- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents SUGAR, a framework that jointly reconstructs PET activity and aligns a CT-derived attenuation map using TOF-PET measurements. It addresses a practical problem: when CT and PET are misaligned, errors in attenuation correction can be absorbed into the reconstructed activity, and aligning the images afterward may not remove those errors. SUGAR represents the CT attenuation map as a frozen neural field and adjusts its sampling coordinates through a global transformation and a local deformation network. A separate neural field models PET activity. The method introduces three designs to guide optimization: removing rigid-motion components from the local deformation, separating activity coefficients into magnitude and mixture weights, and gradually introducing finer spatial features. Experiments on BrainWeb and XCAT phantoms show improved reconstruction quality over the evaluated baselines at both normal and low count levels. Additional controlled experiments examine how these designs affect geometry recovery, optimization speed, and early activity compensation. The results are promising, although validation remains largely based on simulated measurements.
Critical strengths
1.Well-motivated problem and formulation. The paper addresses a practical issue in PET reconstruction: a misaligned CT attenuation map can introduce activity errors that subsequent image registration may not remove. Jointly estimating activity and attenuation geometry through the emission model is a sensible approach.
2.Coherent optimization design. The three components address identifiable difficulties: redundancy between global and local motion, coupling between coefficient magnitude and composition, and early compensation for attenuation errors by the activity field. The full factorial ablation is useful for examining how these components interact.
Critical weaknesses
1.Evidence for reliable geometric recovery is limited. The trained gauge-correction comparison uses only one phantom and one seed. Moreover, rotation in normalized coordinates does not generally represent physical rigid motion when box side lengths differ. The deformation has no invertibility guarantee, and the PET/MR extension reports folding and out-of-box queries. These issues make it difficult to conclude that improved PET images consistently reflect correct alignment.
2.The experimental comparisons leave important uncertainties. Joint-Motion and FastMCPET undergo substantial task-specific adaptations, but their training, tuning, and computational budgets are insufficiently documented. The main evaluation uses simulated measurements with simplified acquisition physics, while the PET/MR study is not an independent test-set evaluation. The composition of the ten main reconstructions and the variability of the factorial ablation also need clarification.
Questions for authors
1.Compared with existing implicit neural representation, registration, joint reconstruction, and coarse-to-fine optimization methods, what is the indispensable new mechanism of SUGAR beyond combining these established components?
2.Beyond reducing redundancy, can the sampled rigid-mode correction provide stronger evidence for identifiability, convergence, or geometric recovery?
3.Are the CT and PET reference volumes strictly aligned before mismatch is introduced, and is the ground-truth transformation known and applied only to the attenuation prior?
4.Are the author-constructed PET sinograms, mismatch transformations, and evaluation references publicly available, together with the simulation pipeline?
5.How do the authors ensure that the author-designed simulation setup and baseline adaptations do not systematically favor SUGAR, and that all methods were tuned under comparable budgets and protocols?
No Authors' Response
Since I have not found the authors' responses to my concerns, I will keep my rating.