W1. Insufficient statistical evidence for robust source-count extrapolation.
A major concern is the limited statistical support for the real-world evaluation. According to Appendix Table 2, the test set contains only three higher-source configurations, corresponding to three, four, and six active fans. Each source count is represented by only one configuration, while source locations, operating conditions, and pairwise interactions also differ across these configurations.
Consequently, the observed performance differences cannot be attributed solely to increasing source count. The evaluation also does not establish whether the proposed method can consistently generalize across different configurations containing the same number of active sources.
Furthermore, the reported standard deviations are computed across five random training seeds rather than independent test configurations. Although these results characterize training variability, they do not capture uncertainty arising from variations in physical configurations. The approximately 10% MAE improvement over the strongest baseline (0.183 vs. 0.203 m/s) is promising, but its robustness across independent configurations remains unclear.
This limitation is particularly relevant because different configurations were measured in separate sessions, and the measurements themselves are subject to instrumental uncertainty. Although the numerical experiments provide broader configuration coverage, they cannot fully compensate for the limited statistical evidence from the real-world evaluation.
W2. Limited empirical support for the proposed scale-conditioned compositional mechanism.
The paper's main methodological contribution lies in combining separate source/pair attention with spectrally constrained residual reconstruction. However, the controlled numerical experiments provide limited evidence that these components consistently improve source-count extrapolation.
According to Appendix Table 8, separate attention achieves an MAE of 0.070 compared with 0.071 for joint attention, indicating only a marginal improvement. Similarly, removing spectral band restrictions slightly improves MAE from 0.070 to 0.069. Although the authors report improvements in other metrics and frequency components, the overall MAE results do not demonstrate a consistent advantage for these two central design choices.
Furthermore, the scale-resolved analysis indicates that 97.7% of the six-source MSE reduction relative to the reference field comes from the DC and lowest-frequency components. While this observation is informative, it does not establish that the proposed scale-conditioned relational composition is necessary to obtain these improvements. Simpler global or low-frequency correction models might achieve similar benefits.
The measurement-domain ablations suggest that separate attention and spectral constraints improve performance, but these results are based on only three higher-source configurations. Consequently, the strongest evidence supporting the proposed architectural components comes from the statistically limited part of the evaluation.
Overall, the current experiments do not sufficiently isolate the contribution of scale-conditioned composition from simpler alternatives, such as low-frequency residual correction or general spectral regularization.
W3. Underperformance of the full model on numerical benchmarks and unclear model-variant selection.
Another major concern is the inconsistency between the claimed effectiveness of the framework and the numerical benchmark results.
According to Appendix Table 6, the full ScaleComposer model achieves an MAE of 0.070, which is substantially worse than several competing methods, including DeltaPhi-DeepONet (0.047), Ref+GNOT (0.053), Ref+FNO (0.054), and Ref+GINO (0.054).
Removing output reference addition improves ScaleComposer's numerical MAE to 0.047, matching DeltaPhi-DeepONet. However, this variant does not consistently outperform the baselines across all metrics. For example, its PCC of 0.798 remains below Ref+GNN (0.850) and Ref+GNOT (0.836).
These results raise an important concern regarding the general effectiveness of the proposed framework. The full reference-assisted model performs best on real-world measurements, whereas removing output reference addition substantially improves its performance in the numerical experiments. Importantly, the reference-free output variant only removes the final addition of the reference field; reference-related information remains available to the model. Thus, this ablation evaluates the contribution of output reference addition rather than completely removing prior information.
Although the paper acknowledges this domain-dependent behavior, it does not establish a clear criterion for selecting the appropriate model variant before evaluating higher-source test configurations. If the choice between variants is informed by their performance on higher-source test sets, the reported results may reflect test-dependent model selection rather than a predefined, reproducible prediction framework. This does not establish that such selection occurred, but the selection protocol should be explicitly clarified.
Without a validation-based selection criterion or a systematic analysis of reference-field quality, it remains unclear under which conditions the full ScaleComposer model can be expected to outperform existing baselines.
Response to Reviewer Dbd1
We appreciate the positive and constructive comments from you! We have modified our paper according to your comments.
We appreciate this concern and agree that evaluation within a single physical environment limits the generalizability that can be established experimentally. Please refer to the general response 2.
Thank you for these suggestions. We have added both ablations. Table 8 details their constructions, while Tables 9 and 10 report their results on the measurement and numerical datasets, respectively. We also discuss these findings in general response 3.1 and have updated Section 5. Results and Analysis of the manuscript accordingly.
(1) Fan-only's difference to fan + pair variant
In the original submission, we evaluated the combined source–pair representation without separately isolating the contribution of pair tokens. We agree that this comparison is important for understanding the role of explicit pairwise representations, and this omission made it difficult to assess its contribution. As stated in general response 3.1.1, we have therefore added a SourceOnly variant that retains fan attention but removes the pair representation. On measurement, its MAE rises from 0.180 to 0.205 m/s (+13.9%) and the PCC falls from 0.798 to 0.745. The across-seed standard deviation of MAE also increases from 0.009 to 0.025 m/s. On the numerical benchmark, PCC decreases from 0.871 to 0.849. These results indicate that explicit pairwise representations improve prediction accuracy and stability. While fan tokens represent individual sources, pair tokens additionally encode relative geometry and operating conditions between sources, providing information relevant to their interactions.
(2) "Compare their sigmoid with the 1 + G denominator to a standard softmax"
We have added a variant using standard softmax over valid items. As stated in general response 3.1.2, its measurement MAE increases from 0.180 to 0.188 m/s, while its numerical PCC decreases from 0.871 to 0.851. The motivation for our normalization is particularly relevant to extrapolation across source counts. For two-fan training samples, there is only one valid pair token. Standard softmax therefore assigns it a weight of one regardless of its attention score, providing no gradient through the attention weighting for that single pair. At test time, however, configurations with up to six fans introduce as many as fifteen pair tokens, whose softmax weights must share a fixed total of one.
In contrast, our sigmoid-based normalization with the 1 + G denominator retains score-dependent weighting even for a single pair and does not constrain the aggregate weight of valid pair tokens to equal one. This allows the model to adjust the contribution of pairwise information as the number and relevance of source pairs change. The observed improvements support this normalization choice for extrapolation to larger source configurations.