- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a Compression-Aware Context Routing Network, a restoration framework that uses local degradation evidence to coordinate both contextual compensation and skipfeature selection. Specifically, a Spatial-Channel Interaction (SCI) module is proposed to derive local degradation cues and uses them to retrieve location-specific contextual prompts. These prompts are drawn from a Contextual Codebook Bank, which recursively aggregates multiscale encoder features into a compact set of image-adaptive tokens, and are injected into the decoder through efficient factorized spatial attention. In parallel, a Compression-Aware Gated Fusion (CAGF) module is designed to recalibrate skip features before fusion, suppressing artifacts while preserving reliable structural details. Extensive experiments on blind, non-blind, and double JPEG restoration benchmarks demonstrate that CACRNet achieves superior quantitative performance.
Critical strengths
A new state-of-the-art method for JPEG artifact removal on blind, non-blind, and double restoration benchmarks with superior quantitative performance.
Critical weaknesses
The novelty of the proposed method is insufficient and the proposed designs, i.e., a Spatial-Channel Interaction module and Compression-Aware Gated Fusion module, are adopted previous works in other low-level vision tasks. Compared them, author should provide the clear and detailed comparison. The core novelty and contributions should be clarified. The more discussion for recent JPEG artifact removal in related works should be provided.
Some recent works should be discussed and compared, such as [1] OAPT: Offset-aware partition transformer for double jpeg artifacts removal. ECCV 2024 [2] Blind Quality Enhancement of Compressed Video via Fine-Grained Degradation-Guided Sequential Inference. TCSVT 2026 [3] CPGA: Coding priors-guided aggregation network for compressed video quality enhancement. CVPR 2024 [4] Blind JPEG Artifacts Removal via Inverse JPEG Compression. Tcsvt 2026 [5] Compression-aware one-step diffusion model for jpeg artifact removal. ICCV 2025 [6] SODiff: Semantic-oriented diffusion model for JPEG compression artifacts removal. AAAI 2026
Questions for authors
Please view Critical Weaknesses
2 comments
Thank you for the responses and additional experiments. The authors have provided clarifications and have mainly addressed my concerns regarding novelty and the designed comparisons. These modifications should be presented in the new version. Since the original novelty is insufficient, I maintain my original rating.
Response to Question 1
Thank you for asking us to clarify the specific contributions and their relationship to existing attention and gating designs. CACRNet introduces a task-specific context construction-and-routing framework that connects contextual retrieval with skip-feature regulation. The motivation is that JPEG compression can weaken genuine structures while introducing additional local variations, making restoration dependent on both what structure is present and how compression affects it.
SCI: structure-and-distortion-conditioned contextual retrieval. Compared with directly reweighting the current feature map, SCI uses complementary G/V/D descriptors to condition decoder queries that retrieve information from an image-specific contextual bank. The computational distinction concerns both the conditioning signal and the information being selected: G/V/D describe local transitions, feature variation, and channel dispersion, while CCB supplies contextual candidates constructed from the current image’s multiscale encoder features. Compared with PromptCIR’s spatially weighted learned prompt bases, this makes the candidate content itself image-dependent. These choices organize contextual information around the structural and compression-dependent characteristics of the input.
CAGF: cross-level regulation of skip transmission. CAGF uses the decoder representation as a complementary reference when regulating encoder features. Compared with attention weights generated from the skip features alone, its cross-level conditioning accounts for the relationship between the information being transmitted and the decoder state receiving it. Relative to the backbone’s existing feature-correction pathway, CAGF adds multiplicative control before fusion, with an exponential gain that permits both attenuation and amplification.
Controlled comparisons. To evaluate these design choices, we replace SCI’s query conditioning or CAGF’s weight generator while retaining the remaining architecture and training/evaluation protocol. The results on LIVE1 at QF40 are:
Full improves over these alternatives by approximately 0.07, 0.05, and 0.10 dB, respectively. These comparisons demonstrate the restoration benefits of the proposed conditioning and skip-regulation designs over the evaluated alternatives. We have added the controlled comparisons and corresponding visualizations to the appendix.
Response to Question 2
Thank you for suggesting these relevant works. We have expanded Section 2.1 to discuss all six studies, including OAPT, IJCN, CODiff, SODiff, and the related compressed-video enhancement methods CPGA and fine-grained degradation-guided sequential inference. The added discussion summarizes their contributions to compression-aware restoration, as follows.
OAPT predicts compression offsets and groups similar compression patterns for attention-based double JPEG restoration [1]. IJCN compensates for quantization errors and color distortions through learned rounding offsets and quantization-table guidance [2]. CODiff learns compression-aware visual embeddings to guide one-step diffusion [3], while SODiff combines semantic-aligned image prompts with quality-aware timestep prediction for detail reconstruction [4]. In compressed-video enhancement, CPGA exploits coding priors to guide temporal and spatial aggregation [5], while Yu et al. [6] combine fine-grained, multiscale degradation representations with sequential inference that adapts the number of restoration stages to compression severity.
[1] Qiao Mo et al. “OAPT: Offset-Aware Partition Transformer for Double JPEG Artifacts Removal.” ECCV, 2024.
[2] Shuai Liu et al. “Blind JPEG Artifacts Removal via Inverse JPEG Compression.” IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems for Video Technology, 2026.
[3] Jinpei Guo et al. “Compression-Aware One-Step Diffusion Model for JPEG Artifact Removal.” ICCV, 2025.
[4] Tingyu Yang et al. “SODiff: Semantic-Oriented Diffusion Model for JPEG Compression Artifacts Removal.” AAAI, 2026.
[5] Qiang Zhu et al. “CPGA: Coding Priors-Guided Aggregation Network for Compressed Video Quality Enhancement.” CVPR, 2024.
[6] Li Yu et al. “Blind Quality Enhancement of Compressed Video via Fine-Grained Degradation-Guided Sequential Inference.” IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems for Video Technology, 2026.