-aware local graph operators, compact global token communication, and overlapping domain assembly provides a coherent approach to balancing local geometric detail and long-range interactions. Although the individual components are not entirely novel, their combination addresses a practically important challenge in neural PDE operators.
- The paper reports improvements across AirfRANS, five RealPDEBench systems, and a challenging 3D reacting-flow dataset, including substantial gains on full-field AirfRANS and improvements in engineering quantities. This breadth is particularly valuable because it suggests that the proposed architecture may generalize beyond a single PDE benchmark, provided the reported results can be verified.
Critical weaknesses
- Multiple numerical discrepancies appear across the paper. For example, Tables 6 and 7 report different R² and lift-coefficient errors for the same configuration (P=48, H=2), while Table 10 repeatedly labels the proposed model as "HPNO (ours)" rather than GDDNO. For the Foil task, the simulation-trained relative L2 error is reported as 0.0344 in the main text but 0.0360 in Table 3. These issues raise substantial concerns about experimental result management and reliability. Since the paper's main contribution is largely supported by empirical improvements, the authors should reconcile these discrepancies and provide verifiable experimental records.
- The proposed interface consistency loss penalizes differences between neighboring cell states without directly constraining numerical fluxes (Sections 3.2–3.5). Its connection to the claimed flux consistency is therefore unclear, and the penalty may suppress physically valid gradients. Furthermore, the ablation study (Section 4.2) does not isolate the contribution of global token communication or separately evaluate the overlap and interface losses. Consequently, the evidence does not adequately establish the necessity of the key architectural components or support the claimed physical consistency. More rigorous physical validation and targeted ablations are needed.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors clarify the inconsistencies in the reported experimental results? Tables 6 and 7 report different and Cl errors for the same configuration (P=48, H=2), while Table 10 repeatedly refers to the proposed model as "HPNO (ours)" rather than GDDNO. How can the authors ensure that the reported results correspond to the correct model and experimental configurations? Please provide corrected results and verifiable supporting evidence.
- How much does global token communication independently contribute to the performance gains? The current ablations do not evaluate the model without global attention, nor do they separately examine overlapping subdomains and interface consistency losses. Can the authors provide targeted ablations to establish which components are responsible for the improvements?
- What justifies interpreting the proposed interface consistency loss as a flux-consistency constraint? The loss penalizes differences between neighboring cell states rather than discrepancies in numerical fluxes. Since physically valid solutions can exhibit substantial gradients across adjacent cells, could this regularization introduce artificial smoothing? Can the authors justify its physical interpretation and evaluate its impact on conservation errors?
4 comments
Response to reviewer tjx4 (Q3, W2)
Q3: What justifies interpreting the proposed interface consistency loss as a flux-consistency constraint? The loss penalizes differences between neighboring cell states rather than discrepancies in numerical fluxes. Since physically valid solutions can exhibit substantial gradients across adjacent cells, could this regularization introduce artificial smoothing? Can the authors justify its physical interpretation and evaluate its impact on conservation errors?
W2: Furthermore, the ablation study (Section 4.2) does not isolate the contribution of global token communication or separately evaluate the overlap and interface losses.
We thank the reviewer for this insightful suggestion. In response, we have supplemented a more detailed continuity analysis of the predicted physical fields. Specifically, we evaluated four quantitative metrics,, , , and ,whose physical meanings are summarized below:
| Metrics | explanation |
|---|---|
| Net flux imbalance across the entire computational domain | |
| Volume-weighted average of cell divergence | |
| Mean net-flow imbalance of subdomains | |
| Relative error of subdomain interface flux compared to CFD ground truth |
Due to space limitations, their exact mathematical definitions and formulations are detailed in the revised manuscript Appendix D.5. The statistical results of these metrics are presented in the table below. As shown, GDDNO’s consistency strategy significantly improves both global and local flow field continuity as well as physical conservation, demonstrating the effectiveness of our two proposed constraints within the domain decomposition framework.
| Fields | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CFD | ||||
| \mathcal{L\}_{\mathrm{data}}+\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{interface}} | ||||
| Transolver | ||||
| Mondrian | ||||
| GDDNO |
Furthermore, to provide a more intuitive illustration, around Page 10, Line 500 of the revised manuscript, we have visualized the predicted fields with zoomed-in local details under three ablation settings: removing the overlap loss, removing the interface loss, and removing both. Severe discontinuities (or named fragmentation) clearly emerge across subdomain boundaries when these losses are omitted, confirming that both consistency losses substantially enhance the continuity and conservation of the solution.
Similarly, eegarding the reviewer's concern about potential artificial smoothing, sharp discontinuities in physical problems, most notably shock waves in supersonic flows, induce steep gradient variations. In numerical simulations, handling strong discontinuities inherently involves a certain degree of numerical dissipation due to discretization schemes and stability considerations. GDDNO captures fine grained local flow structures through its geometry-aware local operators, which largely preserves local features, including steep physical gradients, and avoids introducing excessive smoothing.
In fact, our cavity combustion task serves as strong evidence for this concern. This task is a 3D supersonic combustion case naturally characterized by complex shock waves and turbulence–chemistry interactions. Because GDDNO extracts fine-scale local flow features prior to global communication, the two consistency losses do not eliminate the flow discontinuities, while achieving substantially higher accuracy compared to other baselines (please refer to Figure 3(c), Figure4, Table 6, and Table 14 in the revised manuscript).
Finally, we sincerely appreciate the reviewer's rigor. We acknowledge that the current version of GDDNO does not directly enforce constraints on the numerical fluxes of the predicted solutions, and we have revised the corresponding statements in the manuscript. But we all think incorporating explicit numerical flux conservation is indeed a very promising direction, which we plan to explore in our future work.
