One of the main concern is the connection between the motivation and the method remains unclear. In the current manuscript, it is not sufficiently demonstrated that the proposed method addresses the motivation, i.e., decrease crossing and increase smoothness of learnt field. Fig 3 provides evidence on a 2D toy problem, but moving a sample away from the original position of one reference does not guarantee to establish fewer conflicts among trajectories. Authors should show more analyses to bridge the gap here. Fig 3(b) indeed reports lower Lipschitz constant of learnt fields, but this does not directly quantify trajectory crossing (as claimed in the first bulletpoint at Intro). Comparing same time crossings/near-conflicts between conditional training paths before and after modification would more directly test whether CoFlow achieves its intended effect. Also, authors should show evidence beyond the toy setting, as the prevalence of near-conflicts and their reduction by CoFlow are not measured on ImageNet. Trajectory straightness or curvature, for example, the normalized flow straightness analyses in CAF [A] and VRFNO [B], time-dependent Jacobian norms or local Lipschitz estimates would help connect the toy evidence to the main generation results.
Regarding the second bulletpoint, the connection to Doob’s h-transform is overstated. The attraction–repulsion analogy is understandable, but it does not establish a direct connection between Doob h-transform formulation and CoFlow with a clear distinction: the attractive drift arises from conditioning on a terminal endpoint, whereas CoFlow designs repulsion from an intermediate reference. I’m not sure this whole standalone section in the method part about Doob’s is necessary in the current manuscript, and believe it needs to be toned down and presented as motivation.
Finally, the last bulletpoint also has a huge issue, where it claims theoretical insight into DeltaFM, but it is already present in the original paper with deriving the affine relation between the optimal DeltaFM and FM fields. The added contribution here appears to be the practical extension to CoFlow with VC. The authors should distinguish this practical extension from the existing theoretical result and revise the contribution statement accordingly.
Taken together, all three stated contributions need stronger support or more precise framing to clarify.
Another problem is concerning the equivalnce between the repulsive SDE and proposed stochastic interpolant in Appendix C, which is the key theoretical framing of the whole paper. The Gaussian reparameterization in Eq41-42 is valid for the Brownian integral at a fixed time. However, the repulsive integral depends on the state history driven by the same Brownian noise. The manuscript does not establish how this dependence is preserved when passing to the simulation-free reparameterization in Eq8. Thus, matching the Gaussian term’s marginal distribution alone does not establish the claimed marginal equivalence of the complete constructions. This part need clarification.
Regarding the experiments, there are two concerns. First, the logic/analysis and the main sampling evaluation use different dynamics, e.g., eq4 and toy experiments in Fig3 says about deterministic ODE integration, whereas the main table is regarding SDE sampling. The authors should report matched-NFE ODE results for the main table using the same trained checkpoints and evaluation settings.
Second, the OT-CFM baseline needs clarification. The OT-CFM results in Table 3 look particularly weak, even compared with standard FM. Since standard minibatch OT can perform poorly in high-dim/many-class conditional generation, as discussed in C²OT [C], the authors should examine C²OT and its experimental setup and evaluate CoFlow in that setting.
And a comment regarding presentation: Fig2 should be improved to make it self-contained. Current version is not reflecting whole concept and full comparison of two methods. For example, in the CoFlow part, the blue trajectory is not explicitly connected to the displacement producing the modified path.
[A] Constant Acceleration Flow (NeurIPS 2024)
[B] Straighten Viscous Rectified Flow via Noise Optimization (ICCV 2025)
[C] The Curse of Conditions: Analyzing and Improving Optimal Transport for Conditional Flow-Based Generation (ICCV 2025)