- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a conditional EDM-based 3D image restoration framework to address mild motion artifacts in head CT images, which are sparsely distributed and often mixed with normal anatomical structures. The method constructs a discriminator response field (DRF) using the input gradients of an artifact discriminator and employs spatial differential attention (SDA) to guide restoration. Semantic structure anchoring (SSA) and a spectral amplitude matching loss are further introduced to preserve anatomical structures and image details. Experiments on simulated data with varying artifact severity, public datasets, and real-world data demonstrate improvements in most reconstruction metrics.
Critical strengths
- The problem is practically important, with clear motivation. Correcting mild motion artifacts requires both local artifact removal and preservation of normal anatomical structures. The proposed method addresses these two challenges through complementary guidance and constraint mechanisms.
- The reconstruction results are competitive, with comprehensive ablation studies. On data with mild artifacts, the method reduces brain-region MAE from 23.43 HU (EDM) to 18.12 HU. The authors also evaluate different combinations of components and use the same backbone architecture and number of sampling steps for diffusion and flow-based models, making the comparisons more interpretable.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited methodological novelty. The framework combines input-gradient saliency, attention biasing, and pretrained feature alignment. While this combination is well motivated, the methodological contribution beyond these existing techniques is not sufficiently established.
-
Insufficient validation of artifact localization. Classifier input gradients reflect sensitivity to the classification decision and do not necessarily identify artifact regions. The paper lacks quantitative localization analysis demonstrating that DRF reliably distinguishes motion artifacts from normal anatomical structures.
-
Unclear connection between SDA and selective correction. Equation (6) introduces a query-independent bias over key positions, which changes feature aggregation but does not directly control which output regions are modified. Further analysis is needed to establish that this mechanism produces spatially selective correction.
-
Insufficient evidence for anatomical preservation. Reference-based metrics are reported only on motion-corrupted slices, without separately evaluating unaffected slices or unaffected regions within corrupted slices. Consequently, improved reconstruction scores alone do not substantiate the central claim of preserving normal anatomy and reducing overcorrection.
-
Limited validation on real clinical data. Real-world evaluation relies solely on FID and KID, which measure distributional similarity but cannot establish lesion preservation or anatomical fidelity. Reader studies or lesion-focused evaluations are needed to support the method’s clinical utility.
Questions for authors
The same as the weaknesses.
Response to Reviewer 6K3f
We thank the reviewer for the accurate summary and the constructive weaknesses, which have directly shaped our revision. Please see our point-by-point responses below.
W1: Limited methodological novelty. We respectfully clarify that our contribution is the framework formulation for the under-explored problem of mild motion artifact correction, not the individual techniques: (1) we convert artifact-discriminative knowledge into an explicit slice-selection prior via input gradients and inject it as an attention bias (new in motion artifact correction to our knowledge); (2) we adapt representation alignment to anchor a 3D CT diffusion restoration process to artifact-free anatomical features, which empirically prevents over-correction (Tables 1, S4).
W2: Insufficient validation of artifact localization. We agree with the reviewer. Classifier input gradients reflect the sensitivity of the classification decision rather than directly identifying artifact regions, and we have revised the manuscript accordingly. Specifically, the claims throughout the paper (Abstract, §3.1–3.3, Conclusion) have been reworded: the DRF is now described as an explicit slice-selection prior with a structure-sensitive response on gated slices, instead of as a spatial localization map of artifact regions. In addition, the revision provides quantitative validation of this gating function: the slice-level artifact discriminator attains AUPRCs of 0.9942, 0.9996, and 0.9900 on the Mild, Severe, and SynthRAD2023 test splits (new Suppl. §1.3, Table S3, Fig. S2), and artifact-free slices receive an exactly zero prior, keeping them outside the SDA gate by construction.
W3: Unclear connection between SDA and selective correction. We have added direct analyses of this connection in the revision. The new whole-volume evaluation (Suppl. Table S4) quantifies modifications to unaffected anatomy: our Mild whole-volume SSIM (0.9677) exceeds the uncorrected input (0.9556), whereas all generic baselines fall below it. The new real-data difference maps (Fig. 5) visualize where the output changes: modifications concentrate at artifact-affected boundaries while parenchyma is preserved. Mechanistically, the selectivity is realized along the axial direction by the DRF prior. Artifact-free slices receive an exactly zero response, so SDA applies no bias there, and the conditional sampler, which targets the posterior mean of the clean volume given the motion input, returns those slices essentially unchanged. The bias therefore does not need to directly control output regions; it gates which slices may be modified and steers aggregation on the gated slices.
W4: Insufficient evidence for anatomical preservation. We have added this evaluation. New Suppl. §2.1 (Table S4) reports metrics over the entire volume, which is dominated by unaffected slices and regions, and §2.2 (Fig. S3) reports per-case distributions. On the Mild Dataset, our whole-volume SSIM (0.9677) is higher than the uncorrected inputs (0.9556), whereas most generic baselines fall below the inputs (e.g., EDM 0.9441); on the Public Dataset, our framework attains the best whole-volume results across both regions; on the Severe Dataset, it remains best or second in most columns (e.g., brain-region MAE 24.15 and SSIM 0.8907, the best among all methods).
W5: Limited validation on real clinical data. We agree with the reviewer and have added the following in the revision: (1) Radiologist reader study (new Table 3, §4.5.2). Two radiologists blindly rated 72 pairs of motion-corrupted vs. corrected volumes; both assigned significantly lower interference scores after correction (median 3.0→2.0 and 3.5→3.0; Holm-corrected p = 0.005 and 0.014); (2) Real-data visualization with difference maps (new Fig. 5, §4.5.3, ±50 HU scale). The difference maps show that corrections are confined to artifact-affected boundaries while parenchyma is preserved.