- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GRASP, a diffusion transformer-based framework for real-world image super-resolution that balances structural fidelity and realistic detail synthesis through decoupled visual and semantic conditioning. The method introduces a Decoupled Prior Injection mechanism, combining diptych-based visual in-context completion for local structure preservation with a Vision-Context Bridge (VCB) for global image guidance. An inference-time agent iteratively refines semantic prompts, followed by Best-of-K selection. Experiments on five Real-ISR benchmarks demonstrate competitive perceptual performance, particularly on no-reference quality metrics. Ablation studies, qualitative comparisons, and a human preference study further evaluate the proposed components.
Critical strengths
-
This paper introduces a structured conditioning mechanism that separates local visual evidence, global image context, and semantic guidance into distinct information pathways. This modular design makes the roles of different conditioning sources explicit and reduces the need for additional local feature extraction networks. It provides a flexible and interpretable way to incorporate heterogeneous information into a pretrained diffusion transformer.
-
The separation between model adaptation and inference-time semantic control is appealing because it allows the generation behavior to be adjusted through prompts rather than repeated fine-tuning. Although the iterative inference process introduces substantial computational overhead, the parameter-efficient training design and flexible semantic control remain valuable technical characteristics.
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper presents agent-driven prompt refinement as a major contribution. However, the complete inference pipeline requires approximately 750.7 seconds per image, compared with only 7.7 seconds without the agent. Although the experiments demonstrate improvements across refinement rounds, they do not sufficiently establish that the agent outperforms simple repeated sampling and Best-of-K selection under the same computational budget. This raises concerns about the necessity and practical value of the proposed mechanism.
-
Introducing the agent improves no-reference quality metrics across three paired benchmarks but consistently worsens LPIPS, DISTS, and FID. While this does not necessarily indicate that the model generates incorrect details, it suggests that the paper has not sufficiently established a connection between improved perceptual quality and faithful detail restoration supported by the input evidence. This is a significant limitation for a method whose central objective is Grounded Restoration.
Questions for authors
-
The proposed inference-time strategy combines iterative agent-driven prompt refinement with Best-of-K candidate selection. Although the paper provides round-wise results, i still wonder how much of the improvement comes from semantic reasoning rather than repeated generation and candidate selection.
-
Table 1 shows that agent-driven prompt refinement consistently improves no-reference perceptual metrics while worsening LPIPS, DISTS, and FID compared with static GRASP across all three paired benchmarks. Could the authors clarify how the refined semantic prompts are constrained to avoid introducing unsupported or hallucinated details? In particular, what evidence demonstrates that the additional details are consistent with the original low-quality input rather than merely improving perceptual quality scores?
-
The proposed framework separates local visual evidence and global image context through diptych completion and the Vision-Context Bridge. However, Table 2 shows that the global-only variant achieves higher MUSIQ and LIQE scores than the full visual GRASP model. Could the authors clarify how these results support the claimed complementarity between local and global conditions?
3 comments
Thank you for the additional experiments. They have alleviated some of my concerns. My remaining concerns are the incremental value of closed-loop refinement and the strength of the fidelity claims. Matching the number of candidates does not match the computational budget. Moreover, the open-loop prompt control reported in your response to another reviewer recovers approximately 70–77% of the improvement at substantially lower runtime. These results support prompt adaptation, but provide a less compelling justification for the additional cost of sequential feedback.
The OCR improvement is encouraging. However, fixed visual conditioning and low-frequency consistency do not guarantee that synthesized high-frequency details are supported by the input. The thin-structure improvement is small without uncertainty estimates, and the 30-image audit supports only a limited non-inferiority conclusion under the specified margin. The consistent deterioration in LPIPS, DISTS, and FID therefore remains relevant; attributing it to imperfect references does not establish that the added details are faithful.
Thank the authors for the additional experiments and clarifications. The new comparison substantially addresses my concern about the incremental value of closed-loop feedback and the strength of the fidelity claims. Hence I decide to raise my rating from 2 to 3 , and I hope these experiments will be included in the final revision.
Thank you for the detailed rebuttal and additional experiments. After carefully reading all the reviews and the authors’ rebuttal, I have decided to maintain my original score.