- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3(+1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CAD-WAM, a text-to-CAD generation framework that combines autoregressive CAD operation generation with geometric state prediction. The method encodes intermediate CAD geometries into latent representations using a pretrained VAE and jointly predicts the next CAD operation and its resulting geometric state through a shared LLM backbone. During inference, generated operations are executed through a CAD kernel, and the resulting geometry is used to guide subsequent generation. The authors construct stepwise training trajectories from DeepCAD and evaluate the method against task-specific CAD models and general-purpose LLMs.
Critical strengths
- Well-motivated and technically sound approach. The proposed framework is coherent and addresses the limitations of autoregressive CAD generation by incorporating geometric feedback and next-state supervision.
- Strong experimental performance. CAD-WAM achieves convincing improvements over competitive baselines across multiple geometric metrics, particularly on longer construction sequences.
- Comprehensive experimental evaluation. The paper includes comparisons against recent CAD generation methods and general-purpose LLMs, along with reasonable ablation studies demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed components.
Critical weaknesses
- Novelty. Although the framework is technically sound, several of its core components appear closely related to existing research. cad-specific tokenization and command-sequence modeling have been extensively explored in previous works, including Text2CAD, FlexCAD, and CAD-Tokenizer. Similarly, using VAE-based representations to encode geometry is a relatively established technique. Overall, I find the methodological contributions somewhat incremental, and the paper would benefit from a clearer justification of its novelty.
- Limited experimental scope. The evaluation is conducted exclusively on DeepCAD, which primarily contains relatively simple sketch-and-extrude operations. Given the increasingly saturated performance on this benchmark, additional experiments on more challenging datasets would strengthen the paper's claims regarding generalizability.
- Lacking qualitative examples of text-to-cad generation.
Overall, I think it is a purely borderline work. The content is quite solid, but the contribution is incremental and I am not sure if I genuinely learned something other than "this work is the best on benchmark xxx". It would make perfect sense and be a clear accept if it was evaluated by a second-tier conference, but I am just not sure that the requirements of insights and novelty are the same for ICLR. I am giving a 2 for initial score and set my confidence low, and would be very happy to hear from the authors.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors provide more qualitative samples? Specifically, the input prompts should be included with the demonstrations.
- How would the authors place the work among all the previous works? Where is the novelty coming from?