- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper adds explicit guidance to diffusion-based super-resolution during both training and inference to improve content fidelity. It combines HR-supervised gradient guidance during training with LR observation-consistency guidance during sampling, implemented on StableSR. Evaluation uses bicubic-generated LR images from RealSR and DRealSR. Quantitative comparisons, visual examples, and ablations report improved reconstruction under this known-degradation setting.
Critical strengths
On the two test sets synthesized using bicubic degradation, the full method improves PSNR over StableSR by 6.184 and 6.571 dB, respectively, while also improving LPIPS. Relative to inference guidance alone, adding training guidance provides further PSNR gains of 0.393 and 0.383 dB, respectively, and further reduces LPIPS. Some text examples are also closer to the ground truth. These are meaningful empirical benefits.
Critical weaknesses
(1) About the central posterior interpretation and the new mechanisms
At inference time, the explicit condition is a deterministic transformation of the existing LR observation, . Consequently,
Conditioning again on this transformation therefore introduces no new posterior information. The additional nonzero guidance in Eq. (13) may serve as a data-consistency correction to an approximate conditional model, but it does not follow simply from conditioning twice on the same observation.
Moreover, DifIISR (DifIISR: A Diffusion Model with Gradient Guidance for Infrared Image Super-Resolution, CVPR25) already injects loss gradients into noise predictions during training and uses a closely corresponding normalized log-amplitude spectral loss. FGPS (Frequency-Guided Posterior Sampling for Diffusion-Based Image Restoration, ICCV25) already introduces guidance based on observation residuals filtered by a time-varying low-pass operator. The paper needs to establish the specific technical contribution of combining its training and inference stages; describing the combination as a unified framework is not sufficient.
(2) About evaluation under a known bicubic degradation
The paper states that test LR images are generated by bicubic downsampling the HR images of RealSR and DRealSR, with the same known operator used during inference. However, performance under real imaging degradations remains untested.
The comparison lacks fidelity-oriented baselines matched to bicubic degradation, such as classical 4x SwinIR, as well as controls using ordinary fine-tuning with the same budget, direct spectral-loss supervision, and existing guidance methods. The independent benefit of the proposed mechanism is therefore difficult to identify. The text examples are encouraging, but systematic content-error statistics are absent. LR consistency cannot exclude incorrect HR details in the null space of the downsampling operator, and no-reference scores exceeding those of the ground truth do not substitute for an evaluation of hallucinations.
Questions for authors
How is the nonzero guidance term in Eq. (13) justified given that adds no information beyond the existing condition ?
Are the fidelity conclusions intended to be limited to the known bicubic setting evaluated in Section 4.1?
What specific technical contribution distinguishes the proposed guidance from the training guidance in DifIISR and the inference guidance in FGPS?
Under the current bicubic test protocol, how does the method compare with classical ×4 SwinIR in reconstruction fidelity?