- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ForeCAD, an autoregressive framework for CAD program generation that explicitly models latent geometric states and transitions before generating CAD features. It introduces geometric supervision for state and transition representations and a Representation-Guided Execution Alignment (RGEA) strategy optimization stage. Experiments on Procedural Construction and DeepCAD-Complex show improvements over several baselines in geometric reconstruction and execution success.
Critical strengths
1.The paper addresses the important challenge of generating executable CAD programs that produce geometrically accurate shapes.
2.The explicit geometric supervision and execution-based alignment provide a structured approach to incorporating geometric information into CAD generation.
3.The experiments evaluate both geometric reconstruction quality and program execution success.
Critical weaknesses
-
Necessity of the proposed formulation. Both ForeCAD and an execution-feedback-based agent aim to improve CAD generation using geometric information. However, the latter can directly execute CAD operations and use the resulting geometry to guide subsequent decisions. The paper does not sufficiently justify why explicitly predicting latent geometric transitions is preferable to this alternative.
-
Generalization to complex objects. The current benchmarks do not sufficiently establish whether ForeCAD generalizes to substantially more complex geometric structures beyond the patterns represented in its training data. Evaluations on more diverse and structurally challenging objects would strengthen the paper.
-
Contribution of the transition representation. It remains unclear how accurately predicting latent geometric transitions translates into better discrete CAD feature generation. The authors should provide more direct evidence linking transition prediction quality to final reconstruction performance.
Questions for authors
See weakness