- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the Green’s Observation Operator (GObO) for predicting PDE responses between lower-dimensional source and observation submanifolds coupled through an ambient medium. The method learns a medium-conditioned Green kernel represented by low-rank spatial factors and exponential temporal modes. This representation preserves linearity in the source, enables efficient reuse across different sources, and supports streaming prediction through a fixed-dimensional state. Experiments on three-dimensional heat conduction and advection–diffusion demonstrate generalization from stationary training sources to moving test sources and efficient repeated source evaluation, with a trade-off in in-distribution accuracy. Additional experiments investigate resolution transfer and extensions to selected nonlinear effects.
Critical strengths
-
A well-motivated perspective on a practically PDE problem: In many applications, observations are indeed available only on a lower-dimensional submanifold, while need to be predicted under varying source configurations. Focusing on the source to observation mapping directly addresses these practical requirements. This perspective provides a compelling motivation for learning a reusable operator that captures the influence of the ambient dynamics.
-
Generalization from stationary training sources to moving test sources: Models trained exclusively on stationary sources retain good predictive accuracy on moving sources without retraining, with substantial improvements over the evaluated black-box baselines. The results support the method’s potential utility for predicting responses to source configurations beyond those encountered during training.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited baseline comparisons: I recognize that predicting between submanifolds under varying sources presents challenges that many existing methods are not directly designed to address. Nevertheless, it would be valuable to explore additional comparisons with methods that can be reasonably adapted to this setting. Such comparisons would strengthen the empirical evidence for its advantages.
-
Lack of a complete method architecture diagram: Although Figure 4 illustrates the conditioning network, it does not show the full prediction pipeline. A complete architecture diagram, even if included in the appendix, would help readers understand how the individual components work together.
Questions for authors
-
Can GObO generalize to more spatially localized sources or sources with rapid temporal variation? In particular, does the model trained on the current stationary-source distribution retain its predictive accuracy under these changes without retraining?
-
The experiments focus on heat conduction and advection–diffusion. How applicable is the proposed framework to other propagation kernels? Could the authors discuss its expected performance and whether such settings would require changes to the kernel parametrization?
Dear reviewer, we thank you for your thoughtful feedback and positive assessment of our work, especially your recognition of the practical relevance of our setting.
To summarize, we addressed your concerns through:
Details are provided below. Changes to the revised paper are marked in blue. Further additions include expanded theory and ablations, mixed-source training, and curved-manifold experiments.
We believe these additions address your concerns and further strengthen the evidence for our method. We hope they will reinforce your positive assessment and support a higher rating. If any relevant concerns remain, we would greatly appreciate the opportunity to address them.
W1: Baseline Comparisons
The original paper already considered several complementary baselines: FNO-2D, FNO-3D, a backbone-matched spectral predictor, and NGO, together with a one-step variant using GObO's own backbone (Appendices E.1.1, E.3, F.2.1, and F.3.2). We now additionally include DeepONet, extending the comparison to another major neural operator architecture (Appendix F.2.1, Table 17). It also performs poorly on unseen moving sources.
Furthermore, we recognize the connection to DMD/Koopman methods and have added a discussion in Appendix A.1. In particular, our best linear one-step map experiment is closely related to DMDc and delay-embedded variants, as now discussed in Appendix F.3.2.
Together, these comparisons cover several neural operator architectures, a direct Green's operator competitor, and connections to classical data-driven dynamical models.
W2: Architecture Diagram
We appreciate this suggestion and agree that the complete prediction pipeline should be more clearly illustrated. We therefore added a full GObO pipeline diagram (Figure 6), showing how the medium is encoded, the kernel is constructed, and new sources are evaluated through batch or streaming prediction. Together with the existing detailed diagram of the conditioning network (Figure 5) and minor text clarifications, this now illustrates both the overall method and its individual components more clearly, improving readability (Appendix D.2–D.3).
Q1: Generalization to Other Sources
To directly investigate this question, we added zero-shot experiments with narrower spatial pulses, short temporal bursts, and pulse trains (Appendix F.2.1, Table 17). All models are evaluated without retraining on these new source distributions.
Narrow pulses cause severe failures for all models, demonstrating a limitation when sources are substantially more localized than in training. However, GObO retains low errors on short bursts (0.015) and pulse trains (0.010), compared with 0.261 and 0.084 for FNO-2D, respectively. Thus, GObO substantially outperforms the baselines on both types of rapid temporal variation.
Furthermore, we now show that GObO's generalization advantage persists even when training includes moving sources (Appendix F.2.5, Table 22). Together, these experiments strengthen the evidence that GObO generalizes beyond its training source distribution, while identifying extreme spatial localization as a remaining limitation for all models.
Q2: Other Propagation Kernels
GObO is not inherently restricted to heat conduction. The main requirements are linear, time-invariant dynamics admitting a suitable Green's kernel expansion with stable temporal rates. This includes other dissipative PDEs and potentially oscillatory systems such as damped wave equations.
Importantly, we already demonstrate such an adaptation for advection–diffusion, where complex conjugate rates accommodate oscillatory components while retaining the same kernel parametrization and streaming construction (Appendix D.4). This illustrates how different propagation mechanisms can be handled within the framework.
The expected accuracy, however, depends on the kernel spectrum. Diffusion strongly suppresses high-frequency modes, whereas wave propagation generally exhibits weaker spectral decay and may require more modes for comparable accuracy. Vector-valued systems may additionally require adapted spatial factors, while time-dependent media would require more substantial changes. Thus, the main expected limitation is approximation efficiency rather than applicability of the framework, provided the required spectral structure holds.
Further, added an experiment on nontrivial curved source and observation manifolds (Appendix F.2.3, Table 20). This provides further evidence that the framework applies beyond the original geometric settings.