- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FEDE-ControlNet for reconstructing 3D CT volumes from two orthogonal X-ray projections. The framework adapts a pretrained and frozen 3D MedDiffusion model through a trainable ControlNet branch. It combines geometry-aware back-projection of X-ray features with a multi-scale spatial-frequency encoder (FEDE) to provide volumetric conditioning features. Additionally, a multi-level volumetric feature matching loss is introduced to supervise the reconstructed CT volumes during training.
Critical strengths
Controlled comparisons with the same pretrained generative prior. The paper includes a reasonably controlled comparison with C-MedDiffusion, which shares the same pretrained diffusion backbone and geometric back-projection conditioning. The factorial ablation also evaluates the individual and combined contributions of FEDE and volumetric feature supervision. These results provide evidence that the proposed conditioning pipeline can improve reconstruction fidelity under the evaluated synthetic acquisition setting.
However, this empirical improvement does not fully address my concerns about methodological novelty and the practical significance of the reconstructed volumes.
Critical weaknesses
1. Limited methodological novelty.
The proposed framework appears to be primarily an integration of existing techniques. In particular, FEDE, which contributes most of the performance gains according to Table 2, closely follows the Frequency-Enhanced Dual-Encoding architecture in DuFal (Tran Van et al., 2026). The global and local Fourier operators, spectral-channel factorization, Galerkin attention, and frequency-domain cross-attention have direct counterparts in DuFal, including the mathematical formulations in Eqs. (6)–(10).
Although the authors acknowledge DuFal, the overlap extends to the core design of FEDE. The main adaptation appears to be lifting these features into multi-scale volumetric conditions for a pretrained diffusion model, while the ControlNet-based adaptation itself is also established. Consequently, the paper offers limited methodological novelty and does not provide substantial new insights into biplanar X-ray-to-CT reconstruction.
2. Insufficient motivation and ablation for spectral conditioning.
The motivation for using Fourier Neural Operators in this task is not sufficiently established. What specific limitations of conventional spatial features are addressed by frequency-domain processing? More fundamentally, how does extracting additional spectral information from two X-ray projections help resolve the severe depth ambiguity of 3D reconstruction?
The ablation studies only demonstrate the benefit of adding the entire FEDE module. They do not establish whether the improvements arise from Fourier processing, increased model capacity, or richer multi-scale conditioning. Comparisons with parameter-matched spatial encoders and ablations of the individual frequency components are necessary to support the proposed design.
3. Limited practical significance and lack of downstream validation.
Biplanar X-ray-to-CT reconstruction is an extremely underdetermined problem. In such settings, the practical value of reconstruction often depends on recovering specific clinically relevant anatomical information, rather than merely improving overall image similarity. For example, applications such as scoliosis assessment, anatomical segmentation, and image-guided interventions require accurate reconstruction of particular structures, geometries, or organ volumes.
However, the paper evaluates reconstruction quality almost exclusively using PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS. The qualitative results still exhibit noticeable anatomical inaccuracies, and it remains unclear whether the generated volumes are sufficiently reliable for downstream applications. Given the thoracic CT setting, evaluations such as lung/airway segmentation, organ-volume estimation, or lung-nodule preservation would provide more meaningful evidence of the method's utility.
Questions for authors
1. Spectral conditioning. Why is Fourier-domain processing particularly important for biplanar reconstruction? Can the authors provide comparisons with parameter-matched spatial encoders and ablations of the global/local Fourier branches and frequency-domain attention to isolate the benefits of spectral processing?
2. Potential pretraining–test data leakage. A serious concern is that the pretrained 3D MedDiffusion model was developed using datasets including LIDC-IDRI, which is also used for training and testing in this paper. Specifically, the original 3D MedDiffusion paper lists 1,010 LIDC-IDRI scans among its pretraining data sources, although the final training collection underwent additional filtering. The authors do not clarify whether the LIDC-IDRI test cases overlap with the pretraining data of the frozen diffusion backbone or CT autoencoder.Although the comparison with C-MedDiffusion partially mitigates this concern because both methods share the same pretrained prior, potential overlap could still affect the absolute reconstruction performance and the fairness of comparisons with other methods.
3. Downstream validity. What is the intended practical application of the reconstructed CT volumes? Can the authors demonstrate anatomical fidelity using downstream tasks such as segmentation, organ-volume estimation, or lesion preservation?
4. Reconstruction resolution and generalizability. Most experiments are conducted at only 128³ resolution, raising concerns about the preservation of fine anatomical structures. Although a 256³ experiment is included, it evaluates only FEDE without the proposed volumetric feature supervision and compares against C-MedDiffusion. Moreover, the Volume PSNR improvement decreases from approximately 0.913 dB at 128³ to 0.243 dB at 256³. While this does not conclusively establish poor scalability, it raises questions about whether the reported gains remain meaningful at higher spatial resolutions.
Additionally, all experiments use synthetic X-ray projections generated under a fixed projection geometry. Even the external LCTSC evaluation follows the same synthetic protocol. How well would the proposed method generalize to real clinical radiographs, different acquisition geometries, and potential geometric calibration errors? The current experiments provide limited evidence in this regard.
6. Completeness of comparisons. Why are closely related diffusion-based methods such as DiffuX2CT and DX2CT discussed but not included in the quantitative comparisons? Could the authors also report the additional computational cost of FEDE and the inference time of the complete framework, particularly given its 1,000-step DDIM sampling?