1. Mathematical correctness and stability analysis
Several mathematical results appear inconsistent with the proposed equations. In particular, Lemma 4 seems to omit the starvation throttling factor e(H∗) from the equilibrium expression for healthy adult bees. Lemma 2 appears to characterize points as saddle equilibria that are not necessarily equilibria, and Lemma 3 seems to require additional assumptions for stability. Furthermore, the numerical equilibrium reported for Lemma 1 does not appear to match the provided parameters. Could the authors clarify these discrepancies and demonstrate that the reported analytical results, numerical calculations, and implementation are consistent? Do any corrections affect the conclusions?
2. Computation of the 95% confidence intervals
How were the reported 95% confidence intervals in Figure 1 calculated? Do they represent uncertainty in the estimated parameters, model predictions, or something else? Were these intervals evaluated for empirical coverage on held-out observations? This is important for assessing the statistical reliability of the reported forecasting results.
3. Data collection methodology and measurement precision
Could the authors explain how the hive inspection measurements were collected and converted into numerical values? I examined the released dataset and noticed that some bee-frame measurements contain up to four decimal places. How was this level of precision obtained from manual inspections? Are these direct observations, estimates, interpolated measurements, or processed values? I would also appreciate clarification on how mite infestation measurements were converted into the model's representation of mite-infected bee frames.
4. Quantitative forecasting results and transferability
Could the authors provide exact numerical forecasting errors, preferably with variability across individual hives, rather than relying primarily on graphical comparisons? Additionally, the transferability experiment uses parameters estimated from six hives and applies them to eleven additional hives. Were these datasets collected from the same geographical location or under similar environmental conditions? How much target-hive observation data is required for initialization, and is the forecast horizon one day or the interval until the next inspection? These details would help determine the extent to which the results demonstrate generalizability.
5. Biological validity of the estimated parameters and hypothetical scenarios
The authors emphasize that the model parameters have biological interpretations and can be checked against expected ranges. However, Table 2 reports values for c7′ and c8′ that fall outside their stated ranges. Could the authors explain these discrepancies and whether the imposed parameter relationships are biologically justified? Additionally, is there any independent evidence supporting the quantitative outcomes of the what-if scenarios, particularly changes in larval populations resulting from different egg-laying rates?
These are clarification requests concerning the manuscript's central claims rather than suggestions for future work. The responses, particularly regarding mathematical correctness, uncertainty estimation, and data collection, could materially affect my final assessment.
Q1. (a) We updated Lemma 4 to match the revised equation set (7) - (14). Please refer to Section 3.3.1.
(b) Please refer to Appendix A.3 for the proof of Lemma 2
(c)Please refer to Appendix A.4 for the proof of Lemma 3
(d)We thank the reviewer for this observation, and we have addressed the comment. Please refer to Section 3.1.1 in the revised manuscript.
(e) None of the corrections affect the conclusions.
Q2. The shaded band in Figure 1 in our original submission was computed by x^±1.96σ/n where x^ is the forecasted point, σ is the standard deviation of the reconstruction errors, and n is the window size. It reflects the uncertainty of the mean reconstruction error over the window. Therefore, it is not expected to contain 95% of new observations, and it should have been described explicitly as a confidence interval for the mean reconstruction error. In the revision, we replace this band with x^±σ which reflects the 68% prediction interval. We also report the empirical coverage in Appendix A.8. In summary, 50-100% of our forecasts fall in this band (Table A10).
Q3. (a) Colony inspections were conducted approximately every two to three weeks. For each hive, the beekeeper records the number of frames covered by honey, larvae (brood), and adult bees, as integer frame counts, together with a mite measurement (alcohol wash, as a percentage of bees sampled).
(b) Values with decimals (up to four places) are linearly interpolated between consecutive inspections to obtain a regular time grid. They are not direct measurements.
(c) Mite infection intensities were quantified using the alcohol wash method, which is widely used by beekeepers to monitor and manage Varroa infestations. Briefly, we collected a subsample of approximately 400 adult worker bees from each colony and counted the number of V. destructor mites recovered from these bees. This provided an estimate of mite infection intensities, expressed as the average number of mites per sampled bee. DynaBee models the honey bee colony at the population level, treating it as a superorganism rather than tracking individual bees. Accordingly, the model variable (B_M) represents the population of mite-infested adult bees, expressed in equivalent bee frames. To convert the empirical measurements into mite intensities, we assumed that each recovered mite corresponded to one infested adult worker. We then multiplied the observed mite-to-bee ratio by the total number of frames occupied by adult bees (B): Mite infested bee frame B_M = Total bee frame B × (no of mites / bees sampled).
We added this explanation as a footnote in Section 5. Q4. (a) We have added Tables A2-A9 (appendix A.7) reporting RMSE for each method on every individual hive, for both Dataset 1 and Dataset 2.
(b) Yes, both datasets were collected from the same geographical location and under similar environmental conditions. We added this explanation in Section 5.
(c) For initialization, we use the inspection data from six hives in the first dataset. For each hive, the first four recorded inspection points, together with eight linearly interpolated points for H, L, B_M , and B_H , are used for parameter estimation.
The forecast horizon is the next inspection point, corresponding to a prediction horizon of approximately two to three weeks, which matches the scheduled hive inspection interval Q5. (a) The ranges listed for (c'_7) and (c'_8) in Table 2 were transcription errors. We updated the table.
(b) We do not have independent empirical evidence (e.g., controlled experiments varying queen egg-laying rate) that validates the quantitative outcomes of the what-if scenarios, and we do not claim that they are predictive of real colonies. The scenarios are intended as simulation, model-based explorations: they show how the model’s state variables respond when c4 is varied, so that domain experts can judge whether the direction and relative size of the response is biologically plausible.