- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a method to adapt flow matching for sparse-angle or limited-angle CT to use the number of angles or the angular range as time variable during velocity field estimation training. The resulting method has two stages, the first producing two velocity fields (one directly pointing towards the ground-truth image, and one pointing towards the reconstruction one time-step further, i.e. with a few more angles or slightly larger angular range). Results show good performance on three different datasets, including medical and industrial datasets.
Critical strengths
Training a Flow Matching algorithm with 'number of angles' or 'angular range' as the time variable is interesting, and the results included show that predicting two velocity fields can indeed make it work. These could be valuable contributions to the field.
Critical weaknesses
- The main motivation of the paper is unclear and not valid in my opinion. The authors claim that existing flow-based and diffusion-based methods for CT are trained for a fixed geometry, but this is not true as far as I know. These method often pretrain a general generative model (denoising over time) using high-quality references and then use additional data fitting terms during generation to steer the generated image towards realistic images that fit the data. This approach is not trained for a fixed geometry, which is exactly one of the advantages of it. The second motivation, stating that linear trajectories are problematic, is unclear and not valid as well (and only true for rectified flow in any case), as the data fitting steps in between the diffusion or flow steps push the trajectory off its linear path. The paper should make a clearer case for why existing methods fall short, and how their method differs.
- The experimental setup is severely lacking in comparison methods. As a minimum, there should be comparisons with diffusion and flow-based methods that include data fitting, as these directly compare with the proposed method (see, for example, DM4CT for an overview of diffusion-based methods). Additionally, results should be compared with more baseline methods, including for example INR-based methods and/or gaussian splatting based methods,
- Overall the structure of the paper makes it difficult to read. Section 2.1 is almost a copy of the introduction, with a lot of repetitive text. Figure 2 is difficult to read without a clear caption that helps the reader through it. In Figure 1 it is not clear what is shown in the figure (what kind of trajectories, and in which space?), and the caption does not clarify things. Some claims are unclear: for example, the paper claims that the method generalizes across sparse- and limited-angle settings, but from the experiments it is not clear whether this is the case.
- Experimental details are missing, and sometimes not optimal. The used hyperparameters, how these where chosen, and how they affect results are not clearly stated. The Mayo dataset train/test split seems to be over slices and not over patients, as would be more correct. The experiments are all based on simulated noise-free data, which makes it difficult to assess how the method would perform in practice. Computation times and training times are not reported.
Questions for authors
- How does your approach compare with diffusion and flow-based method that include data-fidelity terms?
- How does your approach handle measurement noise?
- How does your method perform on real-world data?