- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a Super-Resolution Injection with Task-Aware Refinement (SRTAR) that effectively guides the generation of SR images beneficial to achieving satisfactory segmentation performance when processing LR images. The critical component is task-aware refinement (TAR) that enables the SR branch to acquire task-relevant discriminative knowledge from segmentation tasks and provides detail-rich features for segmentation refinement. Moreover, it proposes a mixed-quality patch stack and a trilateral fusion loss to enhance the efficacy of TAR by addressing potential problems when employing the TAR. Extensive experiments demonstrate that SRTAR achieves outstanding performance by generating SR images useful for specific task across 8 challenging object segmentation tasks.
Critical strengths
SRTAR achieves outstanding performance by generating SR images useful for specific task across 8 challenging object segmentation tasks.
Critical weaknesses
The figures in this papers are blurred; the clear figures should be presented.
The metrics should be introduced, such as S_m, F^w_beta, M, Dice. Why are there no quantitative comparisons for SwinIR, while qualitative comparisons include its results? Please explain.
SwinIR is too old for image super-resolution, the recent methods should be compared and discussed. Such as [1] Dual-Level Cross-Modality Neural Architecture Search for Guided Image Super-Resolution. TPAMI [2] Progressive Focused Transformer for Single Image Super-Resolution. CVPR [3] DiT4SR: Taming Diffusion Transformer for Real-World Image Super-Resolution. ICCV [4] CATANet: Efficient Content-Aware Token Aggregation for Lightweight Image Super-Resolution. CVPR [5] Uncertainty-guided Perturbation for Image Super-Resolution Diffusion Model. CVPR Meanwhile, some recent object segment methods should be compared and discussed, such as: [1] Semantic and sequential alignment for referring video object segmentation. CVPR [2] Referdino: Referring video object segmentation with visual grounding foundations. ICCV [3] Long-RVOS: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Long-term Referring Video Object Segmentation. CVPR [4] Lvos: A benchmark for large-scale long-term video object segmentation. TPAMI [5] Refsam: Efficiently adapting segmenting anything model for referring video object segmentation. AAAI
Questions for authors
Please view Critical Weaknesses
The author did not respond to my question, so I will keep my original rating.