- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
For few-step posterior diffusion SR, a plug-in guidance method that does not require retraining the backbone is proposed. The stepwise guidance scale is obtained through LR–HR calibration, and the positive and negative directions of the guidance are used to switch between fidelity-oriented and sharpness-oriented operating points.
Critical strengths
The paper introduces a practically appealing plug-in mechanism that turns pretrained few-step posterior diffusion SR models into controllable systems without retraining the backbone. The solver-inspired perspective is interesting, and the experiments on ResShift and UPSR show a consistent ability to move between fidelity-oriented and sharpness-oriented operating points.
Critical weaknesses
The central theoretical narrative is stronger than what is ultimately justified by the inference-time algorithm: the LR-based surrogate is calibrated only in magnitude and is not shown to align directionally with the oracle correction, while the derivation also relies on a nontrivial Jacobian approximation. Moreover, the claimed continuous operating range and upper/lower bounds are insufficiently validated because the quantitative evaluation focuses mainly on two endpoint settings rather than dense control sweeps.
Questions for authors
-
The connection between the proposed guidance and a genuine second-order discretization correction is not sufficiently established. The paper itself acknowledges that \delta_t mixes prediction error, conditional uncertainty, and accumulated discretization error, while Eq. (5) additionally relies on the strong approximation J_t\approx-a_tI. Please empirically quantify the Jacobian residual and clarify which claims are exact, approximate, or purely motivational.
-
Eq. (13) calibrates only the magnitude of the LR-based gradient against the oracle discrepancy, but does not ensure directional alignment between them. Since the effectiveness of a mean-shift correction critically depends on direction, this is a missing validation. Please report per-timestep cosine similarity between the proposed LR guidance and the oracle correction, together with its variance across images and datasets.
-
Continuous-control claim. Continuous image-quality control is presented as a main contribution, yet Table 2 primarily reports the two endpoint settings LR+ and LR−. Please provide dense sweeps over s in [-1,1] and plot fidelity/perceptual metrics against s for both backbones and datasets.
-
The manuscript refers to LR+ and LR− as upper and lower bounds of attainable image quality, but the current analysis does not establish that these endpoints are extrema for the reported metrics. Different metrics may be non-monotonic with respect to the guidance strength, especially under sharpening artifacts. I suggest either providing empirical/theoretical justification for the bound interpretation or using a more conservative term such as “operating endpoints.”
-
The experiments use ResShift and UPSR, but these models share closely related posterior/residual-shifting formulations, so the evidence for generality is limited. And the sharpness-oriented mode is mainly supported by MANIQA and CLIPIQA, a broader set of perceptual metrics would substantially strengthen this claim.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive review. We apologize for the late response, which leaves little time for discussion.
Q1. Second-order connection; what is exact, approximate, or motivational. We no longer claim that the correction is equivalent to a second-order discretization correction. We claim that it targets a discrepancy that contains the discretization error, as summarized below.
Exact:
Approximate, measured:
Motivational:
What remains of the discretization link.
Jacobian sign. The approximation is now Jˉt≈ctI with ct>0. The negative slope comes only from the minus sign in Eq. 105, and the approximation is exact for the Gaussian predictor (Eq. 107).
Jacobian residual (Table 21). From the second step on, one scalar explains 35–98% of the target energy, and the band-wise slopes are positive and within 1.8× of each other. At the first step it explains about 10%; the correction there is weak but keeps the correct sign, and the applied LR correction is positively aligned for all images (Table 20).
Q2. Magnitude-only calibration and directional alignment.
Q3. Dense sweeps over s.
Q4. "Upper and lower bounds." We agree and adopted the reviewer's term. Sec. 4 (¶"Operating range") now calls LR⁺ and LR⁻ operating endpoints, and the Conclusion describes the calibrated scale as a practical end point of the control range. Tables 4–6 confirm that they are not extrema: larger scales move some metrics further, for example CLIPIQA 0.539 at 3× vs. 0.492 at 1× for UPSR, at the cost of artifacts (Fig. 10).
Q5. Generality and perceptual metrics.