- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the degradation process in real-world thick-slice CT super-resolution. The authors argue that conventional geometric resampling methods overlook the effect of slice thickness and therefore cannot adequately reproduce partial-volume effects. To address this issue, they introduce the Slice-Thickness Model (STM), which uses a slice sensitivity profile (SSP) to aggregate neighbouring thin slices while separately accounting for slice thickness and spacing. The proposed operator supports analytical and data-fitted profiles and can be incorporated into both supervised SR training and iterative reconstruction. Experiments on three real-paired CT datasets demonstrate improvements in degradation fidelity and SR performance over conventional interpolation operators. The authors also report improved segmentation consistency and show that STM-generated training pairs from HR-only CT data can support supervised SR.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a relevant problem in real-world CT reconstruction. STM is simple, interpretable, and applicable to different SR frameworks. The experimental improvements are substantial and reasonably consistent. The synthetic-data experiments provide additional practical value.
Critical weaknesses
- The novelty relative to existing thickness-aware degradation methods is insufficiently established. Tong (2025) already proposed a CT slice synthesis approach using normalized triangular weighting based on physical slice thickness and slice locations. The triangular SSP adopted in Eq. (7) appears mathematically equivalent to this earlier weighting scheme under corresponding parameter definitions. The physical interpretation of the SSP calibration requires further justification.
- The authors extend the formulation to alternative SSP profiles, data-driven kernel fitting, and different SR paradigms. However, these extensions mainly concern the parameterization and application of an existing degradation model rather than introducing a fundamentally new imaging mechanism.
- The claimed applicability across acquisition and reconstruction protocols is not sufficiently validated. STM uses a one-dimensional, spatially invariant SSP to approximate the formation of thick CT slices. In practice, the effective response can also depend on reconstruction kernels, scanner configurations, and acquisition geometry.
- The evaluation does not fully separate the benefits of the proposed framework from those of using a more realistic blur model. The paper introduces several SSP variants, including rectangular, Gaussian, triangular, and data-fitted profiles. However, their respective contributions to the final SR performance are not adequately investigated. A more detailed assessment of these components would help isolate the contributions beyond the fixed triangular aggregation model.
Questions for authors
- How does the triangular SSP in Eq. (7) differ mathematically from the normalized triangular weighting of Tang (2025)? If the two operators are equivalent, which specific components of STM provide the additional methodological contribution, and what existing evidence supports their individual benefits?
- Since the input thin slices already have finite thickness, how is their original through-plane response accounted for when setting ? Does represent the width of the additional aggregation kernel or the effective thickness of the synthesized slice?
- Which SSP variant is used to obtain the main quantitative results in Tables 1 and 2? For the fitted SSP, which data split is used for parameter estimation? Is the same profile applied across different scanners and acquisition protocols without further adjustment?
- Which SSP variant is used for the main results in Tables 1 and 2? Are there any existing SR reconstruction results comparing the triangular, Gaussian, rectangular, and data-fitted SSPs under the same experimental settings? Such comparisons would help clarify whether the reported improvements mainly arise from thickness-aware aggregation or from the proposed flexible SSP parameterization.