- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
Locus is a conditional flow matching method, that first predicts a reconstruction, projects it onto an affine set that is measurement consistent, and then generates the remaining null-space residual of the forward operator. The resulting operation preserves noiseless linear measurements while using the learned prediction as the source center and also as a conditioning input. The authors theoretically relate center accuracy to displacement energy and ideal flow action, and empirically report improvements over a pixel-centered null-space flow on inpainting and super-resolution tasks.
Critical strengths
- The decomposition of the inversion task in to: "preserve, predict, generate" is sensible, and conceptually strong.
- Theory formalizes a previously heuristic design choice.
- The ablation is through and design is excellent.
Critical weaknesses
- Novelty: Paper is an extension of RN-SDE and Pixel-NFSM for flow priors.
- Ablation shows very weak improvement supplying the learned center as network input, which weakens the story.
- The scope of inverse problems is narrow. Noiseless linear measurements are a great start, but verifying results over ill-posed inverse problems with noise would have made the paper stronger and more sound.
- No computational cost analysis.
Questions for authors
- Please provide an equation-level comparison with RN-SDEs and clarify precisely which part of LOCUS and clarify which pars of LOCUS (beyond replacing the diffusion model with a flow matching model) is novel?
- Could the authors report total training compute, parameter counts, wall-clock inference time, and FLOPs?
8 comments
I thank the authors for clarifications on asked questions and formal distinction from previous approach. My main concern remains because source centering (which is the main point of the paper) produced only 0.012 dB gain in the original experiment. The new efficiency and noisy super resolution experiments sound very encouraging with interesting increase in LPIPS but PSNR suffers in more realistic conditions. The rebuttal establishes technical distinctness but does not yet demonstrate sufficiently strong novelty or broad empirical effectiveness.
Thank you for taking another look at the experiments. We agree that the 0.012 dB gain was small in the original one-step ablation, where both flows already received the learned center as input. Proposition 1 explains why a more accurate feasible center lowers the expected velocity-target energy. Our follow-up experiment tested whether changing the source also improves reconstruction at a fixed inference budget.
At the same inference budget, source centering improved PSNR by 0.884 dB in the controlled FFHQ block-inpainting experiment. We trained a fresh center and froze it for both flows. The flows shared the same architecture, initialization, conditioning inputs, and training budget. With 24 flow evaluations each, changing only the source mean raised PSNR from 29.31 to 30.19 dB. Both took about 384 ms per image, including the center call. The centered flow at 24 evaluations also outperformed the reference flow at 40 (30.19 vs. 29.39 dB) with 39.8% lower latency. The PSNR gap at equal budgets was negligible at 8 evaluations and ranged from 0.80 to 0.88 dB at the four tested budgets from 16 to 80. Across 17 large-cohort settings, the full LOCUS model improved both PSNR and LPIPS over Pixel-NSFM. That comparison includes both roles of the center.
The noisy super-resolution experiment measures what residual sampling adds once the measurement has been denoised. At a noise level of 15/255, the center alone achieved 28.63 dB. Adding the flow to the same center lowered PSNR to 28.22 dB while improving LPIPS from 0.213 to 0.160. We agree that this loss in pixel fidelity matters. Across all three noise levels, the center gave the higher PSNR, while the sampled reconstruction achieved better perceptual scores. Importantly, noisy measurements inherently contain less reliable information than their noise-free counterparts. Thus, higher PSNR should not be expected simply from introducing residual sampling into a noise-corrupted reconstruction; the relevant trade-off here is between pixel-wise fidelity and perceptual quality.
Thank you again for the thoughtful discussion and for pressing us to clarify where source centering makes a practical difference.
Dear reviewer, I'm sorry to bother you.We hope the above clarifications and the additional experiments in the revised draft sufficiently addressed your concerns. If you are satisfied, we kindly request you to consider updating the score to reflect the newly added results and discussion. We remain committed to addressing any remaining points you may have during the discussion phase.