- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
AC-Diff proposes a two-stage framework for multi-vendor liver MRI harmonization. It learns anatomy–contrast representations from aligned multi-contrast acquisitions, then applies diffusion only to contrast features while reusing source anatomy features. Experiments show improved target-distribution alignment and modest downstream segmentation gains on an external dataset.
Critical strengths
- Provides a clear architectural mechanism for restricting stochastic generation to contrast features.
Critical weaknesses
- The factor-space analysis uses AC-Diff’s own encoder, while the ablations primarily establish the benefit of contrast-only diffusion.
- A baseline using TotalSegmentator-derived organ masks to condition harmonization would help assess whether learned disentanglement offers advantages over explicit anatomical guidance.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors independently evaluate anatomy–contrast disentanglement, particularly anatomical information leakage into contrast features, rather than relying on AC-Diff’s own encoder?
- Could the authors compare against a harmonization model conditioned on TotalSegmentator-derived organ masks to assess the benefit of learned disentanglement over explicit anatomical guidance?
3 comments
Thank the authors for addressing my concerns. I have raised my score to lower acceptance.
Thank you for your positive reassessment and constructive feedback, which have helped us improve the manuscript.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive suggestions. To address the concerns regarding independent validation of anatomy–contrast disentanglement and comparison with Mask-guided LDM, we conducted two additional experiments.
1. Independent Validation of Anatomy–Contrast Factorization
To assess anatomical information leakage independently of our reconstruction decoder, we froze AC-Diff checkpoint and trained separate linear and nonlinear segmentation probes on za and zc. Probes were independently trained and evaluated on AMOS22 (30/9/21 subjects) and Duke (63/13/15 subjects) using subject-disjoint splits.
AMOS22
Duke Liver MRI
Nonlinear probes consistently recover more anatomical information from za than zc, with paired Dice differences of 0.1389 (95% CI [0.1082, 0.1732]) on AMOS22 and 0.0875 ([0.0606, 0.1175]) on Duke.
However, anatomical information remains recoverable from zc. Relative to the position prior, the nonlinear zc probe improves Dice by 0.1758 ([0.1241, 0.2268]) on AMOS22 and 0.0547 ([-0.0074, 0.1162]) on Duke, with the latter difference not clearly distinguishable from zero.
Linear probes provide supplementary comparisons, although their interpretation is limited by substantial empty-slice false positives, particularly for zc.
Overall, these results support preferential anatomical encoding in za, rather than complete anatomy–contrast disentanglement. Confidence intervals were estimated by subject-level bootstrapping conditional on the fixed trained seeds.
2. Comparison with Mask-Guided Harmonization
Following the reviewer's suggestion, we implemented a Mask-guided LDM trained on our in-house multi-vendor abdominal MRI dataset, using anatomical masks extracted by TotalSegmentator MRI as conditioning inputs. We evaluated the trained model on the external Duke Liver dataset, where conditioning masks were predicted from the original Duke images without using ground-truth annotations.
Although Mask-guided LDM preserves high source-image similarity (MS-SSIM: 0.9916; PSNR: 34.57 dB), it does not improve target-domain intensity alignment over the original images (Wass. 0.1848 vs. 0.1810). In contrast, AC-Diff achieves better target-domain alignment and downstream liver segmentation performance.
These results highlight the advantage of AC-Diff over explicit mask conditioning in achieving effective target-domain alignment.
Summary
Overall, our experiments show that za contains more anatomical information than zc, although the two are not completely disentangled. The mask-guided comparison also shows that AC-Diff achieves better harmonization and downstream segmentation performance. We will include these results and discuss the remaining limitations in the revised manuscript.