- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The author proposes DeMemSR, a diffusion Transformer framework of degraded perception, and the experiments on four real-world benchmark data sets show that DeMemSR has achieved leading performance in the quality of non-reference perception.
Critical strengths
-
The author makes a comparative experiment on four data sets, and the experiment is sufficient and convincing.
-
The author's overall writing is good, and the flow chart looks clear.
-
The visualization effect of the author in Figure 2 is better, and the details are more sufficient, and the visualization results are more pleasing to the eye.
-
The author also compares a large number of the latest comparison methods, which achieve good performance.
Critical weaknesses
-
In the initial submission of PSNR and SSIM, the author gave the corresponding results in my response.
-
I think the related work on super-resolution should provide more visual results. I have only seen the results in Figure 2, and I feel that the visualization of the three images is not sufficient.
-
Why are many indicators in Table 6 and Table 5-? Why is this? Why are these indicators not provided by the author? I hope the author will give an explanation.
4.It seems that SeeSR's performance is superior on RealSR dataset.
Questions for authors
I found that PSNR and SSIM were not used in Table 1, but they were tested in many ablation experiments. I was puzzled why the main evaluation indexes of the experiments were different. Of course, I saw that the reply given by the author supplemented the indexes.
W1 & Q1: Full-Reference Metrics
Response:
Diffusion-based super-resolution methods generally place greater emphasis on perceptual quality. Due to space limitations, we focused on no-reference perceptual quality metrics in the original manuscript.
Following the reviewer's suggestion, we have added full-reference metrics for DeMemSR and its baseline model, DiT4SR, on DRealSR and RealSR in Table 2 (page 8) of Section 4.2 of the revised manuscript.
Compared with our baseline model, DiT4SR, DeMemSR also achieves improvements in full-reference metrics.
W2: Comparisons with Simpler Alternatives for SD-LRMF
Response:
Following the reviewer's suggestion, we have added two baseline configurations:
The corresponding experimental results have been added to Table 5 (page 10) of Section 4.4 in the revised manuscript.
SD-LRMF outperforms both simpler alternatives in nearly all metrics.
W3: More Fine-Grained Ablation Studies of Key Components and Design Choices
Response:
We have conducted additional ablation studies on SD-LRMF fusion strategies and auxiliary re-degradation supervision in TDRL.
(1) Ablation Study on Auxiliary Re-degradation Supervision in TDRL
To further evaluate the contribution of re-degradation supervision to downstream super-resolution performance, we compare two training strategies:
Both strategies are evaluated using the same DAC conditioning mechanism to assess their effects on final restoration performance.
The corresponding experimental results have been added to Table 6 (page 10) of Section 4.4 in the revised manuscript.
These results demonstrate that auxiliary re-degradation supervision improves downstream super-resolution performance across nearly all reported metrics, supporting its effectiveness in TDRL.
(2) Fine-Grained Ablation Study on SD-LRMF Fusion Strategies
For SD-LRMF, we have added two simpler alternatives, fixed-weight fusion and standard residual connections, and compared them with the complete learnable layer-wise fusion strategy.
The corresponding experimental results have been discussed in detail in our response to W2.