- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents SAGE-RSS for semantic segmentation across multiple radar views. The method is motivated by the observation that sparse radar evidence can be lost in different ways during encoding, fusion across views, and decoding. It introduces three dedicated modules to capture target support at multiple scales, combine global context with local details, and reconstruct structures specific to each view. Experiments on CARRADA show competitive results in both Range Doppler and Range Angle views.
Critical strengths
The paper presents a unified design logic. Encoding, fusion, and decoding address support at different scales, global and local context, and reconstruction adapted to each view, respectively. This organization by processing stage is intuitive. The combination of PSE, GLFR, and CCAD forms a coherent and relatively complete system.
Critical weaknesses
-
The technical presentation is confusing and contains many inconsistencies between the text, equations, and figures. The raw input is defined as , while PSE suddenly assumes without explaining the dimensional transition. Equation 1 computes the third PSE branch from , whereas Figure 3 appears to use . For CCAD, Equation 8 obtains the memory tokens through a fixed slice, whereas Figure 3 depicts a Top-K ranking. These discrepancies leave the actual architecture unclear and make the method difficult to reproduce.
-
The ablation study is not described sufficiently. Table 3 only indicates which of PSE, GLFR, and CCAD are enabled, but does not explain what structure replaces each removed module. It also lacks internal ablations for the PSE identity route, kernels, and SE gates, the GLFR global and local branches and frequency weights, and the CCAD context branch, anchor settings, and directional kernels. It is unclear which specific design choices produce the reported gains.
-
The evaluation does not directly support the core sparse evidence hypothesis. The motivation emphasizes weak pedestrian and cyclist returns, variation in target support, and the risk of erasing local peaks. The paper reports only aggregate mIoU/mDice, without IoU reported separately for pedestrians, cyclists, and cars or analyses stratified by target scale, sparsity, or signal strength. The qualitative evaluation is also limited to a single car example.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors clarify the tensor flow around PSE and resolve the inconsistencies between the equations and figures for PSE and CCAD?
-
What architecture is used as the baseline in Table 3, and what replaces each removed module? Please also provide ablations of the main internal design choices.
-
Could the authors report results for each class and analyses by target scale, sparsity, or signal strength, together with more examples of small target classes?