Thanks to the authors for their detailed response and additional experiments. The new ablations provide useful evidence for the contributions of global communication and the consistency losses, which address some of my earlier concerns. I also appreciate the authors' efforts to clarify the numerical discrepancies and provide experimental logs.
However, I still have some reservations. The explanations for the numerical inconsistencies are plausible, but the repeated reporting issues make it difficult to fully restore confidence in the empirical results. In addition, while the new experiments show improvements in several conservation-related metrics, the interface loss does not directly enforce flux conservation, and its individual effects are mixed across different metrics.
Overall, the rebuttal has improved my assessment of the paper, but I do not think it fully resolves my main concerns. I will maintain my current rating, although I would not strongly oppose acceptance if the other reviewers find the additional evidence convincing.
Response to reviewer tjx4
Thank you for taking the time to assess the additional experiments, and for noting that our additional ablations and logs address part of the earlier concerns. We fully understand why repeated reporting discrepancies make it difficult to immediately restore full confidence in the results, and we appreciate your fair and constructive stance.
Why indirect consistency constraints is beneficial for flux/conservation and why individual effects are mixed:
As noted by the reviewer, GDDNO does not impose an explicit numerical-flux loss. However, in our evaluation (Appendix D.5), face flux is computed by interpolating the predicted velocity field onto mesh faces, and cell divergence aggregates these face fluxes.
Interface loss reducing artificial discontinuities across subdomain boundaries and overlap loss aligning overlapping predictions for shared cells, these two losses prevent mismatches that would distort interpolated fluxes and conservation residuals.(Refer to Figure 4 of the manuscript and Figure 2 in Supplementary-response.pdf) At the same time, our geometry-aware local graph encoder still captures genuine steep gradients, such as those in supersonic cavity combustion.
The effects of interface and overlap alone are mixed across metrics because each term's target is differen:
- Adding interface loss alone penalizes state differences across core boundaries and directly reduces interface flux error from 4.7221e-3 to 3.8355e-3 and overall Rel L2 from 0.0914 to 0.0886.
| Comparison | |
|---|---|
| Data-only → Data + interface | −18.8% |
- Adding overlap loss alone enforces agreement among local copies of shared cells, improving cell divergence residual (from 3.1638e-4 to 2.6985e-4), subdomain net-flow imbalance (from 5.9878e-4 to 5.1084e-4), and AirfRANS errors (pressure coefficient error, lift coefficient error, and relative L2 error), while having a smaller effect on cross-boundary interface flux error (4.6739e-3).
| Comparison | ||
|---|---|---|
| Data-only → Data + overlap | −14.7% | −14.7% |
- Combining both consistency losses with data loss coordinates shared-cell representations and cross-boundary transitions together, yielding the strongest results across all four conservation metrics as well as the main accuracy metrics. It also has a very large improvement compared to other baselines.
| Comparison | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CFD | ||||
| Data only | ||||
| Data+Interface+Overlap | ||||
| Improv | −39.9% | −19.4% | −4.8% | −42.8% |
| Comparison | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Transolver | ||||
| Mondrian | ||||
| Transolver → GDDNO | −87.3% | −97.1% | −95.2% | −98.8% |
| Mondrian → GDDNO | −82.1% | −77.0% | −62.7% | −93.4% |
We again thank Reviewer tjx4 for the thorough engagement and candid feedback throughout the discussion.
Response to reviewer tjx4 (W1,Q1, W2, Q2)
We sincerely apologize for these errors. The discrepancies in Tables 6 and 7 (now Table 7and 8) resulted from a keyboard shortcut failure when copying data from the experimental logs during manuscript preparation, while the inconsistency in the airfoil results was due to a manual writing error. We understand that these mistakes may have affected the reviewer's confidence in our results. To facilitate independent verification, we have uploaded our original experimental logs as supplementary materials. The original data for (P=48, H=2) reported in Tables 6 and 7 can be found in lines 6058–6070 of
of-metrics.json, while the airfoil results reported in Table 3 can be verified at line 68 ofeval.log.For the name HPNO, during the early development stage, we named the model "Halo Patch Neural Operator (HPNO)" to reflect our design of introducing overlapping boundaries between subdomains. We renamed the model to GDDNO only one week before the paper submission. Unfortunately, one of our co-authors had not updated their code branch to the new name in time and therefore continued to use the earlier one. The
eval.logfile also provides evidence of this naming history. We once again apologize for this oversight and have corrected the corresponding errors in the revised manuscript.Finally, we commit to publicly releasing the code within one month of paper acceptance. Due to the double-blind review requirements, we will provide the repository URL in the camera-ready version if the paper is accepted. The code included in the supplementary materials is already executable and provides the implementation needed to reproduce the reported experiments.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive suggestion. To thoroughly evaluate the contribution of our proposed components, we have conducted comprehensive ablation studies. We compared GDDNO with two variants: (a) a model replacing the cross-subdomain attention with a simple global pooling baseline, and (b) a model without any inter-subdomain communication. As shown in Table below, GDDNO reduces the overall relative L2 error from 0.0996 to 0.0816 and achieves the lowest Cp error among all settings. This demonstrates that our proposed communication mechanism is significantly more effective than uniform aggregation or isolated subdomains
We evaluated the individual and joint impacts of the interface and overlap losses. Incorporating either loss independently improves the prediction accuracy, and their combination further boosts the overall performance. This fully proves the effectiveness and complementarity of both consistency constraints.