- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Given multiview videos, the proposed method reconstructs dynamic hair strands, including its appearance. It consists of two parts: a) coarse strand generation module and b) refinement module that optimizes for Gaussian SH color. A coarse strand generation module adds K-Plane features over scalp UV and time to features from a U-Net over the UV grid. It decodes them into strand geometry with the frozen geometry decoder of Gaussian Haircut. Training uses L1, mask, orientation, strand-smoothness, scalp-SDF and temporal-smoothness losses. The method is evaluated on 6 subjects on Nersemble dataset. It is compared to 4DGS, GaussianAvatars and Gaussian Head Avatar using PSNR/SSIM/LPIPS, with an ablation of three components.
Critical strengths
- Explicit, strand-based dynamic hair is useful for avatars than unstructured Gaussians. The hairstyle-transfer demo (Fig. 9) hints at reusable assets.
- The paper is generally easy to follow.
Critical weaknesses
-
[Not enough qualitative results] There is not enough qualitative results. Table-1 states that metrics are averaged over six NeRSemble subjects, however there is not enough video results. The video includes only single actor.
-
[Marginal Improvement] The abstract states the method “outperforms state-of-the-art methods by a significant margin” (L040-041). In Tab. 1 the PSNR gain over GaussianAvatars is 0.25 dB (31.59 vs 31.34)
-
[Efficiency motivation not supported] The motivation is that other dynamic-hair methods are costly (L055-058), and the abstract claims a balance of “optimization efficiency”. No training time, memory, or rendering speed is compared with any baseline. The appendix only mentions ~12 hours for 20k strands.
-
The “dynamic” aspect is not tested. Evaluation uses one held-out view of the training frames, so it measures view interpolation of a per sequence fit. There are no held-out time steps.
Questions for authors
- Fig. 1 shows GaussianAvatars at 20.92 dB, about 10 dB below its Tab. 1 average of 31.34. Could authors clarify whether this is an outlier subject?
- Would it be possible for authors to show the inner part of the hair?
8 comments
A Gentle Reminder Regarding Our Rebuttal and Revised Manuscript
Dear Reviewer,
As we approach the end of the discussion period, we hope you have had time to review our rebuttal and revised manuscript. If our responses have adequately addressed your concerns, we would sincerely appreciate it if you could consider updating your rating. Otherwise, we would be grateful for any further feedback on the remaining issues.
Thank you very much for your time and thoughtful feedback.
Concerns are addressed, quality is still limited
Dear authors, thank you for your detailed answers! Thanks for sharing the additional videos, especially comparison_2x5_4s.mp4. Some of my concerns have been addressed. I have a follow-up question: By 'inner part of the hair' I meant the hair gaussians without head to see how the internal Gaussians look like. Would it be possible to render the hair Gaussians only?
Regarding the evaluation, I'm happy to increase my score if other reviewers have a strong argument, because the quality of the hair appearance seems blurry to me.
First Rebuttal for Reviewer Cw5x
Thank you for your review. We provide the following explanations to address your concerns.
Response to W1
A: Thank you for the suggestion. We have added the supplementary video
comparison_2x5_4s.mp4, showing rendered appearance and 3D strand motion for five subjects, alongside the seven-subject appearance and geometry results in appendix Figs. 8–9. These results demonstrate detailed hair appearance and coherent strand motion across the presented subjects and hairstyles, providing broader qualitative support for the robustness of our reconstruction.Response to W2
A: We agree that the average PSNR gain over GaussianAvatars is modest (0.25 dB), and the phrase “by a significant margin” was too strong. Table 1 also shows a reduction in LPIPS from 0.0896 to 0.0764 (14.7%), although our SSIM is lower. Together with the reconstruction of explicit time-varying strand geometry, these results describe our contribution more accurately. We have revised the abstract accordingly.
Response to W3
A: Thank you for this comment. Our efficiency motivation concerns motion-history encoding: methods such as DynHair use an LSTM to process a temporal window through recurrent state updates, introducing sequential computation. Our representation directly queries strand geometry and appearance from UV coordinates and time, avoiding this recurrent history-encoding step. We agree that our original wording overstated the efficiency implications and have moderated the abstract and introduction to present this as a design motivation. The approximately 12-hour training time reported in the appendix documents our computational cost.
Response to W4
A: Our objective is to recover a dynamic hair asset from a given multi-view video, including temporally corresponding strands and their changing geometry and appearance. The held-out-view evaluation assesses appearance fidelity. Fig. 7 and the supplementary video
comparison_2x3.mp4compare our method with the variant without K-Plane, showing hair deformation relative to the head, while Table 3 quantifies motion smoothness and stability. Together, these evaluations support coherent reconstruction of the observed hair motion throughout the captured sequence. More broadly, a common approach to hair-motion modeling predicts hair states from motion conditions and temporal history, without direct temporal interpolation. For example, NeuWigs evolves the previous hair state using recent head motion and gravity, while DynHair predicts deformation of a canonical hairstyle from an LSTM encoding of head-motion history.Response to Q1
A: The 20.92 dB PSNR in Fig. 1 is computed for the single image shown in the teaser, while Table 1 reports results averaged over six subjects. As visible in Fig. 1, the hair boundary reconstructed by GaussianAvatars is misaligned with the GT boundary in this example, contributing to its pixel-wise reconstruction error. We evaluate reconstruction quality in the hair region. We hope this clarifies the difference between the score for the illustrated image and the aggregate results in Table 1.
Response to Q2
A: We have added internal hair visualizations in the final part of the appendix, “Internal Hair Structure” (Fig. 11). We apply a cutting plane to the hair on the right side of the visualization, rendering the hair above the plane normally and the hair below it semi-transparently. This reveals the internal strands while preserving the overall hairstyle structure, with an enlarged view showing their geometric details.