- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a “Seed–Diffuse–Refine” unsupervised camouflaged object detection framework based on reliability screening: first, reliable seeds are screened using SAM3’s rejection mechanism; next, a diffusion segmentation head learns the camouflage structure; then, SAM3 is used for boundary refinement; and finally, the segmentation model is trained via geometric-semantic bilateral distillation. The framework achieved leading results on COD10K, CAMO, and NC4K.
Critical strengths
The author's line of reasoning is well-considered, but it overlooks an understanding of basic unsupervised tasks.
Critical weaknesses
Unsupervised tasks cannot rely on foundation models trained under fully supervised conditions, such as SAM3 and the PVT architecture. If that were possible, why not simply feed the data directly into SAM and have it generate the segmentation? The authors have completely overlooked the definition of “unsupervised”; processing can be based on foundation models like DINO, so I tend to reject this claim, and the rebuttal process cannot resolve this issue.
Questions for authors
Unsupervised tasks cannot rely on foundation models trained under fully supervised conditions, such as SAM3 and the PVT architecture. If that were possible, why not simply feed the data directly into SAM and have it generate the segmentation? The authors have completely overlooked the definition of “unsupervised”; processing can be based on foundation models like DINO, so I tend to reject this claim, and the rebuttal process cannot resolve this issue.